Ashley Freeman
Great staff; super fun atmosphere. The cookie is just a fat cookie with a cute little design. Wouldn’t say there’s anything super special about it although it is good. Cool that they offer milk as a drink option. Very nostalgic of childhood milk and cookies and the Count Chocula cookie is “vintage” so to speak.
… moreMichele Ford
Cool concept, who doesn’t like warm cookies with milk. They have limited options ( 3 cookie options when we visited). The flavors were unique ( Milky Way, Count Chocula, PB). They didn’t have simple plain chocolate chip or sugar cookies. The cookies were average. You can purchase cookie flights!
They have a cute courtyard with outside seating (tables and chairs).
No vegan options available.
They also serve breakfast sandwiches, that smelled great!
… moreKina Ramos
The cookies were amazing, amazing, amazing. We got a fresh batch of the biscotti butter cookie-something or other- December flavor- It was amazing! Food was great, staff was friendly. Five stars! Four stars because the hardly any seating & store hours were weird- we wanted to return for more but they were closed for the rest of our stay. We would have gotten cookies every night if we could have! Super delicious. Tik-tok recommended this place to us.
… moreRafi Marques
Truly a Salem hidden gem!
I always heard good things about the place so when I passed by it I knew I had to try!
They have weekly flavors with a range of 3 options you can choose from, plus a salty treat
When I visited they had Oreo, Twix, Dubai Chocolate and a Vegan Mac and Cheese pastry
I tried the Dubai option for about $4 and it tasted soooo good!!
Also the place is super cool, it has this astronaut on the wall and a phone that you can dial a number and hear movie quotes!!
I got John Wick when I tried it!
… moreApril Zaevi
I got the vegan Mac & cheese with spicy beyond meat (I believe).. there is a little side of siracha mayo.. it was absolutely delicious. Also got the vegan dubai chocolate fatty. Cute place and I love that you offer vegan options.
… moreTonya Reed
As one who grew up loving a warm and soft cookie, this place is well worth it. Their flavors are updated every Friday. We had the Oreo, Dubi chocolate, the Twix. I bought the double – 2 of each & have no regrets.
Go and enjoy each cookie!
… moreBradley McElroy
Simple, delicious cookies! We loved the three flavors of the week and wish we could’ve tried more. Soft, rich, and perfectly baked — definitely a must-stop when you’re in Salem.
… moreNatasha Nunez
Goodnight Fatty in Salem is one of my favorite weekend treats! Every week they release three new creative cookie flavors and they’re always delicious The cookies are warm, soft, and gooey in the middle! I love that the flavors are always rotating, so every visit feels fun and unique! If you love cookies, this place is absolutely a must try! ✨
… moreKristin
As soon as you walk in here you are hit with the aroma of freshly baked cookies! It smelled amazing!! But even better, the cookies tasted amazing too! They are open late, so perfect to satisfy your sweet tooth after walking around Salem all day!
… moreMelissa L
Stop here. Just do it!! Sooooo good and fun. The employees are wonderful and the atmosphere is great! And let’s talk the cookies-the BEST! This is definitely a spot to stop in Salem. We sat outside and enjoyed the flight of cookies. Highly recommend!
… more