Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Basic sandwich shop serving up foot-long hoagies since the early 1970s. Cash only.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 242 Nassau St, Princeton, NJ 08542
Phone: (609) 921-7723
Website: http://hoagiehaven.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Hoagie Haven
Going back to the early 1970’s (when the current sign on the outside was new), Hoagie Haven was the first to serve up large hoagies in the Princeton area.
Our Menu – Hoagie Haven
Please Remember To Grab Off Of Rack When Picking Up. Hoagie Haven • 242 Nassau Street Princeton, NJ 08542. Copyright © 2026 Hoagie Haven. All Rights Reserved.
Hoagie Haven – Wikipedia
Hoagie Haven (also known as Haven or The Haven) is an eatery located in Princeton, New Jersey, founded in 1974.
Reviews
Chuck Mound
This place was recommended by many foodies as a must stop while in Princeton. The food item of choice was the cheesesteak. But before I can get to the cheesesteak, I have to share the overall sub sandwich experience. As a place that had been a staple in Princeton for 50 years, you would expect to have some type of an old school experience that would lend this place to be a destination. Parking? Forget about it, there are a few metered spots that you have to be extremely lucky to get one. Plan on driving around a while. Once you do find a spot, do not forget you wallet because that is the next obstacle..No Cash is accepted for your order that must be placed on the Kios. No greeting welcoming you to the famous Hoagir Haven. Just a sign saying No Cash Accepted and order here. Nobody to talk about what they recommended? What is popular? What you can get on your sandwich? Extras. Just a Kios that is no different than ordering from your local Wawa. I wanted my cheesestreak with ketchup and pickles, this was not part of the options. If it was, didn’t have time for a long search with the line behind me. So I received a plain cheesesteak, which was good based on the solid foundation of the bread. What a major disappointment. Then you get the tip prompt for placing your own order.. Will never get that one. Of course a cash tip is accepted, as I walked out with my order that had no Napkins in the bag. Was not a good Haven experience at all amd sadly I would not go back. This is why you can never believe every review. Sorry Hoagie Haven, not a good day for me there.
… moreYelena Mirko
Danggggg. That jawn was massive. Creative sandwiches. Delicious flavors. Definitely a must stop by when in Princeton. At first, we were kind of pissed that 2 14inch sandwiches was $45, and then we received them and we were very happy. We had enough for lunch and dinner and it was delishhhhh. Not much places to sit but we walked down the street to Ivy Inn and sat at their outdoor picnic tables to have our hoagies.
… moreKim Do
I got the Wake-Up Call and the #1 cold hoagie. Both were delicious and huge. Highly recommend.
… moreSebastian Ortega
This place definitely met the high expectations I went in with. I got their most popular whole hoagie (the Sanchez) for a total of $18 with tax. It came with mozzarella sticks, fries, chicken cutlet pieces, and their “Sanchez” sauce. It was humongous and was extremely filling and delicious. Every bite was so good! My friend got their cheesesteak and it was also amazing. I am definitely coming back to this Nassau Street staple.
… moreAma Boampomaa Ohemeng
The workers are very receptive and respectful. No long wait. Usually they tell you the order will be ready in 15 minutes but mostly comes out earlier than expected. Their souvlakis are the best!
… moreMeredith Holmes
Hoagie Haven was recommended to us by someone who grew up in the Princeton area. We went on a Saturday early evening around 5pm. We walked in and used the touch screen to order, as directed by the staff once we shared we were paying with a card. The staff was busy filling orders, and they were friendly to interact with.
This is a carry out establishment, so ambiance is sort of a silly rating, but it was a pleasant place to stand inside and wait for your food.
They have a variety of hot subs, cold subs, and specials. We ordered 3 6-inch subs. The portions were very generous! Fries were fine and onion rings were tasty.
We liked the cheese steak and chicken cheese steak, just be wanted they are made with long, flat, thin strips of meat rather than shredded thin pieces like a traditional cheese steak. Still delicious!
… moreThis is a carry out establishment, so ambiance is sort of a silly rating, but it was a pleasant place to stand inside and wait for your food.
They have a variety of hot subs, cold subs, and specials. We ordered 3 6-inch subs. The portions were very generous! Fries were fine and onion rings were tasty.
We liked the cheese steak and chicken cheese steak, just be wanted they are made with long, flat, thin strips of meat rather than shredded thin pieces like a traditional cheese steak. Still delicious!
Alessandro Ma
The best late night eats and cheap eats in town. There is a certain mood that gets someone to crave a giant hoagie at 11 pm and those needs are met every single time. Decent price and great hoagies. Sanchez with extra Sanchez sauce is a classic move.
… moreSand Box
Hoagie Haven: A Review of Princeton’s Legendary Institution
Located right on Nassau Street in Princeton, New Jersey, Hoagie Haven is the undisputed champion of the “fat sandwich”—a culinary genre featuring hoagie rolls aggressively stuffed with classic fillings and deep-fried sides. This bustling, unpretentious, and often late-night institution is a rite of passage for students and locals alike, famous for colossal, indulgent creations like the Sanchez (chicken cutlet, mozzarella sticks, fries, and their proprietary Sanchez Sauce) and the Phat Lady (cheesesteak, mozzarella sticks, and fries). Built on fresh bread sourced from the Italian People’s Bakery, Hoagie Haven delivers massive portions, tremendous value, and comforting, messy flavors. While traditional cheesesteaks and cold hoagies are available, the true “Haven” experience is embracing the decadence of their unique specialty sandwiches. Just remember to bring your appetite, and be aware that they have historically been cash-preferred.
Final Verdict
Rating: 5/5
Must-Try: The Sanchez or The Phat Lady
… moreLocated right on Nassau Street in Princeton, New Jersey, Hoagie Haven is the undisputed champion of the “fat sandwich”—a culinary genre featuring hoagie rolls aggressively stuffed with classic fillings and deep-fried sides. This bustling, unpretentious, and often late-night institution is a rite of passage for students and locals alike, famous for colossal, indulgent creations like the Sanchez (chicken cutlet, mozzarella sticks, fries, and their proprietary Sanchez Sauce) and the Phat Lady (cheesesteak, mozzarella sticks, and fries). Built on fresh bread sourced from the Italian People’s Bakery, Hoagie Haven delivers massive portions, tremendous value, and comforting, messy flavors. While traditional cheesesteaks and cold hoagies are available, the true “Haven” experience is embracing the decadence of their unique specialty sandwiches. Just remember to bring your appetite, and be aware that they have historically been cash-preferred.
Final Verdict
Rating: 5/5
Must-Try: The Sanchez or The Phat Lady
John K
The hoagie is average at best, Wawa may even have them beat and I am not a Wawa fan. I am sure it is a quick bite for college students in the area but I wouldn’t consider this to be a great hoagie by any stretch of the imagination. The meat looks thick and could even be pre-sliced.
I am fairly certain that my wife and I both had a minor case of food poisoning after both having shared an Italian hoagie.
… moreI am fairly certain that my wife and I both had a minor case of food poisoning after both having shared an Italian hoagie.
Chris Mccarty
This place would not last six months if there was a real sandwich shop in the area. The bread is not a hoagie roll. It’s like Subway bread it falls apart. The lunchmeat they put in the sandwich tastes like it comes out of a bag pre-sliced. The roast beef was Well done, and the turkey was so salted just made for a very un enjoyable sandwich.
… more