Jennifer Valles
We love Handmade! Growing up in St. Louis, I was always used to awesome Italian delis and yummy sandwiches on fresh bread with high quality ingredients – Handmade rivals (or tops!) the best delis I’ve ever had a sandwich at! They’re a favorite for us and a local gem. Customer service is top-notch too – great staff who remember us when we come in. All the sandwiches and soups we’ve had are delicious. If you can’t decide, my favorite sandwich is the Roadie! And don’t skip the homemade cookies – they’re amazing too!
… moreTroy Wilkinson
The food was amazing! Service was fast and friendly and The view out the window of the creek with the spring rain was fantastic. My daughter and I both enjoyed it and she’s hard to please.
… moreLinda Jonsmil
My husband and I recently moved to Hillsdale from Western New York. Buffalo is known for its great food. I knew that would be one thing I would miss terribly. The subs at Handmade are A+++ the best subs I’ve ever had!! We tried it on the recommendation of our daughter and am now a regular customer.
… moreKelly Poniatowski
We ate here for lunch while spending a couple days in Hillsdale. Cute shop, super friendly and helpful staff, and delicious food. We all loved our sandwhiches. Reasonably priced too. Our son asked if we could return again. Definitely will if in the area.
… moreEmily Rowe
It’s been a while since I have been there but very good food, dined in and was generally a nice place. I am not thrilled about pricing issues. Just had some of the zucchini sticks which are amazing but not sure how much they cost. Also kind of not thrilled there’s not a ‘ regular ‘ site and only on Facebook.
… moreJeff C
We tried three different sandwiches. All were excellent with great flavor. Even the pickle was stellar. We did carryout but the dine in had great atmosphere. I’d take it over Panera any day.
… moreJohn Shultz
Great spot to visit, the venue and sandwiches were amazing. The staff were polite.
… moreClaire Bedard
The food was delicious and the ambience was pleasant.
The Colombian —really good; coffee mayo was surprisingly pleasant, mild, probably my favorite part. I might do light mayo next time. Pickles added a nice brightness contrast/complement to lighten. I also enjoyed jalapeños on the side, but not everyone likes those.
**The caramelized onions are So. Worthwhile. Yes. Some people have sad, limp, soggy, boring onions BUT NOT HERE.
The Double BA — good, bacon, my opinion not as good as Columbian, but my dad liked his BA just as much as my Colombian.
Southern corn chowder was good and creamy without being too heavy. The mild spicy bite was nice but not overpowering.
… moreKayla
I kid you not when I say I dream about this place. The sandwiches are incredible and they’re so many choices. It’s a cute little shop to sit and eat and they have the best sandwiches! The service is also off the charts.
Prices are what you’d expect from a sandwich shop but the quality is better.
10/10 highly recommend!
… moreHeather Shemanski
My first time here and I am very impressed. Friendly service, great atmosphere and amazing sandwich. I will be back to try some of the other healthy options.
… more