Kivalina Lawrence
When I worked in Fort Smith Goodfellas was a frequent lunch choice when my coworkers and I wanted to go out together. Sometimes the service is a bit slow if they’re busy, but the food is always worth the wait. Everything is flavourful, well prepared, and you get a big portion for a reasonable price. I’d like to give a shoutout to the gentleman who I’m pretty sure is the owner. He’s always very pleasant and welcoming.
PS: I always get a to-go order of their bread and dipping oil. It’s just too good to pass up!
… moreLyndel Hobbs
We’ve been coming here since it opened. Consistently great Italian. We’ve tried most of their entrees and they’ve each been delicious. We particularly like the Tortellini Alfredo–best Alfredo we’ve had. The bread, the pizzas, spaghetti/meatballs, lasagna, and others are wonderful. Their 3 new soups are also amazing. They have great lunch prices as well. The servers are very pleasant and helpful.
… moreShawna Thomas
The food was so good! The BREAD!!!! ❤️ our family has only dined there once but will definitely be back. I’d like to try their pizza because the photos I’ve seen look delicious!
… moreChristina Bastible
I thought my favorite Italian restaurant in the area was Pasta Grill… and then I tried **Good Fellas**! The food is absolutely **wonderful**. The bread is outstanding, the marinara sauce is perfect, and everything I’ve tried has been delicious. Their pizza and chicken parmesan are both amazing: easily some of the best I’ve had anywhere.
If I could, I’d eat here once a week! The quality, flavor, and atmosphere make it a must-try for anyone who loves Italian food. Highly recommend!
… moreMika Gruszka
Trust these stars! This place was amazing!! They deserve all the good reviews! The server was fast and friendly. The food was fresh and delicious. They served us authentic Italian food, it’s gotta be the best Italian food I’ve had in years. 0live g@rden has nothing on this place. Goodfellow’s has amazing staff and food, please give them a try and i assure you you’ll want to come back and write a good review too.
If you want to know about my dish pictured, it’s the shrimp and chicken tortellini Alfredo. Shrimp was fresh and popping against my teeth. Chicken was falling apart it was so tender. I loved every bit. The mozzarella sticks were never frozen. I’ll be back for sure.
… moreM. T.
We didn’t have a pleasant experience here tonight the food was extremely bland and a bit overpriced, the rudest part were the waitresses they had no table manners and were extremely rude they didn’t even ask if we wanted dessert before bringing the check and kept glaring at us when we were eating, my face was a bit injured tonight and they kept staring at us and we’re just very rude. I wouldn’t come back I have been wanting to try this place but they lost my business tonight, they didn’t even say hello or make us feel like we should be eating there. The fettuccine Alfredo had no flavor. We will not be coming back
… moreBeth Greenfield
This was our first time but definitely not our last. Our server made excellent suggestions and boy am I glad we listened. We shared a trio platter (Momma Mia) and got a Greek salad and fried ravioli. Everything was perfect.
… moreCMA Birdie
A good size group of friends went after church today. My wife & I have eaten here many times & about half the group today has at least once. Those that hadn’t were very pleased.
I started always getting the lasagna, but kept putting off trying the veal parmesan. Once I finally tried it, that’s all I want when we go. I don’t even look at the menu. Good sized portions & very good bread!
… moreShannon Newerth-Henson
I’ve been seeing so many positive things about Goodfella’s on a local food blogger’s Facebook page. I had to go try it! My coworkers and I visited this week. It is a great lunch spot! The service was 5 stars!! Our server was friendly and attentive. The restaurant was clean and it is a creative environment. The food was great! The bread was fresh and delicious. I ordered the Spinach Ravioli and it also tasted fresh and oh so good! Two of my coworkers ordered the Chicken Marghertia. I think they really enjoyed it! One of my other coworkers ordered alfredo with veal and he said it was so good and tender. He wasn’t sure what to expect, and he was very happy with his meal! Thank you Goodfella’s Pizza & Pasta!!
… morePattie Grider
We had never tried this place before but we were very impressed with the food and the wait staff. I would highly recommend anyone giving it a try. We will be back again.
… more