Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
keystonehoagies: Home
Duck Cedar Plaza 549 Rt 17. Tuxedo Park, NY 10987 845.915.3203 · Menu. Home · About · Gallery · Menu · Contact. online order qr code.png.
Keystone Hoagies | Tuxedo Park NY – Facebook
Keystone Hoagies, Tuxedo Park. 494 likes · 141 were here. Keystone Hoagies is a PA-inspired retro hoagie, grinder and cheesesteak place with fresh-cut…
Keystone Hoagies, 549 Route 17, Tuxedo Park, NY 10987, US
Keystone Hoagies is a local eatery in Tuxedo Park, NY, offering a delectable selection of hoagies, wings, and catering options for special occasions.
Reviews
Ian Isaiah
I just happened to be hungry and in the area so I searched “food” and Keystone Hoagies was the first thing to pop up. I drove over expecting a small sandwich shop but to my surprise, there’s also a bakery here.
From the moment I walked in, the service was exceptional and the restaurant has a warm atmosphere.
Second surprise came when I ordered the shrimp Po boy expecting a small sandwich, the sandwich was huge and delicious! Also ordered a ginger limeade and a snickerdoodle cookie. 10/10 will be back and would recommend. I’m so happy I was hungry in the area and happy that I decided to give this place a chance.
… moreFrom the moment I walked in, the service was exceptional and the restaurant has a warm atmosphere.
Second surprise came when I ordered the shrimp Po boy expecting a small sandwich, the sandwich was huge and delicious! Also ordered a ginger limeade and a snickerdoodle cookie. 10/10 will be back and would recommend. I’m so happy I was hungry in the area and happy that I decided to give this place a chance.
Jordan Peak
This place is a gem of the area! Everything is outstanding. I have yet to try the whole menu but that’s a goal. We go out of our way & plan trips around stopping in here. 10 stars!
… moreClark
Excellent food and service! Wish we lived locally so we could eat here all the time! Portions big enough to share. Hoagies served on fresh baked bread. Try the Italian market grinder!
… moreJamie o’connell
Steak and cheese is what they recommended and that’s what I got and I’m glad I did. Delicious! Coffee is fairly tasty too.
Surprised it didn’t come out on a plate, but do we really need a plate…
… moreSurprised it didn’t come out on a plate, but do we really need a plate…
Ashley Graham
I think I got the wrong sub and didn’t like the combo. The food was good, but I’d have to try another sandwich to be sure.
But that might just be an excuse to go back…
… moreBut that might just be an excuse to go back…
Christopher B Smith
Awesome place! Loved my sandwich I got. However what I enjoyed most was the reaction of the owner when one in our group asked what was the best sandwich. He didn’t say this but the look on his face was like ‘these are all my babies’. And that attitude certainly showed in the quality of the food, everyone said their food was great!
… morebyReza byReza
TERRIBLE in every meaning of the word. I ordered the salmon burger and a side of fries. I had to spit the first bite of the salmon out fear of falling ill with food poisoning. The buns tasted as if fried in butter. The french fries soggy and old.
… moreNicholas Pelligra
Keystone Hoagies has a pretty awesome selection of hot and cold sandwiches. They have a vegan option called Phoebe Food that consisted of fried chickpeas, lettuce, and hummus and was very delicious. Service was great and the location is very clean and modern. They also have two vegetarian sandwich options.
… moreJordan Salit
Every sandwich I have tried has been a joy to eat. Had a causal afternoon date here and sat outside. I had the Polish Hammer (Kielbasa, Pierogis, Kraut, Onions and Mustard) , She had the CAB Roast Beef (Angus beef, Roasted garlic spread, Roasted red peppers). The sandwiches were layered with flavor, with each bite you tasted the fresh ingredients and love that went into the meal. Can’t get enough of the hand cut fries. It’s a pleasure to eat here.
… moreMatt McCann
Next door and owned by the awesome (I’ve rated 5 stars) Dottie Audrey’s. The bread is extremely fresh and the place is very unique inside. Our hoagies were delicious, all 5 of us enjoyed our meal. This is without a doubt a repeat place, however it’s going to be hard to choose this over Dottie Audrey’s. The only competition is themselves, which is highly impressive.
… more