Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Casual American restaurant & sports bar dedicated to local baseball Hall of Famer Edward Plank.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 217 Steinwehr Ave, Gettysburg, PA 17325
Phone: (717) 334-1100
Website: http://gettysburgeddies.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Gettysburg Eddie’s: Takeout Home
Gettysburg Eddie’s is a Gettysburg restaurant that has something for everyone from burgers to a full dinner menu.
About Us/Menu – Gettysburg Eddie’s
Gettysburg Eddie’s is named after Edward Plank, a baseball player born in Gettysburg on August 31, 1875, and died in Gettysburg on February 24, 1926.
Gettysburg Eddie’s | Gettysburg PA – Facebook
✨NEW✨ Monday Dinner Special! $25 Prime Rib Dinner Garlic mashed potatoes | Veggies | Au jus | Horseradish $5 Chardonnay or Cabernet Every Monday ⏰ 4–9PM …
Reviews
Jodie Poirier
The food and service were both excellent. The chicken tacos are delicious but spicy with the blackened chicken. The shrimp alfredo was nice and creamy. The steak was very good, although a little overcooked, and the burger was also very good. It’s definitely one of the best restaurants we’ve eaten at here.
… moreIrene Hardesty
Eddie’s was an incredible new gem that we found through a friend if you have not experienced any Eddie’s you need to come out this wait staff is exceptional. The food was great. I had the shrimp tacos and my husband and friends enjoyed the wings and a pasta dish.
… moreCat Mascis
Dined here on a busy Sunday night. Parking lot was very difficult to find a spot for a pick up truck. Found 2 seats at the bar & ordered drinks to start. Bartender was friendly & informative. Seemed they were out of a lot of things on a Sunday night so that made it a little difficult to figure out what to order. I would up with a small side salad that was decent & the wings. My husband had a sandwich & we then shared the homemade peanut butter pie without whip cream. The dessert was excellent. Not a bad choice when in town!
… moreEric H
If you like baseball and elevated bar food, this is the place for you. As a baseball fan myself this was a must stop. They have specials, so make sure you listen to those. The English beef was a solid win and would absolutely get if I came again.
… moreJo Jo
Food was great and bartenders sam and Christian in the upstairs bar were friendly and fun and made us good drinks. We had fish tacos , some homemade kettle chips and a cheese steak with fries. I’ve been here several times and it’s good Everytime.
… moreRick Sussman
A cute little sandwich/burger/sub shop in downtown. Parking can be an issue, especially if you have a larger vehicle, but is around back. Decent subs, cute decor, friendly staff.
Edited on 9/9/25
My wife and I went here again, on a Wednesday, sort of spur of the moment. If anything, it was even better this time (our 2nd visit here). Great server, very helpful and pleasant
My wife got a hamburger and fries, and I got wings (1/2 price Wednesdays) and 2 kinds of dipping sauce, celery w/Bleu cheese dressing and fries. All very good, and too much to finish, so we brought some home.
… moreEdited on 9/9/25
My wife and I went here again, on a Wednesday, sort of spur of the moment. If anything, it was even better this time (our 2nd visit here). Great server, very helpful and pleasant
My wife got a hamburger and fries, and I got wings (1/2 price Wednesdays) and 2 kinds of dipping sauce, celery w/Bleu cheese dressing and fries. All very good, and too much to finish, so we brought some home.
Matthew Baker
Loved my club sandwich.Service was great and the wings and nachos I had were great.Highly reccomend.
… moreWilliam Merritt
Neat little bar and grill kind of place. Parking in the back with a door in between the buildings into the bar. Front entrance into the dining area. The blacked chicken was incredible, flavorful, and had just the right amount of spice/heat to make it perfect on tacos. The portions were great and the lettuce and other ingredients were fresh! The price was very affordable too.
… morePeter Lashinsky
We always save our appetite until we reach Gettysburg Eddies. The drinks are always cold and the food is delicious. The atmosphere makes everything even better
Also the prices are very fair for such a nice place right in the middle of town
… moreAlso the prices are very fair for such a nice place right in the middle of town
Hannah Brumbaugh
We got a takeout order, the House Hero and Chili were amazing! However, we also got the English roast beef and it was incredibly tough to bite through and cut. The shrimp chowder was thick and almost paste like, there was one shrimp in the bowl and the soup base tasted curdled (like it had been reheated multiple times). The fish sandwich was good and we liked the homemade chips. The bill was 136.00 total, with a 23.00 services and fees added when ordering online. Overall, I don’t think food quality met the price.
I will say the staff was incredibly kind and friendly when I went in to pick up. The inside was clean and really warm and welcoming.
… moreI will say the staff was incredibly kind and friendly when I went in to pick up. The inside was clean and really warm and welcoming.