Jenna Squires
☀️Everything was 5 stars, the food was SO GOOD. Dessert, SO GOOD. It’s rare I’m able to find a pickle pizza and they have one! We had a large party (7 kids, 2 adults) and they were able to accommodate us easily and take care of us above and beyond. We felt very welcomed, even loved, and I’m so glad that we found Grumbley’s Pizza while on our Florida vacation. Best pizza we have had in years!! Kid friendly, easy parking, excellent menu. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreMike & Kristal Nardi
We’re not mad… just disappointed. Grumbley’s has been our go to every 1-2 weeks since they opened, and other than the occasional one off here and there, they’ve been consistently excellent and a good value. We’ve made maybe 3 or 4 orders since the change in ownership, and we were happy with the first order, because other than a slight reduction in topping volume, there weren’t any major changes. The next couple orders though, I thought tasted noticeably freezer burnt. My husband didn’t notice it, but I obviously have a more refined pallet than him. So okay, maybe it’s just me, maybe they were using up their old stuff… we gave it one more try tonight and have decided that it’s them, not us. Totally different menu, a 14” is now considered a “large” which on arrival was actually 12” (yes my husband measured it) different cut, not really a big deal, but totally different crust. It reminded me of the Mexican pizza crust we used to get with school lunch, which, ya know, used to hit the spot, but not exactly what we’re looking for anymore. So, sorry New Grumbley’s, but we’ve gotta move on.
… moreRocky Mountain Ecigs
The Pies are still best in town, but staff is now lazy, and just don’t care.
Ordered a carry out. It wasn’t ready when I arrived, no big deal. Asked the front of house staff if I could have some Parm cheese with the Pie. The Pie came up, the back of house was one guy, and he was more concerned with himself than getting orders out. Another front of house had just arrived, and the girl that originally checked on my order, just sat there staring at my pizza on the window counter. Finally, the other girl that just came on grabbed my pie, and of course the first girl didn’t bother to get my cup of Parm cheese finished prior to the pie coming out.
New manager needs to get it together.
… moreDavid Kraskow
Brendan bought the place in 2025, simplified the menu and focused on making top quality pizza & wings. Makes a dynamite cauliflower crust–ask for it, it’s not on the menu–and house-made sauces and coatings. Super welcoming at sit-down but most business is take-out. Brendan served his country and now serves this corner of Titusville. Sorry there was no beer or diet root beer so we just had water. An easy stop for these I-95 travelers! Loved the name, too–lots of jokey possibilities.
… moreJackie Carey
Ordered a takeout to give Grumbleys new ownership 1 more try. We had bought our last one when they first took over.
We were steadfast in our dedication to what we thought was the best pizza to be had. We were assured by the old owners that nothing was going to change.
Well we beg to differ. The sauce used to be plentiful. The ingredients substantial. The crust held up when you picked it up. It was delicious.
$30 out the door for whimpy crust few ingredients and little to no sauce has us bummed out that they sold the place.
We won’t be going back.
… moreJackson Crews
Always a great pizza! Probably our 10th time ordering, sorry for not leaving a review any sooner!
… moreJenuine H
Grumbley’s Pizza is great value for money and the food is delicious! This was our first time dining here and immediately we realised they have an extensive menu of very tempting options.
Jenn was our server, and she was exceptionally attentive and helpful. She encouraged us to try something you wouldn’t expect to get at a pizza place, so I had the Chicken Hunter and my mom had the Chicken Alfredo. The recipe for the Chicken Hunter is the same one used by the old downtown staple, Klobber’s Cafe! These dishes were so tasty and a giant portion size!
We also had garlic puffs with marinara sauce and iced cinnamon treats with blackberry sauce for dessert. We had plenty to bring home leftovers. Tucked into the St. John’s Plaza, Grumbley’s is a great place to get lunch, a meal after working out at the gym, or before going grocery shopping!
… moreJennifer Connors
My coworkers and I decided to treat ourselves and ordered the Sun Burn Pizza and the White Meat Mac bowl… and let’s just say our productivity definitely dropped after that.
The Sun Burn had the perfect kick — flavorful, a little spicy, and absolutely worth every bite. And the white meat Mac bowl? Creamy, cheesy comfort in a bowl. Zero regrets. Would 100% “accidentally” suggest ordering from here again.
If you’re debating it — just do it. Your taste buds will thank you.
… moresattar Boromand
I saw one of the employees reviews and I just wanted to state my claims against it. I came in on a morning my wife and I were there and a server named Rae was there. She walked past our table about 4 times until a nice lady from the kitchen finally came and took our order. The server Rae did not acknowledge us once while we were there and waiting for our drinks and order to be taken. The lady in kitchen helped us even though that isn’t her job and I was very appreciative of her. I placed an order for takeout a week later and the same server was there, I waited over an hour asking how long my order would take and she never gave me a response or answer. I was very upset with how unprofessional the girl handled the situation. The manager came into work and she was very attentive, sat down with me and let me talk to her about my issue. She was very swift to get my order done and even gave me an extra pizza for free and didn’t charge me! There were other customers that the Rae girl was serving that same day who received wrong orders even people dining in! The food overall will always be good and the manager was the sweetest girl and was the only one willing to help me that day. Shes the ONLY reason i even changed my mind about ordering from grumbleys again.
… moreJonathan Feliciano
First time here, tbh this was a very pleasant surprise! The service was amazing and the pizza even better. We were 3 and got the garlic bread, half portion. Trust me it was enough. And we also got the supreme 18″ pizza, It was too much. We saved some for tomorrow. And we were surprised with free dessert, some cinnamon sugar glazed bread. We dont know if its normal but it was great to get free dessert. Overall will recommend to anyone. 20/10!
*Update* We have been here about 4 times now and it has not dissapointed at all. Always the same quality and good service.
… more