Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie: Home
Here at Goshen Pizza Tomato pie, we serve a large variety of food such as jumbo buffalo wings, gourmet pizzas, pasta, subs, and hoagies.
Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie – Goshen, NY – 244 W Main St – Hours …
Order Hours About. 10:00 AM-9:45 PM; Shop address is 244 W Main St, Goshen, NY 10924244 W Main St, Goshen, NY 10924; (845) 294-3393.
Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Goshen, NY! Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Reviews
Johanna Falber
Excellent food. The sauce is phenomenal. Their Cesar salad is made with a home made dressing on the side – yes! Their meatballs are delish. Service is friendly, fast. They’re very customer service oriented. Went there today w my son and the young lady behind the counter is adorable and accommodating. I told her I wanted the Disney villians poster hanging up by the rest rooms and she laughed and said she would be sure to tell the owner. She never said, ok crazy lady. EXCELLENTall the time, NEVER had a bad experience or even a flaw, even when I Door Dash.
… moreSebastian Melendez
Ordered two calzones and both were terrible — extremely bland, poorly made, and honestly hard to finish. The garlic knots arrived cold, which shows a complete lack of care. Overall, the food was gross and a huge disappointment. Definitely would not recommend this place to anyone.
… moremeditacion relaxing
I went to Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie and had a very disappointing experience regarding food hygiene. I ordered 4 Beef Party with cheese and saw the person preparing them take cash from another customer and then, without washing his hands, touch the cheese inside the oven to check if the party were ready. I politely told him that wasn’t right and asked for new parties but he refused and started arguing with me. In the end, he gave me a refund I asked for the manager and he said he was the owner he refused to give me his name
It’s unacceptable for someone to handle food right after touching money without washing their hands, and even worse to respond defensively instead of fixing the issue. I hope they improve their hygiene practices and customer service, because with that kind of behavior, I wouldn’t return or recommend this place.
… moreIt’s unacceptable for someone to handle food right after touching money without washing their hands, and even worse to respond defensively instead of fixing the issue. I hope they improve their hygiene practices and customer service, because with that kind of behavior, I wouldn’t return or recommend this place.
Aleks Velkovski
I think the pizza is very good. Lots of slices with tasty toppings thats aren’t typical.
… moreJillette Nazareno
Best pizza I’ve had from Goshen in a longggg time! Trust me because I grew up through all the openings and closings of various pizza places. Delivery is on time & the staff is friendly. I got a gluten free and regular pie, both were so yummy and I was genuinely so happy to have such a good pizza close to home.
The salad was clean and fresh and so were the garlic knots. Everything was a reasonable price as well. They even give you a gluten free pizza cutter which is awesome if you have allergies!
Definitely ordering from here from now on and you should too.
… moreThe salad was clean and fresh and so were the garlic knots. Everything was a reasonable price as well. They even give you a gluten free pizza cutter which is awesome if you have allergies!
Definitely ordering from here from now on and you should too.
Kathryn Dowling
First and only time that I’ve ordered from this restaurant. I decided to pick up the pizza so that it would be fresh and hot. Although I was waiting for the pizza to be made somehow by the time they handed it to me, it was cold. So I’m assuming that the wing that they were making for me took longer than the pizza and apparently they didn’t even attempt to keep the pizza warm. However, not only was the pizza cold, it was burnt and actually hard. The cheese was not gooey at all, it was also hard.. The wings were only drumettes. There were no flats at all, and they were sitting in a soup of buffalo sauce. Unfortunately, both the pizza and the wings were inedible.
… moremark acosta
I ordered my food today for delivery at 5:24pm and after 3 phone calls, my food was finally delivered at 7:41pm and it was all cold. I had to reheat the entire $45 order so that we could have a hot dinner. Extremely unsatisfied with the service and the excuses I received from the staff when I called to inquire about my food.
They lost a customer tonight…
… moreThey lost a customer tonight…
Lauren Greska
We are staying at Legoland and decided to order door dash from here for dinner. We ordered a Neapolitan pizza, garlic knots, French fries and a chicken parm sub. The garlic knots were left out and the chicken was completely burned on the sub. The kids said the pizza was good but we are disappointed by the quality of the sub and leaving off items. When I called to tell them they told me because we ordered through door dash there was nothing they could do and said to call door dash for a refund. While door dash did refund us for the missing and burned items I am still without dinner. If you’re from out of town, don’t bother!
… moreFrank Smeriglio
In addition to great pizza, we’ve ordered their catering trays which are also excellent!
… moreHannah Mahon
They got my order completely wrong.And when I called back to ask them for a buffalo wrap, they accused me of lying and even called me back saying, if I was sure, eventually they sent the rap that was missing that I had already paid for back.And they asked to have the container that didn’t have the wrap.I will never use them again.The woman on the phone was insulted and accusatory.Do not use them and the food sucked
… more