David M. Dwight
January 11th, 2026
As an added treat, the Medic Unit #1201 Crew will stop in at one of the many Pizzerias in our service area…
Today’s journey was interrupted by a Call Dispatch, but during the response we got cancelled and not to tempt fate we stopped in at the Little Silver Gianni’s…
Sue had her usual Slice of Plain!!!
I also had a Plain Slice, but also ordered a Sausage & Green Pepper Slice…
My slices were delicious but there was a flop on both slices with a significant New York Flop of the Sausage & Peppers!!!
I have enjoyed slices at a number of the Gianni’s Locations and maybe today was just an Off Day.
All of the ingredients were as delicious as they could be, but a firmer crust would of enhanced the presentation..
I will always make another visit, since Pizza is Comfort Food that has healing powers…
… moreVAUGHN CASTLE
Ordered via Uber Eats chicken Fettuccine with garlic knots. The chicken fettuccine was overcooked and oily, and the garlic knots were stale, dry, and had more garlic in the aluminum tray than on the knots themselves. Definitely not homemade.
… moreEllen Bossinger
We ordered a whole chicken parm sandwich. The chicken was tough and dry and probably old. It had hard shreds of chicken and had to throw in garbage. Very little sauce on it and very salty also. Pizza wasn’t bad but was kind of just ordinary. Not good as nj pizza usually is. WS very disappointed.
… moreCristian Tepelt quintero
I ordered a plate of buffalo wings and fries and honestly, they’re nothing like they used to be. Now they’re greasy, like they’re made with lard
… moreedie jo conti
Delicious!! The pizza was warm and cheese was spectacular! One of the best pizza places I’ve ever been to. I ordered just a regular plain pie. It was so flavorful and textured.
I love their selection of sodas. I love the variety of them. Not just do the have coke a cola, but they also have cherry coke! I personally love cherry coke and can never find it anywhere. My soda was fresh and I could tell it was brand new.
When I walked up to the counter, I was immediately greeted by a very nice young man. It was a cold Thursday afternoon and he was very nice for have been working the whole day. He asked me what I wanted politely, and overall it came to my table quickly. The service was great! I was actually surprised! Every pizza place I’ve ever been to has had bad service not Gianni’s!
Thank you so much for the lovely experience!
… moreJay Gordon
I’ve never been so annoyed by a takeout order. I ordered two medium pies and a wrap and the bill came to 63 dollars. When I asked why, I was told I was being charged 3 dollars for Sausage and Pepporoni which totally makes sense but then I was getting charged 3 dollars for peppers and onions is REDICULOUS. The waitress taking my order had no issue telling me that the toppings cost more than the actual pizza! There’s a problem with peppers and onions costing 6 dollars on half of a pizza.
… moreJohn Doe
Quality has gone down since Covid happened (understandable, but it’s remained low, I believe its new owners in the last couple years). I’ve been ordering from Gianni’s for 26 years and I’ve been disappointed the last 2. Our order is wrong every other time, things are forgotten, and new front-of-store staff gives off a lack of care. I used to go straight there on half-days from Markham when I was a kid excited to get the best pizza in town, now I find it a struggle to order. I really hope they step back up.
… moreCorey Lunney
Gianni’s is always my go to when I’m in the area. Pizza is great (I request thin crust), but the wraps are seriously incredible. My go tos are the chicken vodka wrap and the cheese steak wrap. You won’t be disappointed with either! Owner truly cares about his business and will do anything to help fix if there’s a mistake. I’ll be a lifelong customer for sure.
… moreGG
my cousin and i ordered garlic knots and they were completely raw on the inside. they were fine on the outside but the inside was basically all dough. the prosciutto in our paninis seemed a little off as well. we called the restaurant to let them know about the garlic knots and the employees were laughing. originally when we picked up, they were very sweet but on the phone it was a different story. this is our first time ordering from this location but i probably won’t order from them again and stick with the oakhurst location that i usually order from.
… moreJay Cotte
It’s a good place to stop in on your lunch and grab a nice sandwich. I personally got a chicken cutlet with bacon. Bread was crispy, soft and fresh. And the guy’s behind the counter are great staff
… more