Conor Cook
I visited the Crystal Lake Jimmy John’s on Monday, October 20th, 2025. This was my first time back to the Crystal Lake location in months but I have always loved this chain of food. My sandwich was really good and it is highly recommended to order online, it is super quick. I also got the giant sandwich this time and it was super good! I had a great evening off work where I just got to enjoy myself and nothing better than JJ’s to do so. The staff were friendly, respectful and good at their job. I am sure I will be back soon! (Written 10-27-25)
… moreMagdalena F
Jake gets to seal of approval what a freaky fast. Two sixteen-inch bootleggers.
Done in two minutes with a skeleton crew on Memorial Day.
Literally an army of one.
Highly recommend
… moreAdam DeLay
These guys work.
We have ordered from these guys more than once now, mainly for catering. Each time we order they get it right and are you on time. Even with only a few hours notice.
We have a few option when it comes to ordering subs, but we really enjoy what this shop offers in goods and services.
… moreJillyan
Jimmy johns is my go-to sandwich shop. I especially love the new toasted options. Staff is always friendly and efficient.
… moreBee Bee
I asked for avacado . And payed for it extra and they put such cheap amount .. just a little tiny Swab in the middle .. why are we paying extra . Might as well make it free . I’m very disappointed.
… moreJess Miller
This Jimmy John’s is the best one in town. The sandwiches are fresh and fast. The store is clean and well lit, and the employees are always friendly.
… moreChuck G
The best Jimmy John’s out there! Great staff, great food. Always a pleasant experience and the place is kept clean. these employees deserve raises as they are always super friendly even when it’s mad busy!
… moreThe Layla
I’ve had issues twice with orders being late. I don’t mind waiting a couple minutes but I only have a certain amount of time at work to eat my lunch so it’s a bit disappointing that it gets here 20-30 minutes past my lunch time. Besides that sandwiches are good.
… moreSamuel Rail
I wanted to give this place the benefit of the doubt. We had a bad experience with them last time were sandwiches were wrong and it took an hour longer then said. Today we ordered lunch for our entire shop seven sandwiches at 11:15 AM to make sure we could have it here by noon. We tried calling they did not answer so we just drove down there to pick them up and they are not even done with the order yet the time now is 12:52 PM. This place is bad. I do not recommend at all go somewhere else if you wanna sandwich
… moreDoc Z
The other Saturday, I worked all morning, missed lunch, but had to make the 4:03 train out of Pingree. I was going to get to the station about 10 minutes early, but was SOOOO hungry, my stomach felt like acid! I needed something, but didn’t want to cut it too close. I figured I would stop at J.J.’s for a togo sammie. I pulled in to the lot and parked my car at 3:48 pm. I ordered my #12 paid and was back on Rt. 31 at 3:50 pm. You guy’s saved the DAY!!!
How was the food?…pretty darn good!
FREAKY FAST???…definitely!!!
… more