Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
NYC-style deli serving sandwiches on housemade bread, plus salads, hot dogs & bagels.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 224 E Market St, Smithfield, NC 27577
Phone: (919) 934-9100
Website: http://www.gothamsdeli.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Gotham’s Deli – Best NY Deli in Johnston County, NC
The best place to eat in Smithfield! Enjoy fresh New York-style deli sandwiches and take in our New York memorabilia.
Gotham’s Deli Smithfield NC – Facebook
Gotham’s Deli Smithfield NC, Smithfield. 4240 likes · 4 talking about this · 3300 were here. A traditional NY Deli. Also serving home made Salads,…
Gotham’s Deli – Johnston County Visitors Bureau
Located along the main street of Smithfield, this authentic New York-Style deli is a local favorite and attracts visitors as well – enjoy deli sandwiches, …
Reviews
Rebecca M
Gotham’s Deli is a great place to stop if you are looking for lunch in Downtown Smithfield. It is similar to a New York City deli but it is located in North Carolina.
The walls are decorated in sports memorabilia and September 11th tributes. When you walk in, you will see the Statue of Liberty.
I tried to sit in the Mets section, but that was taken as it is a busy place, so I sat near the Yankees. I was ok with the photo of Don Mattingly and don’t hate the Yankees, I just love the Mets. I made sure to spend some time in that section before leaving, seeing the 1986 tributes to Mike Piazza, Jose Reyes, and David Wright. It is just fun to be surrounded by the memorabilia.
The sandwiches also follow in the New York theme. I ordered the Mr. Met, it had ham, turkey, and roast beef with lettuce, provolone, and tomatoes. I’ve had it before, so I knew it was good and ordered the full size rather than a half. I enjoyed every bite of it.
The service was friendly, and they have daily specials with a different sub featured each day. The food was prepared fresh and fast.
If you are looking for a high-quality sub, this is the place to order from
… moreThe walls are decorated in sports memorabilia and September 11th tributes. When you walk in, you will see the Statue of Liberty.
I tried to sit in the Mets section, but that was taken as it is a busy place, so I sat near the Yankees. I was ok with the photo of Don Mattingly and don’t hate the Yankees, I just love the Mets. I made sure to spend some time in that section before leaving, seeing the 1986 tributes to Mike Piazza, Jose Reyes, and David Wright. It is just fun to be surrounded by the memorabilia.
The sandwiches also follow in the New York theme. I ordered the Mr. Met, it had ham, turkey, and roast beef with lettuce, provolone, and tomatoes. I’ve had it before, so I knew it was good and ordered the full size rather than a half. I enjoyed every bite of it.
The service was friendly, and they have daily specials with a different sub featured each day. The food was prepared fresh and fast.
If you are looking for a high-quality sub, this is the place to order from
Lonnie Brame
I am from Long Island. This is NOT a good bagel. Taste like store bought. Its almost $5. I will be going back to Raleigh. I wanted to try more food but I wont. Shame to say you are from Long Island with a bagel tasting like this. If you are from Long Island, you would know the water makes the bagel. For what I got here, it’s worth the gas and time to go to Raleigh, Cary, or Wake Forest.
… moreAdam Snell
Gotham’s Deli is located in downtown Smithfield with plenty of free parking options on the street on a Saturday. We parked about a block away which allowed for a nice little stroll and visits to some of the other shops along the way. Wheelchair accessible and easy to find.
Gotham’s atmosphere is themed in New York sports memorabilia and articles about NYC. Fountain drinks are located in the back of the dining area and features Pepsi products, sweet tea and unsweet tea. The massive menu features Breakfast options and lunch/dinner options as well.
Service was great, more than happy to provide some samples of sauces and chicken salad as well as explaining sandwiches and options.
Food was good. I do feel that there were some things that could have been changed to the meals that we ate that could have improved the construction. However overall, the meal was fine. We would definitely try it again if we are back in the area and wanted sandwiches. The Carrot cake was a little dry but had good flavor. The chocolate chip cookie had an odd flavor but was very soft. The buffalo chicken sandwich has cream cheese, and the buffalo sauce has ranch in it which made it a very mild in Buffalo flavor. Plus the lettuce being sliced and shredded made it so the lettuce fell out of the sandwich a bit. The sourdough bread was good and nicely toasted. I opted for the bowtie turkey pasta which had a good creamy flavor.
