Joseph Lehman
My wife and I dropped in a day or two after the shop’s winter break. I had read about the Old World and needed to try it. We got one to go. Oil, vinegar, seeded roll. We drove that sandwich all over Cape May County and opened it two hours later. The fresh ingredients stood up to the test. Fantastic! Very high quality ingredients, expert prep/assembly, and friendly associates. I’ll be back for another taste for certain. That sandwich is probably hard to top, but the rest of the menu deserves my attention as well. Highest recommendation! See you again soon.
… moreFast Food
Fugetaboutit, this place is the real deal. Giovanni’s has the best sandwiches in Sea Isle City and beyond. The meats are top tier, the bread is always fresh and delicious, the portions are very filling and the service is very good. The roast beef is rare and tender as it should be. The prosciutto is melt in your mouth. The sharp provolone will cut your tongue, Yum! They have other great (Italian) food items in the store but my go to is the Hoagies. The “Old World”hoagie is to die for.
… moreKevin Johnson
Ordered the Diablo Italian Sub/Hoagie. Fresh Roll, nice amount of tasty meats, fresh veggies and they have cherry peppers to upon request.
My first visit. People were friendly, King Sandwich, so yummy. When you walk in the store the smells carry you to the counter. Fast service, clean store, nice people, excellent food. I will be back.
Thank you for a great experience.
… moreJim Reilly
They’re italian hoagie is the best you can get in Sea Isle. Roll is tremendous, ingredients really fresh. They are serious about their food.
… moreTom Sullivan
I didn’t particularly like the meatball Parmesan sub which influenced the 3 star rating. Other than that, it is a nice sandwich shop, Friendly staff, limited seating inside just a small counter top and two small tables outside but is very close to the beach so you can pick up a quick bite and picnic there! Just be prepared, is cash only.
… moreDaniel B.
Lots of choices in sea isle. Tons of pizza places and handful of delis. This place is great. Good quality food, fair prices. Nice staff. They are all very professional and I don’t feel rushed when ordering for a family.
Also a great selection of Cento products if are cooking!
… moreMeaghan Austin
Smells the best hoagie shop of ever walked into. Sweet and spicy all at once. The hoagie was sooo good I bought it two days in a row. They have a great selection of gift type items to select for like various house sauces. Soooo good. Don’t miss out this.
… moreDraven
The staff was all so nice! We got our food in record time and the attention to detail was incredible. All the ingredients were super fresh and the menu options are so authentic. It’s hard to find a deli with prosciutto in general but I’ve never had better than the kind they use here. It wasn’t stringy and melts in your mouth. I’ve been craving it since I first tried it. Highly recommend this place
… moreJaime Kuech
I am from Philly, but moved to Chester County as an adult, I’ve had a lot of issues finding an authentic Italian hoagie, this is the real deal, best Italian hoagie I’ve found in a very long time ❤️
… moreSam T
Really good hoagies. We ordered the turkey Diablo and italian diablo.
… more