Angel Santiago
We rarely come out to the Keys but a place like this could make you come weekly. First things first, the atmosphere is alluring. The dining tables are gorgeous and well crafted art while the music blends it altogether into a wonderful experience. The appetizers were great too. The calamari was simple but satisfying, and the garlic cheese breadsticks were to die for. The dough they use is incredible, which leads me to the pizza. The pizza is probably some of the best Ive ever had in years. The cheese pulls and feels so homemade and authentic, the pepperoni was delicious and full of flavor and their bacon is the perfect addition for an astonishing pizza. While the price seems a little high, the price is made up for in the fact that everything tastes absolutely incredible, and the vibe of the place is wonderful. With great customer service to boot, you will not regret coming here and even bringing the whole family.
… moreBrenda Smith
Cutest little dining experience! Our service was excellent- Erixon was great! We had the daily pizza special- best pizza we’ve had in a long time! the crust . Omg so lite and airy with the right crunch!! So thankful we stopped! Thumbs up for sure!
… moreSofia Gibson
I had such a wonderful experience at Italian Food Company! The penne vodka was absolutely delicious The service was just as impressive. Our waiter, Eric, was outstanding – attentive, friendly, and made us feel so welcome the entire time. He made sure we had everything we needed and really elevated the whole dining experience.
… moreAaron Collins
Found this spot as it’s a short walking distance from our resort. We were in town for a wedding and needed a spot for a light lunch prior. I wish we were in town for longer so we could have a proper dinner. We split a Garlic Foccacia and had some Chicken Caesar Salads. The food was amazingly fresh and delicious. The pasta entrées looked great! The pizza too!
… moreMurray Frazier
We had calarmari with fresh marinara. Outstanding!
Pizza superb!
Charcuterie ridiculously good!
Affagato yummy
… morejerimiah duell
We’re here visiting from out of town (shocker.)
We have eaten out almost every night while here, mostly on a seafood kick, but tonight we wanted something different. Well needless to say I am overjoyed we decided to eat here tonight. This might have been one of the best Italian spots I’ve ever had the privilege of dining in. This place was over the top, from the warm welcome to the amazing service, to the absolutely phenomenal cuisine. Everything that was ordered was fantastic. I personally had the mussels to start and the Cacio e Pepe. The mussels were easily the best I’ve had and the pasta… oh the pasta! Creamy, cheesy, delectable, unctuous and peppery. Everything was incredibly fresh and piping hot. If you’re ever in the area visiting or if you live nearby, run, don’t walk to enjoy some of the most authentic and delicious Italian food around. And just to be clear we dined at the express location in Tavernier. Salute!
… moreMelissa Richards
Ordered pickup last night, it was on the counter waiting a few minutes ahead of the time given. About a 30 -40 minute total wait. Nice texting start to finish. Pizzas were very good! Crust is wonderful. (In case you read other posts- used fresh mushrooms!) Roman large is huge and crust similar in texture to an airy focaccia!, The personal 12” meatball & ricotta was a hit! The Cacio e Pepe pasta was simply delicious and so creamy and flavorful!
… moreCraig Aleman
Great food and service. My kids loved the Roman style squared pizza. We definitely recommend!
… moreM
Staff was friendly and attentive. Establishment was clean and cute.. but the pizza we ordered to go was missing the fresh basil we ordered and doughy & raw in the center. Also had way too much cheese and not enough sauce. 🙁
… moreEric Anderson
Excellent & authentic Italian food. Quick service. Friendly staff.
… more