Sherri Mangieri-Little
This is sad…if there was a zero rating I would e chose that… when I was little we used to go here and it was clean and the pizza was decent for what it was. Just stopped in to grab some slices and haven’t been in here forever… wanted to give them a try to support them. $12 for 4 plain slices that appear to be very old – def not made today or even yesterday…. They smell and not in a good way or even like greasy pizza – they smell like old yeast- you can see the discoloration in the dough from being old and sitting for quite awhile. So didn’t even attempt to take a bite. Threw the box out as soon as I got home. What a shame and waste of money.
The place is run down.. dirty and depressing. And to charge $3 a slice for something inedible is insane. Maybe they should consider making an effort at fresh food and they would have more business like back in the day.
… moreMarc x
Not terrible, but relatively bland and flavorless cheese/sauce. Crust was ok. I’d go back if nothing else was open. The service was good and quick. Atmosphere?….well, it’s a pizza joint, so…
… moreJudith Seeman
I stopped in for a slice after pies on 9 was a complete failure with fly covered pies no thin crust and they refused to add red sauce to the chicken slice I went to your place and asked for a slice with chicken and was told you only had plain and you wouldn’t take my credit card and demanded cash. At this point I went to the old mama Mia’s and had the best most amazing slice exactly how I wanted it! Your customer service sucks when someone comes in with a craving!!!!!!
… morePenny C
They have good pizza but price keeps going up and pizza keeps getting smaller! Shame
… moreChamber Maids NJ
This place has really good pizza. The crust isn’t too thick or too thin, it had just the right amount of crispiness and it was just really good And the best part about it is, I can walk to get a slice! Their prices are amazing!
… moreRonald Kroeschel
I go to House of Pizza every Thursday around 2:00 p.m. . It’s a nice place for me to grab a quick slice and a drink while my mother is next door at Sarah’s salon getting her hair done. You can go pretty much around any corner and you’ll find another place to get a pizza. I am by no means a connoisseur but I do know what I like. I enjoy his pizza very much but would appreciate if he had fountain drinks instead of canned and bottle drinks to go with it. That being said what I enjoy about this place is that the owner Pasquale always engages me in conversation asking how are my mother and I are doing. That to me somebody who cares about their customers. I’m not a local, I drive here to bring my mother to get her hair done. There’s a sign on his door today that says he won’t be open for a while as he’s recovering from surgery. My best wishes to him for a speedy recovery and a profitable future. Remember people support your local businesses. The chain stores make enough money. These are hard-working Americans, just like you and me, that deserve our support.
… morePaul DAmico
Solid thin slice pie. No flop. Great flavor 2 pies for 18. Just go pick up instead of giving grub hub your money.
… moreBill O’Brien
Bayville has lots of pizza places and having recently move here, I have tried most of them. House of Pizza is my favorite! The crust is perfect- not too thick- not too thin. Love the sauce. Made in the old Napoli way. They also keep their price reasonably low. I suggest you give them a try.
… moreLauren Luongo
I LOVE their pizza. It’s my favorite place in this area for sure. I am a thin pizza girlie and they make the best thin pizzas! It’s always cooked perfectly.
… moreJillian Cerbone
I live in Bayville and first tried House of Pizza about 2 years ago. Their food is SO good and the owners are always so friendly. Incredible flavor and sizes. Their prices are also great, especially for the quality of the food! I go here a couple times a month and will continue to do so! 10/10 🙂
… more