Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–3 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–3 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–12 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 545 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: (317) 602-3401
Website: https://www.goodfellaspizzeria.com/mass-ave
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mass Ave – Indianapolis – Goodfellas Pizzeria
Location & Hours. Goodfellas Mass Ave 545 Massachusetts Ave Indianapolis, Indiana 46204 (317) 602-3401 · Get directions. Monday. 11:00 am. -. 12:00 am. Tuesday.
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave | Indianapolis IN – Facebook
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave. On Indy’s vibrant Mass Ave, enjoy New York–style pizza and classic cocktails in a stylish spe …
Menu – Goodfellas Pizzeria
View the full Goodfellas Pizzeria menu online! Explore pizza, sides, salads, and more in Indiana, Kentucky, Ohio, and Tennessee.
Last Updates
Reviews
D Mathias B
If you are looking for a solid slice and a unique atmosphere, this is the place. The pizza is consistently delicious, featuring large slices that are authentic to the style. Do not miss the backroom bar; the lighting and décor create a moody, sophisticated ambiance that feels distinct from the main restaurant. It is an ideal location for a night out.
… moreArielle Poynter
As chapter president, I’m always on the lookout for places that can handle our big events and late-night cravings. Let me tell you, Goodfellas Pizza totally delivered . The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh, and slices were MASSIVE. Plus, the pick up was super fast, which is a lifesaver when you’re trying to plan an event!! Seriously, if you’re looking for a crowd-pleasing pizza place for your next sorority event, Goodfellas is the way to go. 10/10 would recommend!
… morekristen keeling
Best pizza I’ve ever had!
This West coast girl finally understands why you only get a slice and not a whole pie!
… moreThis West coast girl finally understands why you only get a slice and not a whole pie!
Jamie Ginsberg
Delicious crust and sauce. To be very clear, I had a rough night here, it took awhile to get our pizzas and we were starving, and my pizza was made wrong and had to be remade. And, I’m giving them 5 stars! To be fair, it was Saturday night and it was jam packed with pizzas flying everywhere and I am difficult with no cheese. Alex ate most of his sausage and cheese pizza and enjoyed the rest for breakfast. The staff was exceedingly nice and offered to make it right with a dessert etc. which I didn’t want. I enjoyed the vibes of the restaurant and the reaction in fixing the order was prompt and respectful. We both enjoyed our pizzas and highly recommend this as the spot for pizza in Indy!
… moreBrian Brooks
Love this place. Hate making reviews like this. Been frequenting this establishment since it opened on Mass Ave. My review is based off your corporate policy (1 star) of not selling things you don’t have available and waiting off to the side. This place is always busy when I go. So sometimes what I order isn’t available. They refuse to sell me something that isn’t in the “window”. It’s always coming though and they tell me to go past the checkout and wait until they have what I want becomes available. It’s happened no lie at least twelve times. Every time I’m waiting and they bring said pizza to the “window”, the ten people in line behind me order the entirety of the newly available pizza while I’m waiting for them to recognize me for what I wanted. Then it’s gone. Pepperoni pizza. That’s it. Nothing crazy. I’m more than happy to pay and wait as long as it takes to get said pizza. Staff is busy. I get it. If this happened once or twice, I’d get it. But this happens way too much and I always tell them that. Went last Saturday (2/7) and I argued with staff my stance about this. They did however get me taken care of Saturday and I appreciated that and gave a 50% tip. But it’s the policy I have issue with. A complementary drink is nice and most appreciated, but I could care less about a free drink if I have to wait for an entire whole other pizza to be made to try and hope they remember when they make it available that that’s what I wanted. A better system is recommended, like let’s say letting someone pay and that person gets the first available thing ordered when it becomes available. I’m not going to stop going here, but I’m probably going somewhere else next time this happens for my own self preservation/sanity if this continues to be the corporate policy on unavailable items.
… moreDusty Schulz
A great Pizza place for dine in, carry out, and picking up a fresh slice bigger than your face!
I’d highly recommend checking them out if you’re in town! Their staff were kind, their website was easy to use, and prices werent bad at all!
… moreI’d highly recommend checking them out if you’re in town! Their staff were kind, their website was easy to use, and prices werent bad at all!
dana h
I highly recommend bringing your food into the speakeasy. The food is reasonably priced, and the pizza is great. It’s a nice vibe. I will caution that it can take a while if you order an entire pizza, but they always have pizza by the slice available.
… moreTiffany Spencer
We wanted to grab a late night bite after leaving The Garage area. We parked took a short walk and we were greeted immediately the cashier was very pleasant. Pictured is the meatball jalapeno pizza! I asked for both sauces highly recommend.
… moreRaquel Cornejo
I had been coming here maybe every so often, my brother had a birthday yesterday and let him choose what he wanted for his birthday dinner and he chose this VERY expensive pizza, I worked overtime to get this meal for him and the whole family to share. I spent $168.00 on this pizza, just to bring it home to be burnt, stiff, un edible. EVERYONE, even my brother said how gross it was. I felt shot down because I tried to rely on this company to give my brother a good birthday meal and it turned out to be a complete disaster. I had ordered ahead of time, for 3 PM, I called around 12 pm to reschedule the order for a bit later of time. At 4 PM. They agreed to reschedule it for me (I have screenshots of the time I had called, PROOF.) and I called about my order later on and the manager ADMITS that she had left it under a heated area for a hour and some minutes before I picked up and proceeds to tell me I WAS LATE? CALLING ME A LIAR?? I had rescheduled the time for this pizza and they are saying I’m LYING?? I have SCREENSHOTS for when I had called.I was only offered half of my refund when 4/5 of these pizzas were completely wasted. I will never be returning here again. Rude service and un edible pizza, I could’ve gotten better pizza at the mall.
… moreMiranda Andrews
Don’t ever trust your boyfriend to order pizza! This man got 2 22″ pizzas and when I tell you these pizzas are MASSIVE I’m not joking, the slices themselves are friggin huge! We also got cheese bread and bread sticks and the bread sticks are so big they fold them in half to put them in a box! The pizzas themselves were AMAZING definitely get the Vinny! Ricotta cheese on a pizza!? WHY HAVE I NEVER DONE THAT BEFORE!? IT’S SO GOOD! I will warn you if you get the 22″ you will be eating it for DAYS it’s huge! The cheese bread is really good too and they have a variety of sauces! We can’t have bread sticks marinara let’s be real if you’re an out of towner like myself and love pizza you will definitely enjoy this place!
… more