Rachael Marie Harrop
This is probably one of the best pizzas and Pasta dishes (We had the Supreme Pasta) that I have ever eaten. Staff were all superb, as well. Good luck to the Kind Soul with the incredible voice. Such a beautiful Soul. Thank you, Hideaway Pizza. We will be back….we are frequent flyers there.
… moreMabelyn Calvin
I loved the cheesecake, it was prepared by Cassandra. Proof in the pic!!!! The pizza was a little tough. The delivery driver was amazing. I didn’t catch his name but he was very friendly.
… moreLawana Martin
This is my go to pizza place in Stillwater. I have been to other Hideaway locations through Oklahoma and there is something different about the “Original” that sets it above the others. Over the years I have had numbers types of pizzas from here but my favorite is always the Pizza of the Gods! The white sauce and artichoke are amazing. If you want to start it off with an app the garlic bread is my go to, but if you’re a mushroom fan the stuffed mushrooms are always a hit with people I have been with.
… moreRuss Milburn
For a long time this has been the last truly great pizza place I know of. Unfortunately tonight was not the great pizza I’m used to. I’ve always gotten the pepperoni/mushroom. Not for sure why it didn’t measure up, but it may be mostly that the mushrooms were not what they’ve been historically. My wife said they were sliced too thick, but it seems like it was more than just that. It seemed like there were not as many as usual, and I’m just not sure they were as flavorful as usual. If it was not totally the mushrooms I’m not sure what else it could have been. I just know it was not up to the normal GREAT standard I’m used to at the Stillwater Hideaway. Really disappointing. If you guys can figure out what the problem was please fix it. We occasionally take the drive from OKC to Stillwater just to enjoy the great pizza, and I tell everyone that it is worth the drive. I hope that never permanently changes.
… moreSarah Evans
Truly a favorite spot in Stillwater. The vibe, the staff, and the mushrooms are always the same: AMAZING!
… moreJasmine Fly
5 Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Thank You, Hideaway Pizza!
I just wanted to take a moment to say a huge THANK YOU to Hideaway Pizza for offering such a delicious vegan pizza! It’s not always easy to find plant-based options that are both satisfying and full of flavor, but you all have absolutely nailed it. The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the vegan cheese melted beautifully — a rare treat!
As someone who eats plant-based, it means a lot to have a place like yours that goes the extra mile to accommodate different dietary needs without compromising on taste.
Keep up the amazing work!
… moredeependablereviews
Decent pizza and good service, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to go back to this place. They had a nice selection of specialty pizzas and I liked that you can get a mini if you aren’t that hungry. I just wasn’t blown away by the flavors of the pizza. The chicken on the Chicken Florentine was what really bummed me out. Looked and tasted like they just sprinkled some frozen chicken on top of the pizza and baked it. Service was friendly and they came to check on the table often when though they were busy.
… moreRooke Jackson
The ORIGINAL Hideaway is always a great experience. The food is consistently delicious. Service is always helpful and friendly. The atmosphere is nostalgic and perfect for everything from a fun college date night to hangout with family and friends.
… moreJohn West
I have only been to the Stillwater location and all times I have had both excellent service and excellent food. On my most recent visit, we had the Pizza Supreme. Our pizza was perfect!! It was loaded with sausage, pepperoni, green pepper, onion, black olives, and mushrooms. It was the best pizza I’ve had in a very long time.
The staff was on point with their friendliness and attentiveness. I felt like I was welcome as they fulfilled my needs with a cheerful and enthusiastic attitude.
… moreDirty Gerd
Ordered a double pepperoni pizza for delivery and there were maybe 2 slices of pepperoni per slice. We called and they only offered us $3 off the whole pizza which still makes it $32. The owner was very rude on the phone and said she didn’t want to send another pizza during their peak hours. We ordered here frequently but after this treatment we will be ordering from empire instead. I suggest if you order for delivery check the pizza is correct before you sign off because they won’t compensate you for incorrect delivery orders.
… more