Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington

  4.4 – 994 reviews   • Hoagie restaurant

Social Profile:

✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington 46208

Hours

MondayClosed
Tuesday11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday11 AM–9 PM
Thursday11 AM–9 PM
Friday11 AM–9 PM
Saturday11 AM–9 PM
Sunday11 AM–9 PM

Address and Contact Information

Address: 4155 Boulevard Pl, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Phone: (317) 426-5731

Website: http://hoagiesandhops.com/

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Order: Order online

hoagiesandhops.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Hoagies & Hops – Home

Authentic Pennsylvania Hoagies made right here in Indianapolis. Bread … Butler Tarkington Neighborhood. This is the only Eagles Nest in the Midwest …

Hoagies and Hops | Indianapolis IN – Facebook

Our largest fundraiser each year, dating back to 2019. Every National Cheesesteak Day, March 24th, we donate 15% of food & @chillywaterbutler taproom beer sales …

Hoagies and Hops | Indianapolis City-wide Dining Experience

Hoagies and Hops is an independent and woman owned Philly Style restaurant in the Butler Tarkington Neighborhood. We recently celebrated 10 years of.

Reviews

Lindsay Bean
Go Phillies! Very fun place with nice outdoor seating. We enjoyed some Philly cheesesteaks and fries and both were good. We got the “Philly” which was not what I expected but it was good. The normal cheesesteak looked better! The beer was also really tasty. We will be coming back for sure!
… more
Leonard Caponegro
We decided to visit after having a great experience at the food truck when they visited Phil’s Produce in Perry Township in September 2024. My cheesesteak, which had the cooper sharp with onions and long hots, was extremely delicious. The Cooper Sharp added a creamy and sharp profile to the cheesesteak that I had never experienced before. Sadly, when I got to the end of the roll where the meat wasn’t covered in cheese, it was very dry. My son ordered the chicken cheesesteak with provolone, onions, and long hots. He thought it was okay, and it could have been better had it had more cheese and wasn’t so dry. My wife ordered the cheesesteak with ribeye, provolone, and onions. She wasn’t impressed because the sandwich was dry all throughout. Also, my wife ordered the potato salad. It had no flavor whatsoever and tasted like boiled potatoes that hadn’t been seasoned. The Bacon Cheese Fries were delicious but could have been a bit crispier. We sat on the Chilly Water Brewing side, and the tables had a leather like covering that was torn and falling apart in multiple places. That is concerning because appearance plays a role in the rating. I’ll be honest that the cheesesteaks tasted far better from the food truck than at the location. The flavors were on point, and there weren’t any dry spots or dryness to speak of. I’m not sure why the cheesesteaks didn’t taste the same at the restaurant, and it was a bit of a letdown since we expected so much more based on a prior experience.
… more
Westfield Underground Boxing
First time here ever and it was on a busy, snowy Saturday. The line was almost out of the door, pretty unexpected for such a snowy day. The staff was still ultra friendly and nice. I made the bad mistake of coming to just pop in before an appointment. After 25 minutes of a wait (it was packed!) i thought i’d cancel my order and come back after. Then the cook looked at my number and said “I got you” and got it for me on the fly. Ate it in my car on slick roads, still the best cheesesteak i’ve had in Indy. I’ll be back for sure. 10/10 service and food
… more
Silverbreath77
DO NOT GO HERE FOR THE FOOD. We got a classic chicken Philly and a beef Philly. The chicken tasted as if it was boiled and thrown on there with greasy onions and cheese. And the bacon on the cheese and bacon fries tasted like old grease that hasn’t been changed in a month. If you’re looking for a Philly sandwich this is not the place. Philadelphia Steak & Fries on 86th is superior.
… more
Andrew Mancebo
I had the Classic Cheesesteak with Onions and Cooper’s Sharp Cheddar and a Basket of Fries. Very Very Good although small for a Cheesesteak.

However the Atmosphere made the difference. The staff and the environment were killer. Me and the Mrs felt like we were back in Philly.

We’ll definitely be back!
… more
Charline Avey
Went in search of a Philly Cheese Steak. This was recommended as one of the best in town. I ordered the full size Classic with provolone. Really good. Ate half and will eat the other tomorrow. The restaurant shares space with the Chilly Water Tap Room, so I ordered a beer to have with my Philly Cheese. Good craft beer selection. Thursday evenings they have music open mic. Nice 3 person jazz band was playing.
They have some outdoor seating if the weather is nice.
… more
Ted Moore
Took my mom out for a quick dinner after work and we both got steak sandwiches. They lacked seasoning so nothing to really say about them. I could barely taste the onions on mine but the banana peppers added a decent touch. I had cheez whiz and American on mine and she had American and Provolone. Onion rings came out luke warm but tasted okay. The bacon and cheese fries were flavorless and needed seasoning as well. This is my second time coming and I’m left unimpressed again. Workers were really nice. Decent atmosphere.
My 3rd time coming here despite my first two failed attempts and let me tell you they totally changed my mind!!! I ordered a different sandwich and it blew everything law outside water!! Please order the Philly Special, add sweet peppers, add American cheese and No tomatoes, add light spicy ketchup!!! Thank me later!!! It was so delicious!!! 5 stars!!
… more
William Sippel
Really solid Cheesesteaks, and the hoagies are fantastic as well! They get their rolls from New Jersey and they are perfect! Soft yet hearty. And a bonus, Chilly Water Brewing is attached so you can get an awesome beer with your sandwich!
… more
Heidi Aguirre
Unfortunately I was disappointed with the flavor. I was expecting an authentic flavorful sub given the name. My friend and I both ordered the cheese steak and it was unseasoned. The pretzel received a good review though the cheese was advertised as beer cheese and looked like cheddar cheese.
… more
Ronald Baker
I’ve never had an “official” Philly cheese steak sandwich. Thread to meat ratio was good, but the flavor was lacking. I think they could have seasoned it. There wasn’t any that I could taste. I’ve made better at home. If you’re an Eagles fan, this is the place to be during the game.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment