Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Pizzas & Italian favorites dished up in a warm, low-key mini-chain eatery with ample booth seating.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3968 Hempstead Tpke, Bethpage, NY 11714
Phone: (516) 520-6460
Website: https://www.italianobethpage.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Italiano Ristorante in Bethpage
The Best Italian Food In Bethpage New York. The chefs of Tuscany believe in enhancing the purity and natural flavor of ingredients, rather than trying to …
Italiano Bethpage highly recommended pizza restaurant – Facebook
Another great meal at Italiano Bethpage. I’ve been coming here from the start and it’s certainly caught on. Place was packed by 6:00. For a …
Italiano (@italiano_bethpage) • Instagram photos and videos
Bethpage, Long Island, NY ♥️ #LongIsland #ITALIANO #Foodie #Bethpage #Pasta …
Reviews
Arlene Curcio
First time there. The food is amazing. My husband and I ordered the Clams Oreganato and Fried Mozzerella. They were both great. Says it comes with marinara but ours was with vodka sauce. So good. Then he ordered the Short Rib Rigatoni in a bread bowl with melted mozzarella on top. That was amazing. The rib meat is so tender. So good. I ordered the Chicken franchise with spaghetti bread bowl. Again so delicious. Will definently be going back.
… moreJoanie
We had such a great Valentine’s Day here and genuinely had a lot of fun. The ambiance is very cozy and romantic, and the perfume in the restaurant smells absolutely divine. Even though it’s a family restaurant, it still feels like a really lovely, intimate place for a date night.
⭐️ PROS
– The sauce was excellent, rich and well seasoned.
– The pasta itself was very good and cooked properly.
– The bread was amazing and easily one of the highlights of the meal.
– The pomegranate martini was my favorite drink of the night.
– The truffleinis appetizers were unreal and honestly the best thing we’ve ever eaten. We would come back just for those alone.
⛔️ CONS
– The chicken tasted like frozen dinner, pre-cooked meat.
– The meats lacked flavor overall and were disappointing.
✅ FEEDBACK
– Glasses of water should be brought automatically.
– Salt and pepper should already be on the table.
– A basket of bread should come by default.
Even with the downsides, we still had a really fun evening and don’t regret choosing this place for Valentine’s Day. With a few improvements, especially on the meat side and basic table setup, this could be an excellent spot.
… more⭐️ PROS
– The sauce was excellent, rich and well seasoned.
– The pasta itself was very good and cooked properly.
– The bread was amazing and easily one of the highlights of the meal.
– The pomegranate martini was my favorite drink of the night.
– The truffleinis appetizers were unreal and honestly the best thing we’ve ever eaten. We would come back just for those alone.
⛔️ CONS
– The chicken tasted like frozen dinner, pre-cooked meat.
– The meats lacked flavor overall and were disappointing.
✅ FEEDBACK
– Glasses of water should be brought automatically.
– Salt and pepper should already be on the table.
– A basket of bread should come by default.
Even with the downsides, we still had a really fun evening and don’t regret choosing this place for Valentine’s Day. With a few improvements, especially on the meat side and basic table setup, this could be an excellent spot.
Kelly Kiefer
The food was good. We saw a Tik Tok about the place and decided to try it while in NYC. Their pizza by the slice was a huge hit for my kids. The pasta was very good. The bread bowl, while very tasty, was a little disappointing for the extra price. The pasta portion in the bread bowl seemed much smaller than without the bread bowl. We went for lunch on a week day, not very crowded but busy. Staff was friendly. Would recommend giving this place a try!
… moreMara NYC
Dropped in for a quick slice of pizza, then noticed they have vegetable stick- like a mini roll, very good. So comfortable, nice relaxing music, busy crowded but not loud. Staff was very friendly and great service. Reasonable price for meal, parking lot in front. Cute birthday for patron, with happy birthday song on speakers and sparkler at table, nice occasion touch.
… moreJames Rivera Jr.
Saw a reel about there bread bowls and made it a must go to place. My daughter and I enjoyed a nice dinner for 2. Cesar salad, fried calamari, penne al vodka in the bread bowl and a short rib rigatoni. Everything was fresh and flavorful. Our server was on her job the whole time and the atmosphere was nice. Music wasn’t too loud, NFL red zone on the TV by the bar. My daughter approved and that’s usually tough.
… moreRahj
Rigatoni Raffaele is good. Very nice in a bread bowl too but very very expensive at about $32. Chicken is juicy and flavorful. Pasta was cooked well. I must say, table bread was very good too. Service was good. I would get the pasta dish again but without the bread bowl. Bowl is ok…wish it was garlic bread or had some flavor to it.
