Monica Lucid
A friend and I went in the early afternoon and it was slow and quiet. The food was excellent, as I remember. He was really happy with his Beef Wellington.
… moreRichard J. Oberle
I am not a steak eater but my friend said his steak was one of the best he ever had. I am not a steak eater myself and choose the channel #5 meal. The sauce was to die for but it was not the best pasta dish of my life. Was it good? Yes very. Next time I will try something else. House salad was excellent.
… moreCuma UGUR
Best steak I’ve ever had! The staff was incredibly kind and welcoming, always smiling. The service was fast and professional. Steaks were cooked to perfection—real quality meat. Great music and cozy atmosphere made the whole experience even better!
… moreIna Murphy
We had such an amazing experience at this place. Our server Zay was wonderful and very caring and really enjoyed having Zay as our server. The food was exceptional! I am so impressed with the quality and the taste. The berry martini and raspberry limoncello drinks were so refreshing and delicious. I had the veal medallions with shrimp and crabmeat. Out of body experience! Just fantastic. Their marinera sauce that came with calamari is amazing and the most delicious marinera I ever had. We are so pleased and satisfied with our experience at Johnny’s Italian Steakhouse! I would give 10 starts if I could. Also, I am very picky about my food and service. So that says a lot!
… moreSimon Crapo
Great meal. I had the beef Wellington. I wish it was left uncut and had the chance to cut it myself. But overall very good.
The artichoke dip was fantastic. Good Moscow mule. I would come back here.
… moreSunera Rahman
so im going to give an honest review. i dined in here tn. Sunday, Aug 31st 2025 at like 7:45PM. sure there were major issues with the side dish… but the entree did make up for that significant problem. the steak trio omfg, delicious and made perfectly. the server suggested this and omg it was so good. im from canada and exploring all the restaurants here…i paid way more money at en vino for a lower quality steak meal. this was the best steak ive had since moving here. toppings were amazing.
with that being said. the ambience needs work. the interior needs new everything. tables have scratches and holes. menus have scratches, markings, and look ancient. cuterly seems old, lots of markings. if ya’ll renovated and updated, this would have potential to be top notch for middleton for sure.
… moreRocky Stark
Service was amazing, server took our order and left us alone to eat but food was sub par. Don’t let the plate appeal fool you on quality.. First and last time here
… morePaige Zugin
Johnnys Italian steakhouse is my favorite go-to restaurant when we feel like eating out! Service is excellent and food is always amazing, steaks are always cooked properly. I haven’t tried one thing I don’t like yet! They have the perfect portion sizes and every entree comes with a side and salad! 10/10 recommend!
… moreSydney Moyers
Owen is the best server I’ve had at this restaurant so far. He is so kind, respectful, and professional. His service is top tier and he makes the best drinks at the bar. He is also so funny and I love having him every time I come in.
… moreCharee Peters
We go here for my partner’s birthday almost every year. He loves the steaks and we enjoy the atmosphere. We finally tried the mini beef wellington and it was amazing. It can be a bit expensive but it’s nice for a celebration. The staff are always great!
… more