Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4260 S Tamiami Trl, Venice, FL 34293
Phone: (941) 493-1515
Website: https://www.johnnytomatoespizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Johnny Tomatoes Pizza | Discover Your New Favorite Pizza – Order …
Johnny Tomatoes Pizza in Venice serves authentic New York Style Pizza, delicious wings, and garlic knots, order todat!
Johnny Tomatoes Pizza | Venice FL – Facebook
Johnny Tomatoes Pizza . New York style pizza right here in Venice, Florida! Pizza place · (941) 493-1515. . Follow …
Food Menu – Johnny Tomatoes
Chicken Vodka. $12.95. Chicken cutlet, vodka sauce & fresh mozzarella ; Italian Cold Cut. $11.95. Salami, prosciutto, ham, pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, & red …
Reviews
Naomi
Delicious and worth a try… you will not be disappointed! The pizza is one of the best in the area. I’ve had both regular and Sicilian pies. I always ask for my pizza to be lightly cooked, and they are exactly to my liking when I pick them up. Their meatballs are also some of the best around. Also tried a caprese sandwich which was quite tasty. I chose to warm it in the toaster oven at home to melt the cheese and warm the bread, but you don’t have to do that. And the mini cannolis are to die for! The cannolis are filled once ordered so the shells are crunchy when you get them. Both the shells and cream have perfect flavor. In fact a friend who doesn’t like cannolis tried one and wound up eating a second one as well as scraped the container to eat any remaining cream. I’m looking forward to trying additional items on their menu as well as continuing to eat their pizza. This is a family-run business, and the owners are incredibly friendly. So glad they chose to locate their establishment here!
… moreSusan Byrne
Hey, it’s Florida, I wasn’t expecting great pizza. I’m a Jersey girl. This pizza was great! Will definitely go back next time I’m in Florida!! My salad was so good too! I think it was just called the Italian salad, delish!! I’m a fan of Johnny Tomatoes!
… moreZOM BEACH
At first they made a mistake and made our pizza without any cheese at all and we were a little disappointed, but they immediately got another pizza in the over exactly how we wanted and also gave us a refund, and wouldn’t take no for an answer, so we accepted the refund and ordered another pizza to share with friends and family. The pizza we got was perfect, absolutely delicious, the original pizza is great too 🙂
… moreAustin Rumancik
Yummy New York style pizza! Thin crust but still just a bit of chew, no flop, and a solid undercarriage, what more could you ask for… Whole family enjoyed the buffalo chicken pizza too!
… moreMatt Harwood
Great pizza isn’t hard to find around here, but exceptional pizza is rare for me since I don’t eat a lot of things others do. The folks at Johnny Tomatoes are doing it right! From the second you walk in the door, the experience is welcoming and pleasant. The pizzas we’ve had have been perfect! The garlic knots are pretty amazing too! No garlic powder here, only fresh, real garlic. If a place uses fresh garlic instead of powder on their bread, you know their other ingredients are equally top notch!
… moretmaug 1974
Omgosh! This pizza is amazing! It is extremely close to the pizza I’ve eaten when visiting family in NJ. I personally ask them to not put the grated Romano cheese on it, and it’s perfection! The calzone was delicious too! I’ve had it 3 times now, and it’s consistently the best!
… moreMike P
Some of the best pizza we’ve had. We got bbq chicken, lasagna and vodka sauce pizza (with onions). Highly recommend and delivery was quick!
… moreJoy Tancey
We love pizza and tried Johnny Tomatoes tonight. To say it was delicious is an understatement! They were hot, fresh ingredients and the flavors were so good! This is our new go-to pizza place. I can’t remember a better pizza! Keep up the excellent work, Johnny! Addy, thanks for the great service! You are a definite asset to the team! See you soon ❤️ ❤️
… moreShawn Clugsten
Dude all I can say is wow. This pizza is a game changer. In Venice, FL? Go see Johnny Tomatoes. You want NJ? You want NY? you want MI? You want BUFFALO GARLIC KNOTS W BLUE CHEESE? LASAGNA PIZZA? LIMONCELLO CAKE? Dude. Try this pizza today. Not a paid actor just a fat guy who TORE UP HIS PLATE
… moreDavid V
They just opened and the food was good. Can’t wait to see how much it improves over the next few weeks and months. Cant wait to order again!
Two pizza and 20oz soda combo is a heck of a lunch deal!!
… moreTwo pizza and 20oz soda combo is a heck of a lunch deal!!