… moreB G
I decided to try this spot after seeing those mouthwatering DevourPower videos — everything in that clip looked incredible. Unfortunately… my experience was the complete opposite.
First, this is not the restaurant the video makes it seem like. It’s basically a standard pizzeria with a small dining area on the side nothing “high-end” about it. The place was empty, yet my partner and I sat for almost 20 minutes before anyone even acknowledged us. When we finally got our sodas, another 10 minutes had passed. No bread for us, but the table that arrived after us got some right away.
I started with the fried mozzarella, which was actually very good and honestly the highlight of the entire meal. For our mains, we ordered the Penne Firenze and the short rib rigatoni. The wait for the food felt endless, and the waiter never once came by to give us an update or see if we needed anything. By the time the food arrived, I was already frustrated — and then the first bite made it worse. My dish was dry, bland, and disappointing. I paid an extra $7 for the bread bowl, and it wasn’t even worth a dollar. I had asked about swapping ricotta for burrata — they wanted another $7 for that too, so I skipped it. The Penne Firenze was definitely better, but still not enough to save the night.
The service didn’t improve. Our waiter never checked on us once throughout the entire meal.
For dessert, we ordered the chocolate cake totally average — and a cannoli that was barely edible. To top it all off, the spoon for both of our desserts came covered in whipped cream… on the handle. I’ve never seen that before. I had to ask the busboy for clean utensils because our waiter only seemed to appear every 25 minutes.
Overall, the food, the vibe, and the service were a letdown. I won’t be returning.
… moreFirst, this is not the restaurant the video makes it seem like. It’s basically a standard pizzeria with a small dining area on the side nothing “high-end” about it. The place was empty, yet my partner and I sat for almost 20 minutes before anyone even acknowledged us. When we finally got our sodas, another 10 minutes had passed. No bread for us, but the table that arrived after us got some right away.
I started with the fried mozzarella, which was actually very good and honestly the highlight of the entire meal. For our mains, we ordered the Penne Firenze and the short rib rigatoni. The wait for the food felt endless, and the waiter never once came by to give us an update or see if we needed anything. By the time the food arrived, I was already frustrated — and then the first bite made it worse. My dish was dry, bland, and disappointing. I paid an extra $7 for the bread bowl, and it wasn’t even worth a dollar. I had asked about swapping ricotta for burrata — they wanted another $7 for that too, so I skipped it. The Penne Firenze was definitely better, but still not enough to save the night.
The service didn’t improve. Our waiter never checked on us once throughout the entire meal.
For dessert, we ordered the chocolate cake totally average — and a cannoli that was barely edible. To top it all off, the spoon for both of our desserts came covered in whipped cream… on the handle. I’ve never seen that before. I had to ask the busboy for clean utensils because our waiter only seemed to appear every 25 minutes.
Overall, the food, the vibe, and the service were a letdown. I won’t be returning.
Eric Martin
Went here on the 13th for valentines day dinner. My gf got the Alfredo parpadelle pasta with fried chicken in a bread bowl. I got the pesto gnocci bread bowl special with grilled chicken.
The restaurant was very busy. Service was kinda slow. Our waitress was very friendly. I think she was just very busy so it wasn’t a big deal. Our food took about 45 minutes to come out. We had to ask where it was.
The food was good. The bread bowl is unnecessary, but that’s just my opinion. My biggest gripe was the portion size difference between my food and my girlfriend’s. Her bread bowl was filled to the brim with pasta and over loaded with fried chicken and cheese. My bowl had very little pasta in it. Considering my meal was about 40 dollars this made me really annoyed.
Overall, I’ll try them again. Maybe when they’re less busy. The food was flavorful.
… moreThe restaurant was very busy. Service was kinda slow. Our waitress was very friendly. I think she was just very busy so it wasn’t a big deal. Our food took about 45 minutes to come out. We had to ask where it was.
The food was good. The bread bowl is unnecessary, but that’s just my opinion. My biggest gripe was the portion size difference between my food and my girlfriend’s. Her bread bowl was filled to the brim with pasta and over loaded with fried chicken and cheese. My bowl had very little pasta in it. Considering my meal was about 40 dollars this made me really annoyed.
Overall, I’ll try them again. Maybe when they’re less busy. The food was flavorful.
Fran Marie
Everything about this restaurant is excellent! The entire staff is friendly, professional, and attentive. The owner is THE perfect ambassador. The food is the best Italian food I’ve had in a long time. An excellent choice for special occasions.
… moreYoshi Takita Real Estate Broker
Very good food, very nice and clean environment. And reasonable price. And very good service. I would recommend when you are hungry
… more