Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
No-frills, order-at-the-counter pizzeria with an auxiliary menu of subs, wings, pasta & gyros.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 345 Amherst St, Buffalo, NY 14207
Phone: (716) 447-0165
Website: https://www.joesnewyorkstylepizza.com/?utm_source=gbp
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Joe’s New York Style Pizza – Buffalo, NY – 345 Amherst St – Hours …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Joe’s New York Style Pizza in Buffalo, NY. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Joe’s New York Style Pizza – 345 Amherst St, Buffalo, NY 14207 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Buffalo, NY! Joe’s New York Style Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Joe’s New York Style Pizza Reviews | Buffalo, New York – One Bite
Order Joe’s New York Style Pizza. Hungry? Order right now on Slice. Order now on Slice. About Joe’s New York Style Pizza. Powered by. Yelp Rating.
Last Updates
Reviews
Synergy Fitness
I’m looking for authentic NYC style pizza. Buffalo style pizza is terrible. They’ve tried to blend the best of both worlds and you can see it I their crust. They’ve done a great job in blending hometown Buffalo style with NYC. I appreciate the effort! Joes is excellent nonetheless! It comes very close to NYC style pizza for being in Buffalo. I can say they are good and among the places here in Buffalo, they’ve done a great job! Their Stromboli and stuffed pizza is on point as well!
… morekenny p
Disappointed! Spent $50 for 2 large NY style pies.. Not a NY style pizza. No crisp bottom on the pizza, very chewy, oil soaking through the box. Don’t think it was cooked thoroughly
.It was a Sunday, not busy. They should take the time and do it right. Customer service was good, friendly cashier. It’s unfortunate but I would rather go to Costco for pizza.
… more.It was a Sunday, not busy. They should take the time and do it right. Customer service was good, friendly cashier. It’s unfortunate but I would rather go to Costco for pizza.
DP
Father son owned pizzeria, holding it down in black rock for a decade, quality slices and staff! Keep local pizza thriving!
… moreNeal Jones
I’m Not from Buffalo and finding “Real” Pizza was a chore. After sampling many others, I was lucky enough to find Joe’s.
If you are from NYC or Long Island and what a taste of home, this is the only Place you need. Everything is good. A variety of Pizza styles. But their Cheese is so good. I have tried to make my own as anyone from NYC area knows there is nothing like Our Pizza. If you want a slice that tastes like Brooklyn, Look no further. Enjoy. I Love it so much, I get a slice while I wait for a pie.
… moreIf you are from NYC or Long Island and what a taste of home, this is the only Place you need. Everything is good. A variety of Pizza styles. But their Cheese is so good. I have tried to make my own as anyone from NYC area knows there is nothing like Our Pizza. If you want a slice that tastes like Brooklyn, Look no further. Enjoy. I Love it so much, I get a slice while I wait for a pie.
Meng Thao
Good restaurant inside town more. The pizza was great! Good NY pizza. The spaghetti with meat ball was awesome! We eat everything.
Bathroom was out of toilet paper but got some from the cashier.
Price for the pizza is on the higher end. Spaghetti price is average.
… moreBathroom was out of toilet paper but got some from the cashier.
Price for the pizza is on the higher end. Spaghetti price is average.
Tyler “The Mealtime Maverick”
As a part of our two-week vacation to the states, we drove and spent the day in Buffalo, New York. We had one thing in our sights. The thing that New York is famous for more than anything else… New York style-pizza.
Dad found a pizzeria that fit our criteria (high rating, big parking lot, and not downtown). Its name was Joe’s New York Style Pizza.
We walked in at 1:30 in the afternoon, and our sights were set on two types of pizza: cheese, and pepperoni. We got about 6 slices in total. I hate to say this, but it was just regular pizza. The cheese was far better than the pepperoni. I’m going to give the cheese a 7.8/10 and the pepperoni a 6.8/10. The pepperoni was too spicy. I do acknowledge that we got slices ALREADY made. Maybe, we should’ve asked them to make us a fresh pizza.
