Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Family-owned and serving Florida’s Treasure Coast since 1996, Goodfellas Pizza is known for handcrafted pizzas, hot wings, subs, fresh salads, and homemade pasta. With nine locations across Port St. Lucie, Jensen Beach, Fort Pierce, Jupiter, Vero Beach, Sebastian, and more. We offer fast delivery, takeout, and reliable corporate catering. Whether you’re craving a meatball sub, Caesar salad, or the best pepperoni pizza around, Goodfellas brings bold flavors and quality you can count on.
Casual restaurant offering NY-style pizzas, subs & pastas, with delivery available.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2993 S 25th St, Fort Pierce, FL 34981
Phone: (772) 465-6525
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
goodfellaspizza2.hrpos.heartland.us
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Goodfella’s Pizza Pasta Subs | Family Pizza Restaurant near me
Goodfellas Pizza serves fresh pizza, pasta, subs, wings, and family meals across the Treasure Coast Florida. Order online for pickup or delivery from your …
Order Goodfellas Pizza (Fort Pierce) – Menu & Prices – Uber Eats
Use your Uber account to order delivery from Goodfellas Pizza (Fort Pierce) in Fort Pierce. Browse the menu, view popular items, and track your order.
Goodfella’s Pizza – 825 Seaway Dr Suite 7, Fort Pierce, FL 34949
PASTA DISHES · Pasta w/Marinara Sauce. Includes fresh Tossed Salad & homemade Garlic Knots · Pasta w/Garlic & Olive Oil. Includes fresh Tossed Salad & homemade …
Reviews
Scott Loken
Good place to order. Reasonable prices too. Delivery fast and friendly. For credit card orders they have a credit card machine on hand. So, no need to give your credit card over the phone. Food is amazing, if I could say one thing though. Please do some updating on your website menu. It’s not completely accurate…. but I still love the place all around. Thank you so very much…..
… moreBerea Standifer
I’m very disappointed in this place i ordered my food from them several times and me being a loyal customer i was thru up under the bus the manager took my order and got it completely wrong i called and told him my order was completely wrong and he gave me a nasty attitude bout my order and refused to give me a refund this supposed to be a greek salad with blackened chicken with extra onions olives and pickles and this is what i received
… moreMila Wogalter
Expected a bit more from pizza (not sure what exactly, sure try rising crust the next time), tho toppings were excellent and, amazingly, NO heartburn after the red sauce! We tried “meat lovers”, and simple “cheese pizza” and something else with olives and meat and cheese on a thin crust, but THE BEST were garlic knots, omg to die for!!! Cannoli were “to go” because there was no room left to fit anything in we sure shall be back!!! Got the rest of the food nicely packed to enjoy at home; the staff was nice, smiling, happy, polite and helpful! The place is clean and cozy inside, overall 5 ⭐ plus!
… moreMichiko Kroupa
Stopped by this pizza place recently for dinner. The atmosphere was casual and family-friendly, and the staff was polite and helpful. The pizza came out hot and the crust had a nice texture — not too thick or too thin. The toppings were fresh, though I felt the sauce could’ve used a bit more flavor.
Service was fairly quick, and prices seemed reasonable for what you get. It’s a decent spot to grab a bite with friends or family if you’re in the area. Nothing fancy, but overall a good, straightforward pizza experience.
… moreService was fairly quick, and prices seemed reasonable for what you get. It’s a decent spot to grab a bite with friends or family if you’re in the area. Nothing fancy, but overall a good, straightforward pizza experience.
Frank W. Cowles II (Design&Illustration)
Always a great pizzeria, either by the pie or by the slice. With many many different locations, it is easy to locate a Goodfella’s pizza somewhere in St Lucie county.
… moreMiltreda Kress
First time & last time I’ll ever order from this place. I placed a delivery order to my job for my lunch break at 1:36pm, I was given a delivery time for 2:45pm. I waited to clock out for lunch until 2:45pm. My delivery had not arrived. I then called the store to inquire about my delivery, was apologized to & told they were sending it out right now, that was at 2:51pm. My job is literally the next red light down from the store. At 3:13pm I called again to cancel the order & ask for my money back as I now wouldn’t even have time to eat it before having to clock back in from lunch. The sad part is that I now won’t be able to eat until 11:00 tonight bc I go straight to another job from this job & don’t get home until then. Most unreliable service I have ever experienced, especially from a business less than 1 mile away.
Update: Due to not eating anything all day, not even breakfast, I decided to place an order with Domino’s. I placed the order at 3:50pm & by 4:08pm my food was delivered. I believe Goodfellas needs to take lessons from Domino’s.
… moreUpdate: Due to not eating anything all day, not even breakfast, I decided to place an order with Domino’s. I placed the order at 3:50pm & by 4:08pm my food was delivered. I believe Goodfellas needs to take lessons from Domino’s.
Louis Pegno
I heard the pizza was very good so I decided to order a large pie with extras on it with an important meeting I had a a quick bite. Never got the pizza and address they got completely wrong because of a very bad reception on the phone . Young lady very nasty and bad attitude. And just got that I’ll never go there or order again. People working for you like that will destroy the business completely. Very bad customer service… fix it cuz…
… moreTaharah
Lil man enjoys pizza, cheese and veggie to be exact. So like an amazing mom, I wanted to fulfill his love of pizza. While visiting family in Fort Pierce, my uncle told me about Goodfellas. So my little man and I decided to give it a try. The one we went to is in a small strip next to a gas station. The place offers indoor seating and huge slices of pizza!! They didn’t have veggie available at the time, so Lil man ended up with cheese, and I got a steak and cheese stuffed roll. At first sight I thought my child can’t eat all that….boy was I wrong. He ate the entire slice. I loved my stuffed it was sooooo cheesy and they did not skimp on the steak. I will definitely be back.
… moreGerrard Adams
Rude manager, kept saying he would call me, and acted like he didn’t know me when I called him back. Was very rude. Idk if the food was good, I just walked away. Just be honest with people no need to be nasty.
… moreChris Quigley
Have been going here for 15 years. I called in for pickup and non english man was totally disrespectful. I will never order here again. You lost business from everyone i know. Plus your food has taken a downfall. Im from New York you guys are a joke.
… more