Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Jersey Mike’s, a fast-casual sub sandwich franchise with more than 2,500 locations open and under development nationwide, has a long history of community involvement and support. Started at the Jersey Shore in 1956, Jersey Mike’s serves authentic East Coast-style subs on fresh baked bread – the same recipe it started with over 60 years ago. The company’s mission is to bring its customers the highest quality, freshest made sub in the industry and give back to the communities in which it operates.
New Jersey–based counter-serve sandwich chain serving jumbo subs filled with cold cuts & toppings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 585 Main Street, Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Phone: (631) 666-0557
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Sub and Sandwich Shop in Bay Shore, New York – Jersey Mike’s Subs
Welcome to Jersey Mike’s Subs in Bay Shore, New York, we’re thrilled to have you here! Enjoy our classic East Coast–style sub sandwiches, made with the …
Jersey Mike’s Subs – Menu
Mike’s Hot Italian. Ham, salami & pepperoni with melted provolone cheese. Topped with grilled onions, lettuce, tomato and Hot Chopped Pepper Relish.
Jersey Mike’s Subs – Bay Shore, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery
Northeast-style cold sub sandwiches sliced fresh in front of you. Prepared Mike’s Way® with Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Vinegar, Oil and Spices.
Reviews
Albert Acevedo
Never get your order right. You have to monitor the workers and make sure they get your order correct. I ordered a #8 club sub they didn’t put any mayo and left the bacon out. You say something and you’re met with eye rolls. Never coming to this location again
… moreHailey Vicino
Service and food were excellent! Aaron took great care of me, he was incredibly polite, attentive, and kind. I’ll definitely be coming back soon. Big shoutout to Aaron for his outstanding service!
… moredavid Kdosh
This Jersey Mike’s is a complete disaster. I’ve never experienced customer service this bad in my life. I placed a delivery order through their app — paid over $30 — and they delivered it to the wrong place. When I called the store, they basically shrugged and said, “Not our problem.”
No refund. No remake. No apology. Just pure attitude from the guy on the phone who clearly hates his job and shouldn’t be answering calls.
I ended up with no food, no help, and a reminder of why customer service is dying. This location is everything wrong with fast food — lazy, careless, and rude. Save your money, your time, and your sanity.
Go anywhere else.
… moreNo refund. No remake. No apology. Just pure attitude from the guy on the phone who clearly hates his job and shouldn’t be answering calls.
I ended up with no food, no help, and a reminder of why customer service is dying. This location is everything wrong with fast food — lazy, careless, and rude. Save your money, your time, and your sanity.
Go anywhere else.
Noble Obi
First time going to this location and the service was great. Aaron gave great service and had a welcoming smile and personality which you don’t usually see in young people today.
… moreABMK Investments
By far the worst Jersey Mike’s experience ever. I placed a delivery order through the app, and they somehow managed to deliver it to the wrong address. When I called the store — politely, at first — they couldn’t care less. No refund, no remake, no accountability. Just attitude.
I paid over $30 for nothing. The person on the phone was unbelievably rude, talking to me like I made the mistake.
This place is a joke. Zero customer service, zero responsibility, zero respect. Save yourself the trouble — never order from this location.
… moreI paid over $30 for nothing. The person on the phone was unbelievably rude, talking to me like I made the mistake.
This place is a joke. Zero customer service, zero responsibility, zero respect. Save yourself the trouble — never order from this location.
T JR
After speaking with Marvin the manager he showed me top tier service and corrected all my issues with the food I’m happy with Marvins people skills!
… moremicheal
I had a disappointing experience at this Jersey Mike’s location due to poor management and unprofessional staff behavior. During my visit, the manager was noticeably rude and dismissive, which set a negative tone for the entire interaction. Rather than addressing concerns respectfully or maintaining a professional demeanor, the manager’s attitude came across as impatient and unwelcoming. Additionally, the staff appeared disorganized and unprepared. There was a lack of clear communication among employees, which resulted in confusion, delays, and an overall chaotic environment. Instead of working together efficiently, the team seemed scattered and unfocused, making the experience frustrating as a customer.I have visited other Jersey Mike’s locations and have had much better experiences, which is why this visit was particularly disappointing. I hope management takes the time to address these issues, as professionalism, organization, and respectful customer service are essential to maintaining the brand’s reputation.
… moreAndrew Uszenski
Messed up almost all of our orders and my 6 year old son only wanted cheese on a loaf and they charged us $21 for it not to happy.
… moreKimberly M
Due to the two girls who look like twins and at least one is always, never coming to this location again after being a long time customer. Rude, constant eye rolls, and been there forever but doesn’t even understand how their register system works to the point they tried to make me pay for my last order twice, they were wrong and the transaction fully went through, but they both still continued to try to take my money twice. Came back to try again today, both same girls were there and doubled down on their rudeness today!
… moreBenji Kadosh
Hands down the worst Jersey Mike’s I’ve ever dealt with. Every single person working here should be replaced. I placed an order for delivery through the app — the driver brought it to the wrong location. I called the store immediately, and they flat-out told me there was nothing they could do. No refund. No replacement. Nothing.
So I just paid $32 for food I never got. To make it worse, the guy on the phone had the worst attitude imaginable — rude, dismissive, and completely unprofessional.
All I wanted was a sandwich. Instead, I got frustration, disrespect, and an empty stomach. Avoid this location at all costs. Total disaster from top to bottom.
… moreSo I just paid $32 for food I never got. To make it worse, the guy on the phone had the worst attitude imaginable — rude, dismissive, and completely unprofessional.
All I wanted was a sandwich. Instead, I got frustration, disrespect, and an empty stomach. Avoid this location at all costs. Total disaster from top to bottom.