Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Jersey Mike’s, a fast-casual sub sandwich franchise with more than 2,500 locations open and under development nationwide, has a long history of community involvement and support. Started at the Jersey Shore in 1956, Jersey Mike’s serves authentic East Coast-style subs on fresh baked bread – the same recipe it started with over 60 years ago. The company’s mission is to bring its customers the highest quality, freshest made sub in the industry and give back to the communities in which it operates.
New Jersey–based counter-serve sandwich chain serving jumbo subs filled with cold cuts & toppings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1213 Hill Rd N, Pickerington, OH 43147
Phone: (614) 863-3316
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sub and Sandwich Shop in Pickerington, Ohio – Jersey Mike’s
1213 Hill Road North Pickerington, OH 43147 An image of a telephone receiver (614) 863-3316 Store Hours: Open 7 Days: 10 AM – 9 PM
Jersey Mike’s Subs – Visit Fairfield County
Stop inside Jersey Mike’s Subs on Hill Road in Pickerington, Ohio or order for pickup or delivery today! Print This Listing …
Jersey Mike’s Subs – Menu
Mike’s Hot Italian. Ham, salami & pepperoni with melted provolone cheese. Topped with grilled onions, lettuce, tomato and Hot Chopped Pepper Relish.
Reviews
Ben Smith
I had an amazing time here, like I always do, for over 20 years. They always greet me with a smile and an amazing sub. Keep up the great work!
… moreHenry Menzel
Consistency is really hard to find in chain restaurants, especially for people who travel, but that’s why I rely on Jersey Mike’s so much. I got a consistently tasty sandwich no matter what location I go to, and this location was no different. Very clean very quick very friendly staff. Even met the manager Dustin who made my sandwich himself. Very much appreciated.
… moreJoe John
I’d like some roast beef on my roast beef sub. What is this? I really don’t like spending over $10 on a sandwich only to be given a couple thin slices of meat. I’m a regular customer and I’ve had good experience with this location, but my last couple sandwiches were like this. I guess I’ll be taking my money elsewhere in the future.
Edit: I’m still hungry after eating the sub. And for the owner, you can save the canned response.
… moreEdit: I’m still hungry after eating the sub. And for the owner, you can save the canned response.
tara Duffy
We are always coming here lately we have had smaller problems that can be overlooked but last night we all got a whole sub I got the chicken Philly , hubby got the chipotle cheesesteak and my son got bacon ranch chicken cheesesteak we did online we ordered the rosemary bread (because it’s all about flavor) and none of us got what we ordered. No rosemary bread on any of them my chicken was dry no sauce (so dry it scratched my throat) hubbys the same his was no sauce and cooked dry , my son is also the same dry no sauce!!! This came to $48 for some sandwiches! I tried calling and calling this was irritating because we then went and spent $30 on pizza ! ! This is happening everywhere! We all are working all day don’t have time to cook so we get take out every day and all these places just don’t care anymore! I would have brought them back and got new ones if someone would have answered! I also tried calling today a few times no answer! This food is too expensive to have it messed up all the time and I wouldn’t leave a bad comment had someone answered the phone! Also each store is responsible for their own, there isn’t a headquarters you can get a hold of! This was unprofessional, and if they give us some type of credit I will change this . People and places make mistakes it’s in the way you handle that is what has me heated
… moreAnna Miller
Staff is friendly, this is a busy restaurant with many local businesses nearby. I have never had to wait long to order here, even when there is a line. The food subs are very good here. Sad the discontinued the meatball sub, their meatball subs were so much better than other businesses that sell them.
… moreMissy Emmert
It was awesome the guy working at the Pickerington one today was amazing he new his job and did it well he even helped me with my gift card hard to find nice young men like him that know how to do there job.
… moreScott Sharples
I order online ahead of time to make sure it’s ready and more than once it hasn’t been. I ordered today for 11:45 am before a football game starting at noon. I finally asked at the counter at 11:55 and they said they’ll start it now. Extremely frustrating and disappointing.
… moreRpiesSPIES
So first off, I don’t disagree that the hours need to be updated, but I think it’s silly that people are giving 1* reviews especially the person saying you can just walk in. One would think a person would have sense to look inside the building they’re entering to see through the glass what the situation is. I had asked at a different location how long it’s expected to take, and hopefully there’s only about a month remaining.
Now for what I actually have to say. This is the best Jersey Mikes I’ve eaten at (to be fair, out of 3 locations), and the subs from here are better than any other chain I’ve gotten to. Was sad to see that the company was bought out by someone else, so until it goes to crap, I’ll continue going. I did notice the price increases shortly before renovation went into effect, which is unfortunate considering whomever was in charge of the price increases is entirely ignorant of the situation of income and wages and all that crap, but that’s not really this particular venue’s fault.
So my subs that I get here are really quite good, with nearly perfect consistency, only really changing when a new person is handling my order. The water is somehow also the best water I’ve had anywhere in the Pickerington area and idk how they do it. I really hope the renovations don’t change this as it’s weirdly something I actually look forward to. The regular staff is also great while also handling orders at a consistent enough pace that I never have to worry about being late for work.
… moreNow for what I actually have to say. This is the best Jersey Mikes I’ve eaten at (to be fair, out of 3 locations), and the subs from here are better than any other chain I’ve gotten to. Was sad to see that the company was bought out by someone else, so until it goes to crap, I’ll continue going. I did notice the price increases shortly before renovation went into effect, which is unfortunate considering whomever was in charge of the price increases is entirely ignorant of the situation of income and wages and all that crap, but that’s not really this particular venue’s fault.
So my subs that I get here are really quite good, with nearly perfect consistency, only really changing when a new person is handling my order. The water is somehow also the best water I’ve had anywhere in the Pickerington area and idk how they do it. I really hope the renovations don’t change this as it’s weirdly something I actually look forward to. The regular staff is also great while also handling orders at a consistent enough pace that I never have to worry about being late for work.
James Crowder
Food was made sloppy, The tall fella working with the cross necklace arou d 5:45 was very rude to me and his co workers. Very disappointed, as I frequent here alot
… moreMollie Hessfield
Very slammed on a Saturday at lunch. The kids working were very polite and working hard to get everyone taken care of.
… more