Jamie
My mom and I each picked a sandwich and split them( Philly cheese steak and Italian sausage). They arrived pretty quickly and were incredibly delicious. Kind of heavy but I didn’t expect health food. Atmosphere was ok but definitely felt like a takeout space. Staff were super friendly and accommodating. Will definitely return, can’t wait to try the pizza!
… moremelissa luchini
Got bucket of chicken for pickup, it was delicious! Food was hot and flavor was great. Was best Broasted chicken have had in a long time. Whole family commented on how good it was. Will now be our go to place for chicken. Did online order and also liked how they text you when your food is ready.
… moreAndrew Thorpe
I have ordered from here a few times since they’re opening. And we both thought the pizza was good. The last time we ordered. We got extra cheese because we thought it was a little late on the previous order so, we thought well let’s get extra cheese and see how it is. Well the cheese was so thick that I don’t think the center of the pizza was actually cooked. But I’m not a foodie like my wife so I just truck through it and ate the pizza. Second thing is they send you a survey to take after being a customer and I responded to it twice and never got a response from the owner. We haven’t been back since.
Update 3/7/26: got a call from the owner and offered a free pizza. Had it last week and it was done perfectly. Thank you for making it right, I appreciate that.
… moreLexi Piper Winter
It was fine. Quite expensive for a pizza, but that may have been because my partner likes a ton of meat on his pizza. It was worth trying again.
… moreTrish Beier
We ordered a 12 inch S,M,O pizza, meatball sub and onion rings. Absolutely delicious! Diffently will be back.
… moreMarissa
Drove from Milwaukee to try this place. My husband had it many years ago and still talks about it to this day. The food prices are for tourists, but it is really good. The highlight though was Amber, incredible incredible service!
… moreRich Weinlein
Tastes the same as Poads Pizza. But in my opinion better. Gino’s is more generous with the toppings than Poads was. New owner is a very nice person. New design of restaurant is fantastic.
… moreBetty Breitkreutz
It was a great experience! I was able to order from the website before the store was open, and my food was hot and ready when I arrived at the time I requested it. The chicken and taters were very good!
… moreHeidi Kuechler
The pizza at Gino’s is sooo good. It has the most amazing crust and sauce and they definitely don’t hold back on the amount of toppings. My favorite, by far.
… moreLaura Scharpf
I miss the fennel in the sauce. Pizza was excellent
The crust was nice and thin.
The Fish Fry’s are always perfect. Gino’s is always good
I love the remodel clean and bright.
… more