Adam Champion
Hands down the best dessert you can find in Elizabethtown. They have a massive selection of homemade pies and cake. I had the strawberry rhubarb pie which was baked to perfection. The homemade crust was amazing. A nice casual down home atmosphere. Extremely friendly staff.
… moreSecret Avenger
The Spread on display in There is WOW !!
Just go get a Slice or Cupcake & find out for yourself just how Beautifully Delicious this place is
I noticed a couple reviews Cryin’ that it’s “Pricey”. My response to them is if you want “Factory Produced” pie, cake, or ice cream then take yourself to the grocery. Now, if You want something REAL & DELICIOUS Then go to the Pie Kitchen.
❤
… moreKitty Williams
The cake and pies are just ok. Good enough to hit the spot. This is the 2nd time I been. The first time, eventhough, it was good, I told myself never to come again. Only because it is outrageously expensive.
A slice of cake is almost $8!!!!
… moreSharon McCarragher
Made a detour on our way to Georgia, just to celebrate Pi Day! Laura D was very helpful, and we were pleasantly surprised that in honor of the holiday, the pie was $3.14 per slice. We indulged in lemon meringue, strawberry rhubarb and Dutch apple. Homemade vanilla ice cream was a nice complement. A little disappointed that French Silk pie is only available with preorder, but to be honest I didn’t need it. I don’t normally like crusts, but even the crust tasted good.
… moreKenny Loy
Madison and MacKenzie were fantastic on taking care of our large order. The order was perfect. Super friendly, and the food was great.
… moreJames A
The staff were exceptionally friendly, and the variety of pies was impressive. The ice cream was also delicious. I will definitely return and recommend this place to everyone I know. A special thanks to the female staff who went above and beyond by offering free pie to my Korean friends. Your kindness was greatly appreciated!
… moreKim Bryan
Cakes, pies, cookies, ice cream. Everything is yummy. Best desert place, hands down. Prices are reasonable. If you need a birthday cake, or cake for any occasion made, you should give this place a try. I got a birthday cake that was made that morning. Not a pre order. It was last minute. So I was a little skeptical. White cake with buttercream icing. This cake was fabulous. Very fresh. I will order my cakes from here every time I need one.
… moreBree P
Incredible service and desserts!!! Strongly recommend the chocolate coconut icecream. Cookie was soft and delicious. Very satisfied. Cheap too.
… moreJess
We’ve been here a few times but tonight really stood out. To the lady who got me a scoop of vanilla at closing: thank you so much. Your kindness and understanding was felt and really meant a lot. We both really appreciate you❤️.
Overall, this place has great flavors of ice cream and REALLY great pies! My husband and I love coming for after dinner treats. We both highly recommend for food and service. Overall, great place and great people!
… moreMorana Revel
Seating outside is great and even had a bit of shade at noon, the staff is great and friendly and would you look at the selection! Wow, top notch!
… more