Johnny’s New York Style Pizza

  4.1 – 1,706 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

Johnny’s Pizza Douglasville is proud to bring authentic, great-tasting New York Style Pizza and a variety of housemade dinners, craft beers, subs and more to the neighborhoods we call home. Our dough is made fresh daily, never frozen, hand-tossed and topped with the best ingredients we can find – premium mozzarella and parmesan cheeses, fresh-packed tomatoes, hand-cut veggies, and Italian sausage and beef with no fillers. Then each pizza is brick-oven baked until it’s golden brown, always with our signature soft and crispy crust, and served hot at your table. Dine-in or order online for takeout or delivery! Visit us today directly across Chapel Hill Rd. from the Target Shopping Center.

Family-friendly pizza chain with New York-style pies, submarine sandwiches & calzones.

✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery Johnny's New York Style Pizza 30135

Hours

Thursday11 AM–9 PM
Friday11 AM–10 PM
Saturday11 AM–10 PM
Sunday11 AM–9 PM
Monday11 AM–9 PM
Tuesday11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday11 AM–9 PM

Address and Contact Information

Address: 2911 Chapel Hill Rd Suite 225, Douglasville, GA 30135

Phone: (678) 214-8486

Website: https://www.johnnyspizza.com/location/douglasville/

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Order: Order online

places.singleplatform.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Douglasville | Georgia | Johnny’s New York Style Pizza

Indulge in authentic New York-style pizza at Johnny’s Pizza Douglasville. Located at 2911 Chapel Hill Road, our neighborhood pizzeria is been serving fresh, …

Johnny’s New York Style Pizza | Douglasville GA – Facebook

Johnny’s New York Style Pizza, Douglasville. 1708 likes · 7 talking about this · 6797 were here. With our pizza perks, earning dough is easy! Join…

Johnny’s New York Style Pizza | Restaurant | Georgia

Johnny’s Pizza Franchise Systems sells its franchises in the state of Georgia. Come visit your neighborhood pizzeria restaurant!

Reviews

Jake Smith
Food that we got was good, garlic knots and meat pizza medium, from seat down to food (and we didn’t know what we wanted, since we never eaten here) toke about 30 minutes in dinning room. Server was nice and friendly only reason i gave what I did By 740 I still not have my flat bread pizza I ordered. I just canceled my pizza I wanted to try. In that 40 minutes a man was very loud about a pizza he ordered through uber eats (we heard him across restaurant) he was trying to get other customers to get upset and load too, these made me very nervous, I worry about folks like that and guns, also in that time I seen a Small dog (with out a service harness) walk in with a customer never seen the leave, but may have out another door. Inside is okay needs some tlc Even with the offer of free knots for a 5 star review I could not honestly do that because of the all the bad, and I don’t think I would recommend these place.
… more
Margaret Hill
Amazing food i have to be gluten free and i love their gluten free pizzas! Also had the BEST MARGARITA ever in my life here! I was told that margaritas were the bartender on duty’s specialty so I had to try it and it did not disappoint! I am tequila girly and I love margaritas! 10 out of 10 highly recommend
… more
Mrs. Smith
My friend and I decided to grab a bite here last night (Nov 15). The garlic knots, while having a good flavor, were doughy and dense. The bruschetta dip had thick slices of a hard to melt cheese placed on top of halved, oblong tomatoes over a generous layer of ricotta cheese. It (the dip) was served with fried crispy flatbread that was cut into triangles; the ones that weren’t super greasy were pretty good with a nice crunch.

I ordered a veggie calzone. I was told by our server, Courtney, that it would be cut into three pieces. It was not, but I wish it had been. It may have allowed some of the moisture to escape before it was served to me. The bulk of the green and black olives were concentrated heavily in the middle and one side of the dish. And I guess they didn’t drain them before putting them in the dough because it was so soggy on one side, the “crust” fell apart when I tried to pick it up. The one piece of it I could actually pick up and eat normally was doughy and dense just like the garlic knots. I ordered the “drunk witch” from the fall drink list with the encouragement of our server. It tasted like Act mouthwash. I told Courtney I didn’t like it. She said the regular bartender wasn’t there, so the owner made it. She took the drink and returned a couple minutes later apologizing and saying she didn’t know the owner has “no refunds or exchanges on drinks” policy (though later she told us the owner had “cursed out a old couple because they told him they didn’t like their drinks” and wouldn’t give them new drinks or their money back). It’s worth noting that it’s not written/posted anywhere that I noticed.

