Rory Stafford
Mr Frank was so accommodating and kind, an absolute pleasure to speak to! The waiting staff were superb (Jose and Franklin especially). The food was flawless and the atmosphere perfect. As our last night in NY we couldn’t be happier!
… moreLF D
I have been supporting this downtown establishment since 2004! I love it! Traditional italian food in a cozy atmosphere. They are the real deal here, not pretentious at all. Great for a date night, a treat, a special occasion, or a dinner party with friends. Highly recommend this restaurant.
… moreAmy Limb
Il Cantinori is such an NYC classic for Italian food. They have lengthy specials every day. No one does better eggplant parm than Cantinori. Place was packed! Service is always top notch too. Guaranteed great food and good times.
… moreZack Young
Beautiful environment. Excellent hosts. Everyone has thick accents so it’s very hard to understand. Everything good is not even on the menu. My chicken parm which isn’t on the menu came with green beans not pasta. No wine lists, no wine pairing, no description on the 80 dollar bottle we purchased. Management was very nice and accommodating but way too late to fix any of the issues we were having. Very authentic maybe it’s just not for me. Decide for yourself. I just would like expect more for 200 dollars before tip.
… moreAlly Stacy
Il Cantinori is hands down one of the best dining experiences in New York City. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere feels warm, elegant, and effortlessly authentic. The food is exceptional, with beautifully prepared dishes that showcase classic Italian flavors and top quality ingredients.
What truly makes Il Cantinori special, though, is Frank. He is the heart and soul of the restaurant. Frank’s warmth, hospitality, and genuine care for every guest elevate the entire experience. He makes you feel like family the second you arrive and somehow remembers everyone, their preferences, and exactly how to make the night feel memorable. His presence alone takes an incredible restaurant and makes it unforgettable.
Between the outstanding food, welcoming atmosphere, and Frank’s unmatched hospitality, Il Cantinori is a place you will want to return to again and again. A true NYC gem that sets the standard for what dining out should feel like.
… moreAnnie Kingston
Pasta was great, Ceasar salad and calamari were average at best. Super busy spot with tight tables. Loved the round tables, but the room was very loud.
… moreLora Aroyo
The salads and appetizers were pretty fresh and delicious – caprese salad, prosciutto with figs and grilled maitake salad (my favorite!!). From all the main dishes we had – pappardelle alla buttera and Bucatini Alla Gracia were the best!! I wouldn’t so much recommend the grilled chicken as it was overcooked and dry. The risotto of the day was delicious, but the portion was just huge. We also had a delicious trentino Sauvignon Blanc!!
… moreDelaney Lindstrom
Two of my friends and I ate at Il Cantinori for the first time this last Thursday night. We were excited to go to a traditional Italian restaurant and see its incredible reputation. We were served by Leo and he did an excellent job and had a great attitude! We each had a Caesar salad for an appetizer and then we each had the sampler plate which is off menu. Perfect portions, didn’t even really have to look at the menu to order because Leo helped. Ended the night with tiramisu of course. Totally recommend. Thanks Leo!!!
… moreEric Chen
Came here a while back with some friends during a trip. Food was amazing and the atmosphere was extraordinary. Had an assortment of starters, entrees and dessert and all were delicious. This place is always packed so make sure you get a reservation in advance (especially on weekends) and to dress nicely. An amazing place for a fancy dinner date ~
… morePanos Tzivanidis
You get the best food and the best service in the area. You can feel the “love” & the “family” vibe of this place. If there is one thing, is the ambient sound… It is really loud. (no different to many other places in NY)
If you want real Italian food and you are in the area, do not hesitate!
… more