Keenan Broderick
Lockport location. Very clean. Plenty of parking. Line is always short. Always scared silent teenagers working there. All questions are answered in a confusing way. I always order incorrectly (“no that’s the sundae, and that doesn’t have a cookie”). Ice cream melts 30 seconds after receiving. (Enjoy the cold soup). Tastes good though. Cookies are amazing, lots of options, but expensive for size. $5. Overall expensive. Nice dine-in area, basic, clean. Bring your money and have a few cookies.
… moreJack Voltz
Nice staff, really tasty cookies. They are huge cookies, one of them fills you up instantly. I brought some home with me and they stayed good for a few days, that’s really cool. Definitely have with milk. My favorite was The Monster (I think. M&M one).
… moreChris Greiner
Cookie selection was great but in two separate cookies we found a long strand of hair baked into the cookie – unfortunately it is not my first experience with them where this has happened over the years. Just disappointing that this has happened now more than once after giving them a few opportunities. Workers seem very nice but won’t be back now after this happening twice.
… moreDwight Wadsworth
Best cookies around, they are huge and perfectly crispy on the outside while soft on the inside. Awesome flavor selection changes weekly. My family from out of town loves when we bring them. Highly recommend!
… moreShannon Vona
Absolutely delicious, with alot of variety. Expensive but with it. The cost is the only reason why they dont receive 5 starts but prices are comparable to crumble cookie!!!
… moreAshton Taylor
Best cookies ever! They’re huge and moist. They always have different flavors. They even do gluten free and vegan. The chocolate peanut butter is my favorite.
… moreKatie B
Half Baked was such a welcome addition to Lockport when they opened. We’ve been here at least once a month and the cookies are good. The staff has been super hands off and unwelcoming each visit recently and this past experience was all around awful. For $4 a cookie, I wasn’t expecting raw dough. I’m a huge fan of gooey cookies, but this is just plain raw. The employee didn’t even look up when we walked in, it was just cold all around. I want to love them, it’s great to have another local bakery, but this is just disappointing.
… moreJustin Waters
I recently had the opportunity to attend my 20-year class reunion & ordered a 100 mini cookies from Half Baked Cafe with our class colors being Purple, Gold & White and I must say, the cookies they provided for the event were absolutely amazing. Half Baked Cafe understood the assignment & did not disappoint.
The variety of cookies offered was impressive. From classic chocolate chip to decadent double chocolate, there was something for everyone’s taste buds. Each cookie was freshly baked, with a perfect balance of crispy edges and soft, chewy centers. The aroma alone was enough to make my mouth water.
Not only were the cookies visually appealing, but they were also bursting with flavor. The chocolate chip cookies were loaded with generous amounts of high-quality chocolate chips, providing a rich and indulgent experience with every bite. The double chocolate cookies were a chocolate lover’s dream, with a fudgy texture and intense cocoa flavor.
What set these cookies apart was the attention to detail. They were perfectly baked, without a hint of over or undercooking. The flavors were well-balanced, and there was just the right amount of sweetness. It was evident that Half Baked Cafe took pride in their cookie offerings and put in the effort to create a truly exceptional product.
The cookies were not only delicious but also beautifully presented. They were arranged on platters with care, making for an enticing display. The attention to detail extended to the packaging as well allowing guests to easily grab and enjoy their treat without any mess.
Overall, the cookie selection at Half Baked Cafe for my 20-year class reunion was top-notch. They exceeded my expectations in every aspect, from taste and texture to presentation. If you’re ever in need of cookies for an event or simply want to satisfy your sweet tooth, I highly recommend giving Half Baked Cafe a try. You won’t be disappointed!
… morePeter Carmina
Cookies that are meals! Oh so good. I had the chocolate peanut butter cookie and I’m pretty sure it’s the first cookie that I ate show just to enjoy it! My son had the half baked sundae and struggled to pick one cookie and one ice cream because a majority of the flavors they had where his favorite!
And they keep adding items! Now they have the hurricane which is like a blizzard just with a delicious cookie!
… moreHillie Broussard
Cookies, cookies and more cookies! Have a sweet tooth and love cookies & ice cream? This is the place to go. So many wonderful choices of both. Want cookies? They have everything from classic chocolate chip to their exotic combinations. Never had a bad one yet! Are you gluten free or vegan? Don’t worry, they got you covered! Want ice cream too? They have a very extensive list. Enjoy!!
… more