I made a little discovery, too. It’s a drink called Loganberry from the brand Crystal Beach. The label explains the brand was inspired by an amusement park on the shores of Lake Erie. Loganberry combines the flavour of ripe blackberries and red raspberries. To me, it had a pomegranate flavour. It’s very close to the taste of Fruitopia Integration. I’ll give Loganberry a 7.5/10.
This experience was a reminder that in the food world, you’re not going to love everything you try. But, through this process of elimination, you filter out the stuff you don’t like; and therefore, are left with what you do like.
… moreDad found a pizzeria that fit our criteria (high rating, big parking lot, and not downtown). Its name was Joe’s New York Style Pizza.
We walked in at 1:30 in the afternoon, and our sights were set on two types of pizza: cheese, and pepperoni. We got about 6 slices in total. I hate to say this, but it was just regular pizza. The cheese was far better than the pepperoni. I’m going to give the cheese a 7.8/10 and the pepperoni a 6.8/10. The pepperoni was too spicy. I do acknowledge that we got slices ALREADY made. Maybe, we should’ve asked them to make us a fresh pizza.
I made a little discovery, too. It’s a drink called Loganberry from the brand Crystal Beach. The label explains the brand was inspired by an amusement park on the shores of Lake Erie. Loganberry combines the flavour of ripe blackberries and red raspberries. To me, it had a pomegranate flavour. It’s very close to the taste of Fruitopia Integration. I’ll give Loganberry a 7.5/10.
This experience was a reminder that in the food world, you’re not going to love everything you try. But, through this process of elimination, you filter out the stuff you don’t like; and therefore, are left with what you do like.
john kindred
The steak stromboli was absolutely garbage it was so greasy you couldn’t even pick it up and the green peppers & onions were so undercooked
… moreEntVids
I have never eaten real NY pizza until this week. Very glad we chose this restaurant to experience it. Being from down south, it’s almost impossible to find pizza like this. Some of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. Very friendly staff!
… moreJo Go
Authentic New York-style pizzas can be found at Joe’s New York Style Pizza. We got our slices on May 11th, 2024.
The pizza is thin, the crust is crispy, and the slices are those classic large triangles. The best for us was the cheese pizza. We don’t usually crave a plain cheese on tomato sauce pizza in Toronto, but Joe’s changed our minds. It’s never smelled or tasted this good. When you go to New York, a thin crust cheese slice is a must, and Joe’s does it right.
There are other pizza slices to tempt you in the glass enclosure, and you should try them to compare, but the cheese slice wins every time. Oh, and you’ve got to eat it folded — like a real New Yorker.
Joe’s restaurant isn’t fancy, but it’s clean. The service is good, the price is reasonable, and they also deliver to the surrounding area. But if you’re like us, you’ll cross the Canadian border if you’re in the Niagara region to get it.
Highly recommend.
… moreThe pizza is thin, the crust is crispy, and the slices are those classic large triangles. The best for us was the cheese pizza. We don’t usually crave a plain cheese on tomato sauce pizza in Toronto, but Joe’s changed our minds. It’s never smelled or tasted this good. When you go to New York, a thin crust cheese slice is a must, and Joe’s does it right.
There are other pizza slices to tempt you in the glass enclosure, and you should try them to compare, but the cheese slice wins every time. Oh, and you’ve got to eat it folded — like a real New Yorker.
Joe’s restaurant isn’t fancy, but it’s clean. The service is good, the price is reasonable, and they also deliver to the surrounding area. But if you’re like us, you’ll cross the Canadian border if you’re in the Niagara region to get it.
Highly recommend.
Cindy G.
Wonderful food and service! so many options for the whole family! Best pizza and Stromboli I’ve ever had! We had spinach Stromboli, meat lover Stromboli, pepperoni pizza and the huge lasagna! Nice little view of the town from inside as well
… more