Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
HMK started out in NYC’s Gansevoort Market as the Big apples first-ever little knot shop. After a few years there, HMK had the opportunity to move into a stand alone location in Hillsdale NJ! Also, venturing out into the food truck business which travel to new locations weekly and do private parties and corporate events. HMK specializes in Garlic Knot Sliders, but also offer a ton of different sandwiches, crazy appetizers, gourmet milkshakes and so much more available daily.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 134 Broadway, Hillsdale, NJ 07642
Phone: (201) 666-0706
Website: https://holdmyknots.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Best Pizza in Hillsdale, NJ | Hold My Knots | Pizza near me
We serve the best knots around, not to mention a ton of other options of pizza, sliders, appetizers.
Hold My Knots (@holdmyknots) · Hillsdale, NJ – Instagram
35K followers · 2.5K+ posts · Introducing the Original Garlic Knot Sliders ™ #️⃣holdmyknots ™ 134 Broadway, Hillsdale NJ 201-666-0706 *KNOT YOUR AVERAGE …
Hold My Knots – 134 Broadway, Hillsdale, NJ 07642 – Slice
Hold My Knots · House Favorites · Pizza · Gourmet Pizza · Garlic Knots Sliders · Stuffed Garlic Knots · Appetizers · Soups · Salads. Caesar Salad. Crisp romaine …
Reviews
Mary Sanborn
their eggplant parm sliders were DIVINE & they did not skimp on the garlic which i was overjoyed about! we also tried their buffalo mozzarella sticks which were also incredible. this place does KNOT disappoint
… moreChuck Mound
Wish I had more time to discect their Pizza. Was in town for National Hot Dog Day and snuck in a slice in between. Wish I went with the Garlic Knot slice now, but the regular slice was speaking to me. It was a very good slice that had good harmony. I like more sauce, but it did the trick. Was one of the better fill you belly slices I have had. The workers were friendly and place was clean. Cool art work on the walls. I will definitely be goinv back soon. Nice surprise pizzeria.
… morePeter Haight
Worth the Viral Hype in Hillsdale! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Hold My Knots in downtown Hillsdale is a social media sensation that actually delivers on the flavor. If you’re a fan of garlic knots, this place is essentially paradise, offering creative twists on Italian-American favorites.
Signature Sliders: The vodka sauce chicken cutlet sliders are a must-order—absolutely to die for. Using garlic knots as the “bun” for sliders is a genius move that packs tons of flavor into every bite.
The Sides: Their double battered fries are crispy and satisfying, and the pizza is equally awesome. For those wanting something unique, their garlic knot crust pizza is a literal showstopper.
The Experience: Despite the viral fame, the staff remains super friendly and welcoming. You get generous portions and great value for the price, with plenty of seating for a comfortable dine-in experience.
Summary: This spot isn’t just a social media trend; it’s a high-quality eatery with massive portions and bold flavors. It is 100% worth the visit for anyone who appreciates a good garlic knot!
… moreHold My Knots in downtown Hillsdale is a social media sensation that actually delivers on the flavor. If you’re a fan of garlic knots, this place is essentially paradise, offering creative twists on Italian-American favorites.
Signature Sliders: The vodka sauce chicken cutlet sliders are a must-order—absolutely to die for. Using garlic knots as the “bun” for sliders is a genius move that packs tons of flavor into every bite.
The Sides: Their double battered fries are crispy and satisfying, and the pizza is equally awesome. For those wanting something unique, their garlic knot crust pizza is a literal showstopper.
The Experience: Despite the viral fame, the staff remains super friendly and welcoming. You get generous portions and great value for the price, with plenty of seating for a comfortable dine-in experience.
Summary: This spot isn’t just a social media trend; it’s a high-quality eatery with massive portions and bold flavors. It is 100% worth the visit for anyone who appreciates a good garlic knot!
