Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Chain eatery specializing in thick-crust pizzas, also offering sides & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 601 South Merino Ave, Eddyville, IA 52553
Phone: (641) 969-5350
Website: http://godfathers.com/
Related Web Results
Godfather’s Pizza: Home
It’s not just pizza, it’s a meal! Our pies are piled high with quality ingredients and topped with heaping layers of perfectly melted cheese, so you enjoy a …
Godfather’s Pizza Express, 601 S Merino Ave, Eddyville, IA 52553, US
Godfather’s Pizza Express in Eddyville is known for their pizza pies piled high with fresh quality ingredients, delivering pizza the way it was meant to be.
BP- Godfather’s Pizza Eddyville | Restaurants – Travel Iowa
705 Main St. Eddyville, IA 52553. Ph: (641) 969-4208 0.63 miles away. Welcome Inn Bar & Grill. Casual Dining. Welcome Inn Bar & …
Reviews
Jason Haring
On January 21,2026 in the evening I seen they only had a couple of pan pizzas in the warmer so I ordered a large pizza. I went and got fuel and came back in to see that they put all the pan pizzas in the oven for the warmer before my large pizza. Poor customer service
… moreKelli Elswick
My pizza was almost ten minutes late and I wasn’t even offered an apology. Just told to go pay, so I did. Were not friendly to me in anyway. They were talking to their friends over the counter. While the other was preparing all the mini pizzas for the warmer. The warmer was well stocked with fresh food. I came back to pick up my pizzas, still they said nothing. Was a bit awkward and grabbed my pizza. When I arrived home, my pizza was not made correctly, they offered to remake it, great. Had my husband grab the remake, get it home and the whole middle of the pizza is doughy and uncooked… So had to have my kids eat the first one and just pick off Sausage, as they don’t like it because it’s spicy… The second pizza went to the refrigerator and I’m not sure if I’ll try to finish cooking it or just throw it away. Nothing especial, filling, but not good. Also don’t think people want food poisoning, from under cooked pizza dough. The only positives here are the store was clean and the cashier’s were very kind.
… moreTaylor Bolsinger
Waited at the Chester‘s chicken counter for over 10 minutes before my south and a group of people in front of me were recognized. When I finally placed my order at the lady who took the order was completely rude and you could feel that she could care less about how we were treated and if we were taken care of at all. When I went to finally check out at the registers, there were two more people standing around talking instead of taking care of the customers. The food I got was completely disgusting and dried out as if it had been sitting there for longer than it should have been. I will not be back.
… moreTailor Brown
Young staff, not very attentive to customers at the counter and usually just keep cooking or cleaning while you stand here. They’ve brought up politics and religion several times without prompt but they are nice and friendly once you get their attention. Pizza’not that great, you’d be better off with Casey’s, but chicken is pretty dang good and burgers are ok.
… moreNancy Lightle
When we first moved to Eddyville we loved the fact that there was a Godfathers pizza. Since they have moved across the road it seems like the quality of the pizza is just not as good. When we open the box I’m disappointed in the appearance. I sure hope they can get a handle on this we love Godfathers pizza.
… moreJack Davis
Very tasty. Not the Godfather’s pizza from the past. Still good pizza, just isn’t anything substantial to differentiate it from all the other pizza places. Back in the day, their pizza was thickly covered in toppings and cheese.
… moreIsJERRYZ Kid
Godfathers pizza is the best. Granted o dont eat much, ima always able to find a dish fitted to m tummy size . Most good eateries recognize the fact that some are unable to order regular portion sizes and will let you order lighter fare not limited to. But including child’s fate. Iyd I’d worth asking. I veive the accommodation of entree size is better than them having to clean up what the stomschveasntva le to handle. So Ask!
… moreKelly Malanik
Very clean place, amazing people including the assistant manager and the nice lady who made my pizza. Keep it up!!
… moreKaye Easton
Love this place and love the people, food, knick knacks and everything about it. Was at Eddyville and very busy and yet the workers were very pleasant and efficient. Moved the line fast. Great job to all involved.
… moreCraig Schwartz
Only get your diesel there in a pinch. Still need to go inside to pay with comdata, diesel pumps on the car side only work half the time. And guess what. I smells like old cooking grease like the old one
… more