Vicki Otto
First of all…if you call yourself “Jersey” Mike’s….then step up, “Jersey” subs are not split in half….when someone asks for red hots on the side you DO NOT give them a container of hot sauce ….i mean really ??? You have a lot to learn & also an Italian sub doesn’t use pepperoni…and the workers could be nicer instead of bullshitin be professional, and I am from the Jersey Shore so I know first hand what goes in a sub. Read up on it.
… moreJohn Cleary
My sub two days ago was drowned in oil and vinegar (Mike’s way). If people like soft and soggy bread they should have it as a part of their breakfast as cereal.
… moreDave Walker
My girlfriend got me to Jersey Mike’s Danny DeVito couldn’t do it but my girlfriend sure was able to and it’s been fantastic and the store in Mayfield Heights the manager is Josh they are so overwhelmingly helpful and want to make sure your meal is right they’ve done a fantastic job the last four or five times I’ve been there I just want to say Kudos fantastic job Mayfield Heights Jersey mike’s!
… moreEd Crosby
Great Subs fresh cut delicious delis meat good buns great vegetables. You like peppers you must try there pepper relish. Be sure to get extra napkins helpful staff
… moreK. Taylor
Ordered on the app, picked it up, and headed to the park.
Easy app ordering and payment.
Order was ready, on time, and accurate.
I got the Big Kahuna minus the jalapenos. My wife had a bowl version.
Everything was as it should be.
… moreScott Reno
The cheese steaks was pretty good but for the price, there are much better options…$20+ for one.
… moreSheri P.
I ordered a VERY large lunch catering order for delivery to Mayfield Heights. I worked with Josh at Jersey Mikes to place my order. He was outstanding to work with!! He made sure every detail of my order was correct and he followed up with me immediately for additional questions I had. The food was excellent and exactly what I had ordered. I really appreciate the great service provided by Josh and the staff. Everyone was very friendly and helpful. I would highly recommend ordering catering from this location for any occasion. The catering boxes come with everything you need and would be perfect for company lunches, parties or holiday gatherings. I will be ordering from them again soon.
… moreSpacey Stacey
So delicious, made in front of me, and was a decent size, not like other cheesesteak sandwiches I’ve had, I’m talking about Arby’s puny cheesesteak, this more than enough for me and my husband
… moreGoldie Burrows
I am handicapped and they literally made me stand there for two regular small sandwiches while they did a eight sandwich order in front of me and didn’t give any regards for our lunch break time they should have somebody separately doing the orders for doordash not having people stand in line for 20 minutes to get a sandwich they were very unorganized with it people walking around with two sandwiches in hand just walking around with them running into each other it was just really the worst service I ever had at one of the Jersey Mike’s stores not sure I will come back to this location
… moreSiobhan Adams
I am sitting in the parking lot writing this review from last night as I crave another sub. Yesterday I visited another location, cheating on this one (shhh). I knew something was wrong when I did not smell the wonderful flavors when I walked through door. Needless to say, I left an immediately called this store. The person who answered the phone arrange to take my order over the phone and allowed me to pick it up after little bit after closing. This is the only Jersey Mike’s that actually smells amazing when you walk in. The customer service is top tier, and the food has me coming back the next morning for the same sub I ate last night. Thank you for all that you do reminding us that Covid did not kill all of the restaurant industry.
… more