Jenna Marasco
I ordered a custom cookie cake for my fiancé and his brothers birthday. The guys gave me an idea, i sent it to the employees at GFY who responded with an extensive list of different flavors of frosting and different options for the cookie cake (i never knew there could be so many options.. but we love options) and when i went to pick it up, it was so perfect. The guys were happy and i never felt like i didn’t get my moneys worth. I picked up a couple of goodies while i was there as well because… why wouldn’t i want to try a giant cinnamon roll?! We’ll be back – and not just once a year for a custom cake!
… moreWanida
I cannot explain how pleased I am with this bakery! My sister is turning 30 this weekend, but I didn’t want to do a custom cake knowing it would cost $100+. So it was pretty much my fault for trying to find a cake the week of her birthday.
I was going through google to see which bakeries had cakes on display for sale. I went to a bakery on university ave and honestly right when I walked in all the cakes were tiny (I understand not everyone wants a 8in cake) and lack luster to say the least especially for the price. They also open on Wednesday, which left me only 4 days to get her cake.
I called Go Frost Yourself on Wednesday, Maggie assured me there would be cakes on display by Thursday. I CANNOT explain how cute the cake was! This was just a cake for display by the way, no special order, no requests. It was the cutest purple HEART cake with sparkles. Unfortunately this was only a 6in cake, but she reassured me there would be more cakes the next day.
I went back the next morning on Friday, once again just a cake for DISPLAY! And it was the most beautiful elegant cake perfect for a 30th birthday. Sorry Maggie for bothering you all week!
Staff is amazing, the cakes are beautiful, and the location is easy to find! Also, they save me from just getting a generic cake!
… moreElizabeth Lennon
Ordered a cake for a family special occasion. Juli was quick with communication and made sure my order was exactly what I was expecting! Pick up at the shop was smooth and the customer service was top notch. I even picked up some extra goodies for breakfast the next day 🙂 Trust me, the treats taste as good as they look on social media. Cake was moist and icing was not too sweet for my dad but sweet enough for my 4 year old. I’ve asked my husband to order again for my birthday!
This is a wonderful bakery that clearly cares for the community. Molli goes above and beyond to engage and support other local initiatives. Every time I walk in, there is a friendly face ready to make my day brighter. My family is so lucky to have them right down the road.
… moreEmily Pabis
I have been to GFY a few times and have never been anything less than ecstatic with what I got! Cinnamon rolls on Saturday to die for. Cupcakes incredible. Service unmatched. I have felt like I’m talking to a friend every time I have gone in no matter who is behind the counter!
Most recently I got a cake for my husband for Valentine’s Day and I just have to share a photo because not only was it delicious and beautiful but also HILARIOUS! Can’t recommend GFY enough!
… moreShannon Clare
I started going to Go Frost Yourself for a sweet treat and now I go for the sweet treats and the people. I always have to get whatever cake slices are out there, the scones are to die for and I rarely miss a cinnamon roll Saturday. Hands down the best bakery around and even better people inside the doors!
… moreStacy Ryan
Delicious raspberry cupcake. They are filled, loved that and the filling tastes homemade. Found an adorable smash cake for my granddaughters first birthday. Great experience.
… moreEsther Kwong
I cannot say enough good things about Go Frost Yourself. The owners take PRIDE in their quality and service. They go the extra mile to deliver something memorable! Molly designed and created a masterpiece cake for my brothers celebration of life. I described a complex cake idea and let her have creative license to design it. She created a cake in the shape of a bear head that was so real and detailed and impressive. It was a stunning cake masterpiece – the kind you see on competition shows. Not only was it beautiful – it also tasted amazing! Usually you don’t expect something so fancy to taste that good. This cake tasted as good as it looked. I am so grateful for all that Go Frost Yourself did to make our celebration more special. Ps- the pastry case does not disappoint- peanut butter cookies the best I’ve ever had. Scone nirvana as well.
… moreCourtney Cobb
Mollie and her team created our wedding cake and cupcakes – and wow what an unforgettable experience. The desserts were delicious and beautiful. GFY was dependable with delivery and communication. Guests raved about the cupcakes! Don’t sleep on this bakery!
… moreJen
We used GFY for our wedding in October and I wouldn’t have had it any other way! We did a variety of cupcakes for our guests (cookies and cream, marble and lemon) and a spice cake for us. Everything was DELICIOUS. Our guests raved about the cupcakes. The staff were wonderful to work with. They were prompt at answering emails and were always kind and informative when answering my hundreds of questions.
Since our wedding, we have stopped into the bakery to pick up some treats and of course everything we got (including the famous cinnamon roles) were fantastic.
Whether you are looking for a bakery for an event or just want one to stop into for a cookie or a cupcake, I highly recommend Go Frosy Yourself! Top notch baked goods and wonderful staff!
… moreAngela Reichschlager
The store was clean, bright, and offered many options. I chose a savory breakfast roll and 3 cupcakes. (red velvet, s’more, and peanut butter cup). The breakfast roll was so good, and HUGE. I am not a huge fan of cupcakes (or cake in general) however, the peanut butter cup cupcake and red velvet were good. next time, I’d love to try and OG roll, cookies, and focaccia. Without a doubt, I’ll be back.
… more