Staci Perfetto-Tyson
Had seen this place mentioned on multiple food sites so decided I had to check it out. I visited on a Sunday afternoon. Place was empty. Had the whole dining room to ourselves. The staff is super friendly and the space is clean and modern looking. We ordered three garlic knot sliders, a chicken parm, an eggplant parm, and a meatball. As you can see from the photos they were all of varying sizes. I don’t think the garlic knots are individually baked, probably just a sheet pan of them and then cut into square shapes so that is most likely why 2 of the sliders didn’t look like a full garlic knot. The sliders themselves were just ok. The bread was too crispy from being reheated while the filling was just barely warm. The pizza in the display case was enticing so we got 2 pies to go. The pizza is hard to describe. The crust is slightly doughy and I would have liked more sauce, but they do put on a good amount of cheese. The pizza reheated nicely the next day and actually tasted better on day 2. I’m glad I got a chance to try this place, but don’t know if it is somewhere I would go out of my way for again.
… moreAmanda Walsh
Went here last night for dinner. Overall the staff is so friendly and customer service minded, the establishment was clean and fun, the food is good, and you can tell there is a lot of heart and soul in this place. I will review everything we ate according to my personal preference but if you don’t want to read the whole thing, all you need to know is you should definitely come check it out!!
We ordered 5 garlic knot sliders, one loaded fries, stuffed garlic knots, pizza with a garlic knot crust, one of their signature sandwiches, and their own brand of sodas.
Let’s start with the garlic, there is a lot of it, as there should be. It was the raw, pungent, slightly spicy garlic in oil appropriately put on everything as advertised. I like that. But it was a lot and I missed that subtle garlic infusion of some kind of cooked garlic that provides a softer balance as an accompaniment to the raw. It was delicious though as is and the flavor just stays with you in such a nice way.
Sliders- we got Chicken Bacon Ranch, out of this world, Eggplant Parm, not my favorite but I’m picky about my eggplant parm, Shrimp Parm, coming back for this one it was phenomenal, Chicken Vodka, ok but I didn’t really taste the vodka sauce, and Phill Cheese, also very good. The eggplant I think may have been flour instead of breading (normal differences in preparation) and I prefer breading so I felt like this was just a personal miss on flavor. The garlic know slider bread was so nice and airy and soft. The chicken vodka just got overpowered by the garlic so it was not my favorite. Really enjoyed the tasting experience though.
Stuffed garlic knots – we got Peperoni and they were really good. Dipped in marinara, just what you would expect, cheesy, garlicky, goodness.
Loaded fries – These are really loaded up. We got pulled pork and the pork was super flavorful. My daughter felt like there could be more cheese but I honestly thought it was a good ratio. Fries were solid; standard, string fries. Overall very yummy dish.
Pizza – we got a plain cheese pizza with a garlic knot crust. Very creative. Very cool. The pizza itself was a little too doughy for my taste, I like a thinner crust, but I am sure if I had asked for it as a preference they would have accommodated. The garlic know crust was good. Again, lots of garlic, just as you would anticipate. I enjoyed the crust.
Signature sandwich – we got “the insider” which was Philly cheesesteak like but with their own sauce that really made a difference. Now here you can opt to have the garlic and oil on top or not. We opted in as this was what we came for. I would probably order it on the side next time. The sandwich was out of this world though. Super tender
Steak, pepper and onions, that yummy sauce, oozy cheese, and the bread was very fresh, soft, airy. I would definitely order this again.
Soda – they have their own brand of bottled soda there and the black cherry was so good we ordered two more to go.
I wanted to try a milkshake but was much too full at the end of the meal so we will definitely have to go back for that. All in it was worth the hour drive from the Bronx to check it out and I will be recommending this place for others to come check it out!! Thank you HMK’s for a wonderful dinner experience.
… moreWe ordered 5 garlic knot sliders, one loaded fries, stuffed garlic knots, pizza with a garlic knot crust, one of their signature sandwiches, and their own brand of sodas.
