Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Gerardo’s Pizza and Pasta permanently closes in Shirley
Gerardo’s Pizza and Pasta permanently closes in Shirley … Gerardo’s Pizza & Pasta has bid farewell to Shirley. The pizzeria, which was opened in …
Gerardo’s Pizza & Pasta – CLOSED, 800 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY …
Get more information for Gerardo’s Pizza & Pasta in Shirley, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Gerardo’s Pizza & Pasta | Shirley NY – Facebook
Gerardo’s Pizza & Pasta, Shirley. 582 likes · 53 were here. _. … 800 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY, United States, 11967-2122. Links.
Reviews
Kevin Breese
Delicious Pizza! We ordered delivery from them twice now and both pies were outstanding. No complaints! And for the record we are kinda finicky with our pizza too. I’m originally from Buffalo, where they have awesome pizza and wings, and I’ve also had a lot of Pizza in NYC too, which of course has the best pizza in the world. Considering that, and being almost 50, I’d say I have a lot of experience and know what good pizza is. 🙂 Only complaint is, both times we requested they text us when they delivered it, and both times they didn’t do it, so our Pizza was sitting out in the cold on our porch for 7-10 minutes each time. Surprisingly, at least it was still warm though, not hot, but warm. I guess because we are so close to them. Still giving them a 5-star rating, because mistakes happen, and hopefully they improve on that.
… moreGene Jordan
Went for pizza with the family while visiting the area. Tornado hit while picking up, the staff was kind calm and even finished cooking the pizza and knots! I can’t say enough about how good these people are! The pizza was delicious too!
… morenatasha Mcglynn
Slices were just…eh
Edible, ok, not great nor gross
Inside clean and re done
Staff very nice
Pricing about average
… moreEdible, ok, not great nor gross
Inside clean and re done
Staff very nice
Pricing about average
Henry Canizares
Not the best pizza ever but good
Meal type: …
… moreMeal type: …
Pete R.
Makes one of the better regular cheese pies in the area. It’s more on the thinner side but we prefer it that way anyway. Not too greasy and the size of the pie is large (unlike other stores who are drastically making their pies smaller lately). Garlic knots are very good but are also very small.
… moreKen Harasym
I cant say enough good things about this place! For starters, the owner is a stand up guy, very friendly and welcoming. I am a picky person when it comes to pizza and this place blew my mind away with how fresh the ingredients were and how tasty the pizza was. The actual place is super clean and modern. Favorite new spot to grab a slice, pasta or wings! Great to see a new small business flourish! Best of luck and I will be coming here very frequently for all my pizza, pasta and Italian needs!
… moreMichele Simon
After hearing and reading all the positive reviews we decided to give Gerardos Pizza a try. I ordered a veal parm. and spaghetti dinner w/(4) garlic knots and (2) slices of pizza. I received veal parm. with ziti w/(2) garlic knots and (2) slices of pizza. The sauce on the veal and ziti had a funny taste to it, garlic knots tasted like raw dough with not a hint of garlic flavor. Glad we ordered the pizza because that was good. Staff was very nice, Interior was clean. Disappointed but may go back just for a slice every now and then-:/
… moreMatthew Tuffy
I’m not from the area but was lucky to have stumbled on this spot. Pound for pound one of the best pies I’ve ever had. The sauce was very unique in flavor and they nailed the dough. Staff was cordial, speaking to me throughout the process of making my pie and were more than happy to accommodate my needs. Also highly recommend the garlic knots! Will most definitely make it a point to stop by again next time I’m in the area.
… moreFrancis Reynolds
We ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza. The pizza came to $26. I understand inflation and the prices of everything are more now. The pizza was lacking in toppings and was undercooked. We had maybe a chicken cutlet worth of chicken on the entire pizza and the bacon was almost non existent. There are other places in town that can execute a chicken bacon ranch pizza much better. I will give another shot though it was mediocre.
… morebob smith
I’ve been there twice now and consistently their pizza is very good. I’ve tried a few different types . the owner jerry is a wonderful man. The meatballs were very good. And the sausage and peppers were good as recommend this place
… more