Joseph Harrigan
It’s Soup Season at Heritage Deli. Vegetarian Lentil Soup. Thick enough to be mistaken for a Stew!
… moreEdward Johnson
Tried their “Where’s the beef” hero and added gravy and mayo…they knocked it out of the park! They use quality roast beef, I’ll be back
UPDATE: I have since tried their spaghetti and meatballs. Amazing! The spaghetti sauce is very flavorful and is flavored with green peppers! Chefs Kiss!
… moreIlene Hope Malefatto
They have the best grilled chicken cutlets!! The owner is so friendly I always chat with him he is so nice we always have a nice conversation. I hope he continues to flourish he deserves it!
… moreJason Przywara
Absolutely the best egg sandwich on Long Island
Food: …
… moreDanielle Porrazzo
Just ordered 6 sandwiches for me and some of my co-workers for delivery. We all got different ones and all agree they were delicious! I had the chicken salad club wrap and couldn’t finish it I was too full after half, it was stuffed with chicken salad, lettuce and a good amount of bacon! Awesome customer service and the owner delivered my order himself as the place was pretty busy and they didn’t want to run far behind (we ordered at peak lunchtime). We will definitely be ordering again! Harry was super friendly and it shows how much he cares about his business!
… moreKevin Dennis
UPDATED AGAIN 10/2024:
Same name but under new ownership.
They revamped the pricing to be much more reasonable, food is very good and the service is excellent!
UPDATED:
My standard order does not include bacon and my sandwich went from $5.70 to $8.68 in my book that’s a $3 increase on a $6 item. 50%
PREVIOUS:
Just increased prices 50%. WHAT!?!
Always liked their food but… sorry no.
… moreTerry Parrett
I left a very negative review of this deli several months ago. Since that review, the deli has a new owner, and because it’s right around the corner, I figured I’ve give them a shot. I am delighted to report that the food was terrific, the price was competitive, and the service (and new owner) are super friendly. Excellent portions, clean and bright store, just the best. On top of that, probably the best cole slaw I’ve ever had! So happy that there’s a great local deli again!!
… moreAleksander N
Their Hero sandwiches are delicious! I’m always looking for a good hero place in Suffolk county, this is one I’ll definitely visit again, I can’t wait to try their other items too! The Turkey club sandwich is the main one I recommend!
… moreMatt Mayer
House made bagels… best bagels in the area. I grew up around here and have had them all. Maybe best bagels ever? May need to rename to Heritage Bagels. Everyone also very nice and place is clean.
… moreDublinhead
I hate to give a negative review to a small business but in this case I believe it is warranted. I live in walking distance of Heritage Deli but have rarely been there.
This week my kitchen was under construction so I decided to order lunch from Heritage. We have the menu somewhere but I jumped online for convenience. I called in by phone and ordered the Hot RB (hero) with Cheese and Onions. When I went to pick it up I was served by two very competent, pleasant, and friendly female workers.
The problem? I was charged $17.50 for a lunch sandwich. I questioned that on the spot and was advised that the price had just gone up. The website was inaccurate apparently.
The moral of the story?? Simple – $18 for a lunch sandwich in the boondocks of stripmall Long Island is an outrage.
I hear the echo in the distance of social media responses citing “supply chain issues” “we are in line price wise with our competitors” and “our costs have risen exponentially!”
No – it is greed and gross misalignment with reality. $18 for a basic deli sandwich on Long Island is an outrage.
Was it special?? Not even that – it was bang average. Never again.
… more