Let’s start with the garlic, there is a lot of it, as there should be. It was the raw, pungent, slightly spicy garlic in oil appropriately put on everything as advertised. I like that. But it was a lot and I missed that subtle garlic infusion of some kind of cooked garlic that provides a softer balance as an accompaniment to the raw. It was delicious though as is and the flavor just stays with you in such a nice way.
Sliders- we got Chicken Bacon Ranch, out of this world, Eggplant Parm, not my favorite but I’m picky about my eggplant parm, Shrimp Parm, coming back for this one it was phenomenal, Chicken Vodka, ok but I didn’t really taste the vodka sauce, and Phill Cheese, also very good. The eggplant I think may have been flour instead of breading (normal differences in preparation) and I prefer breading so I felt like this was just a personal miss on flavor. The garlic know slider bread was so nice and airy and soft. The chicken vodka just got overpowered by the garlic so it was not my favorite. Really enjoyed the tasting experience though.
Stuffed garlic knots – we got Peperoni and they were really good. Dipped in marinara, just what you would expect, cheesy, garlicky, goodness.
Loaded fries – These are really loaded up. We got pulled pork and the pork was super flavorful. My daughter felt like there could be more cheese but I honestly thought it was a good ratio. Fries were solid; standard, string fries. Overall very yummy dish.
Pizza – we got a plain cheese pizza with a garlic knot crust. Very creative. Very cool. The pizza itself was a little too doughy for my taste, I like a thinner crust, but I am sure if I had asked for it as a preference they would have accommodated. The garlic know crust was good. Again, lots of garlic, just as you would anticipate. I enjoyed the crust.
Signature sandwich – we got “the insider” which was Philly cheesesteak like but with their own sauce that really made a difference. Now here you can opt to have the garlic and oil on top or not. We opted in as this was what we came for. I would probably order it on the side next time. The sandwich was out of this world though. Super tender
Steak, pepper and onions, that yummy sauce, oozy cheese, and the bread was very fresh, soft, airy. I would definitely order this again.
Soda – they have their own brand of bottled soda there and the black cherry was so good we ordered two more to go.
I wanted to try a milkshake but was much too full at the end of the meal so we will definitely have to go back for that. All in it was worth the hour drive from the Bronx to check it out and I will be recommending this place for others to come check it out!! Thank you HMK’s for a wonderful dinner experience.
Nicole Gordienko
We drove 2 hours to check out Hold My Knots in North Jersey. They specialize in all things garlic knots. We got the stuffed garlic knots, garlic knot dog, and the garlic knot sliders (chicken Parm with marinara and vodka sauce) and meatball, mozzarella sticks and chocolate milkshakes. It was good but heavy. I was only able to eat one and a half knots and 2 Mozz sticks. Very messy and hard to eat but unique and delicious. Good quality comfort food. The only criticism is that the bacon was undercooked in the one stuffed knot but overall, would highly recommend.
… moreDaanish Chawala
Garlic knot sliders were really good and a standout from your average pizza place. Also locally sourced sodas were really nice and complemented the meal perfectly. Otherwise standard takeout pizza vibes with seating available for eat-in
… moreAndrew Abi-Mansour
Excellent food! The garlic knots were very fresh and delicious. The soup was also good. I think the cheese calzone had ricotta cheese, I prefer it with just plain mozzarella. I also tried the garlic Parmesan knot slider with cheese burger, eggplant, and meatball. All three were delicious and super garlicy. The cheese pizza is also decent. Overall, the quality is excellent, and the prices are reasonable.
… moreLiv Perez
delicious food and friendly staff. the garlic knot slider was incredible, and the pizza was legit.
… moreDavid Vaknin
I mean come on!! What better combo than garlic knots with anything! I had the 3 sampler of BBQ chicken, Philly cheesesteak, and Buffalo Chicken sliders and they were ungodly. The bread was cooked to perfection and the sandwiched themselves melted in my mouth. If you love garlic and need your fix come here! 3 for 15 is a great deal and I was stuffed!
… more