4.4 – 62 reviews • Ice cream shop
Jeremiah’s Italian Ice scoops up refreshing Italian Ice, creamy Soft Ice Cream, and their indulgent signature Gelati – the perfect layering of Ice and Soft Ice Cream. Jeremiah’s hand makes their tasty frozen desserts daily, and offers free samples to ensure every guest has a flavorful experience. With more than 40 delicious flavor options, ranging from Mango to Cookies and Cream, including diary-free and vegan friendly options, there’s a treat to fulfill any craving! Drop by to Live Life to the Coolest with the Jeremiah’s Frog Squad!
Counter-serve stand with frozen treats, including soft-serve cones, ices & gelati in many flavors.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Last Updates
Reviews
Jonathan Gray
FINALLY!! A soft serve spot that fills the void that SweetFrog left behind here in Red Bank! I love the atmosphere and overall vibe of the place, and the staff are very friendly and helpful. They definitely passed the “is the Mud Pie good” test, don’t worry. Shoutouts to Emma and Kaiya for making my first visit a reason to keep me coming back for more of the S’More flavor!
… moreHope Guess
So excited to finally have an actual soft ice cream shop in Red Bank! We stopped by and couldn’t have been happier with the entire experience. Their menu is huge, they have so many flavors of Italian Ice, & many toppings as well. I got the Jelati which is ice cream & Italian ice together & my husband got a combination of orange & strawberry Italian ice. The staff were incredibly friendly & offered us so many free samples as well as personal recommendations which I ended up picking – birthday cake Italian ice with chocolate ice cream. We couldn’t be happier to have this place in town!
… moreBrittani English Fulmer
Service was quick, it was clean, and the ice with the soft serve “flavorite” was delicious! Will definitely be back.
… moreBella Turk
Came in on opening day and it was amazing. Cheap prices and the items I got were delicious. Definitely recommend getting the strawberry shortcake absolutely DELICIOUS!! Friendly staff and very helpful when trying to decide what to get. Can’t wait to be back!!
… moreShelby Roberts
Our visit to Jeremiah’s Italian Ice was truly such a sweet experience in every way. The Italian ice was absolutely delicious, so refreshing, flavorful, and clearly made with care. It was the perfect treat to enjoy with my child.
What really stood out to me was how clean and welcoming the store was. You can tell they take pride in their space. The staff were so kind and patient, and offering samples to both me and my child made us feel genuinely valued and appreciated. It turned a simple stop for dessert into a special little memory.
I especially want to recognize the GM, Tia. She was spectacular! She was warm, professional, and clearly passionate about what she does. You can feel her leadership in the positive energy of the team and the overall atmosphere. It’s rare to walk into a place and immediately feel that level of care.
We will absolutely be back. So grateful for such a wonderful experience.
… moreMichael Sims
I’m an ice cream guy, but this was good! The employees were nice and looked to be enjoying their work. They offered to explain the menu, gave free samples, and offered suggestions.
… moreAlyssa Causey
The service was good but one of the young girls behind the counter working said that she guesstimates giving people their change. We gave her a 20$ and the cost of the ice cream was 12.40. They shouldn’t say things like that in front of customers.
… moreDeidre Brown
Amazing service and excellent ice! The atmosphere is so inviting. Definitely a must try! The GM is very friendly and helpful!
… moreReesie P
Just one little suggestion. They should wear gloves when making orders. Other than that, Everything was good.
… moreJessica Abshire
I stopped in to try this for the first time and the GM, Tia, was SO helpful in giving me options and telling me what i’d like or not like based off the questions she was asking me. 10/10 would recommend.
… more … View more