(updated to correct autocorrects from phone)
… moreGotham’s atmosphere is themed in New York sports memorabilia and articles about NYC. Fountain drinks are located in the back of the dining area and features Pepsi products, sweet tea and unsweet tea. The massive menu features Breakfast options and lunch/dinner options as well.
Service was great, more than happy to provide some samples of sauces and chicken salad as well as explaining sandwiches and options.
Food was good. I do feel that there were some things that could have been changed to the meals that we ate that could have improved the construction. However overall, the meal was fine. We would definitely try it again if we are back in the area and wanted sandwiches. The Carrot cake was a little dry but had good flavor. The chocolate chip cookie had an odd flavor but was very soft. The buffalo chicken sandwich has cream cheese, and the buffalo sauce has ranch in it which made it a very mild in Buffalo flavor. Plus the lettuce being sliced and shredded made it so the lettuce fell out of the sandwich a bit. The sourdough bread was good and nicely toasted. I opted for the bowtie turkey pasta which had a good creamy flavor.
(updated to correct autocorrects from phone)
Smith Steven
The atmosphere,service and especially the employees are inviting , friendly and make you want to come and sit down to their exclusive and delicious menu. No matter what I order I have never been happier. Mad props to the owner who leads with fairness, integrity and an emphasis on satisfied customers! I love this place. Reminds me of NY style.
… moremichael brown
The sandwiches were just ok. They reminded me of the sandwiches you can buy from the deli at a grocery store for half the price. My wife’s sandwich had some kind of fake bacon on it. The atmosphere is nice and the people were friendly. Parking was fine. Prices are typical.
… moreVicki Darmody
Haven’t even finished my sandwich (combo meal). Will definitely be taking half home! So awesome has to stop eating to complete this review.
Young man suggested Dark Knight! And I tried the home made potato salad. Not like my sis’ but it has me hooked! Awesome!
I blindly picked this on way home because I didn’t want the same! And it was a really great choice. If your in the area (Smithfield NC), put it on your list of places to eat!!!!
I’ll definitely go out of my way again, and maybe soon. Sure hope I try something different just to make sure.
… moreYoung man suggested Dark Knight! And I tried the home made potato salad. Not like my sis’ but it has me hooked! Awesome!
I blindly picked this on way home because I didn’t want the same! And it was a really great choice. If your in the area (Smithfield NC), put it on your list of places to eat!!!!
I’ll definitely go out of my way again, and maybe soon. Sure hope I try something different just to make sure.
Rachel Zechman
I love this place, I have been coming here for years. They have many different sandwich options that are very delicious. The sandwiches are also a pretty good size for a decent price. My favorites are the ones called the Brooklyn and the dark knight. The atmosphere of the restaurant is nice as well. Very much New York themed with lots of New York decorations everywhere.
… moreMax Wiley
Get a taste of a classic New York deli at Gotham. Sandwiches are tasty and fresh made, the counter is humming and the decor is classic! (I wish they had big fat everything New York style bagels but alas I think you have to go north for that) Come visit Ava Gardner’s hometown and stop by Gotham for a sammy.
… moreAmanda 1095
Gotham Deli in Smithfield is a top-notch spot that never disappoints. Every sub and sandwich is spot on, and the friendly service makes the experience even better. Highly recommend!
… moreLeeann D
I visited Gotham with a friend while I was in town for a few days. Fun and inviting atmosphere with all the NY memorabilia your heart can desire.
I ordered the turkey ruben called the Rachel and oh boy was it delicious! I grabbed a slice of cheesecake to go and it was amazing. Many options to choose from, so the hardest part was deciding what to get.
You’ll definitely want to preplan if your are going to downtown Smithfield, so you’ll know where to park.
… moreI ordered the turkey ruben called the Rachel and oh boy was it delicious! I grabbed a slice of cheesecake to go and it was amazing. Many options to choose from, so the hardest part was deciding what to get.
You’ll definitely want to preplan if your are going to downtown Smithfield, so you’ll know where to park.