My friend ordered wings and a flatbread pizza. The wings were edible, yet almost completely devoid of any flavor. The flatbread pizza arrived so long after the rest of the food, we nearly forgot about it and just took it to go.

Overall, the food was sorely disappointing. I would recommend going elsewhere. We didn’t even want to take our leftovers and there was PLENTY left over. (See photos. Napkin on plate was to soak up liquid. I used a FEW.)
… more
C D
I had a very disappointing experience at this location. I came in July to order several pizzas for an event and specifically requested that the crust not be burnt and that there be no black burnt cornmeal on the bottom. The first box looked great — exactly what I asked for. But when I opened the second, it was the complete opposite: saturated with oil, covered in burnt cornmeal, and visually unappetizing. It honestly looked like the box was used to scrape out the oven.

When I brought this to the manager’s attention, she was dismissive and said she saw nothing wrong with the pizza and that the new one would likely look the same — yet she offered to remake it. That comment made no sense, especially because the first pizza clearly proved it could be made correctly. At that point, it felt like she simply didn’t want to assist me or acknowledge the issue.

This particular location has a history of pizzas coming out like this, but since it’s the closest one to me, I always specify no burnt cornmeal. Sadly, it seems oven cleanliness and quality control just aren’t prioritized here.

When I asked for some type of accommodation for the delay and inconvenience — given that waiting would cause the other pizza to become cold and potentially make us late — I was told the only options were a remake or a refund. Her tone remained dry, dismissive, and completely lacking in empathy or customer care. So I requested a full refund and went to Fabiano’s instead, where the service and pizza were significantly better.

Side note: I contacted the VP and he apologized and said a gift card would be mailed to me to use at another location, and that he would address this with the branch manager. I provided photos, video, and the name of the manager I spoke with as he requested. He agreed it was unacceptable and hates to hear that they are losing a customer to a competitor. He also agreed that other accommodations should have been made….burbling story short and months later, the gift card never arrived.

I tried to resolve this privately and professionally and would not have posted a negative review if the promised resolution had been fulfilled. Unfortunately, it never was.

**UPDATE: The response below from Johnny’s is not accurate. The issue was never resolved to my satisfaction. I spoke directly with VP Scott Allen, who confirmed on his cell phone that he received my photos, videos, name, and address — and the message even shows as “read” (have him check his cellphone ending in **44 on 7/28/25 at 5:20pm). I do not wish to provide my information again. The matter was never corrected, and I remain a very unsatisfied customer. I rarely leave negative reviews, but I believe in being honest — good or bad — and others deserve to know my experience.
… more
Ratchadaporn McQuade
This is the best pizza around the area and I ordered take outs once or twice a month. I give 4 stars because sometime it came out perfect, other times, quite salty.
… more
B G
Had three pies a cheese, meat and chicken with white sauce.

The cheese was the best. Meat pizza was decent yet lacked enough cheese.

The chicken with white sauce was awful my wife bit into a piece of gristle. Yes your subject to pieces of bones I get it.

Yet they do not check the bird meat before putting it into the pie?

Would have earned 4 stars if not for the mishap with the white sauce chicken pie.

Management said they’d reach out. I’m still waiting to hear from them.
… more
Just E
Most of the time I enjoy the food here. The pizza is good most times and the salad is always fresh. I like the calzones more than anything, but it’s hit or miss. Maybe it depends on who makes them. I’ve had perfect calzones that remind me of the ones I got in NY. Some days the calzones lack ricotta and are so greasy it’s inedible. I would love to see the food items be more consistent because when it’s good, it’s really good.
… more
Danette Cius
We came for trivia night, but unfortunately, it was postponed. By far, this place has the best buffalo chicken dip ever! Every time we come, we always get the dip, and it just keeps getting better! We also had gotten Johnny’s Meat Deluxe Calzone. Unfortunately, it looked mouth-watering, so I forgot to take a picture beforehand . But it was amazing! If you pulled it apart, you could see the cheese just melty and oozing apart! We’ll be back!
… more
Mystery animates
Great food and service, everyone is always so nice, and I make a point of stopping by whenever I’m in town. Genuinely such a nice place to stop by at, often very chill, and great if you want to take some friends out for good pizza and drinks.
… more
Krystal McMath
We had an amazing experience at the Johnny’s Pizza in Douglasville. My baby was hungry and cried a lot and no one made me feel bad about it. Our server, Bree was very accommodating and helpful! We loved our experience here!
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment