Jennifer Hoff-Schillaci
Great little local pizza place. Pizzas were hot and fresh. It looked like a quiet night at the restaurant, but everything was clean and well kept.
We did end up with 1 wrong pizza – cheese instead of the pepperoni we ordered. But cheese pizza was good. I guess we should have made sure but we didn’t check the order until we got home with them.
… moreKenneth Preston
Just had an incredible experience at George’s Pizza! The pizza was absolutely delicious, with a perfect crust and fresh toppings that made every bite a delight. The ambiance was warm and inviting, but what truly stood out was the exceptional service! The staff was friendly, attentive, and went above and beyond to ensure we had a great time. If you’re craving some fantastic pizza paired with top-notch service, I highly recommend heading over to George’s Pizza! You won’t be disappointed!
… moreStacy S
Just a good old fashion pizza place…that you can add spam to your pizza!
… moreDragonbird Shawn
Great pizza! Love that they still have a place to let kids watch pizza being made!! We are from the Chicago area and it is pretty neat to be able to get decent pizza in such a randomn place!
… moreJeff Horstmann
I think George’s is losing their touch, my go to pizza was the house special over the years, but the past couple of times I’ve had it , its been burnt, and hasn’t tasted the same. Maybe depends on who’s cooking the pizza.
… moreJACE
Ordered a Greek Salad and a medium pepperoni with extra sauce…Pizza looked horrible, was BARELY warm and looked OLD. Greek Salad had WAY too much oil, TWO TINY pieces of cheese, one TINY chunk of onion (that looked OLD) and they SHOOK IT IN THE CONTAINER TO MIX IT, the seasoning was CAKED to any vegetable in it. DISGUSTING. OVER 30$!!! RE ORDERED THE SALAD WITH OIL AND SEASONING ON THE SIDE and it was beautiful looking! However, 5$ salad was OVER 10$ after DELIVERY!?
NOT WORTH YOUR TIME OR MONEY. I suggest instead of ordering over priced food that looks like it was dropped on the floor, kicked and then punched in the face, GO ELSEWHERE.
… moreBenjamin Fredericksen
We ordered a Margherita pizza, and it was bland. The sauce tasted like fat-free Chef Boyardee ravioli sauce, and the crust was so thin we found ourselves asking, “Did we just eat, or are we still thinking about eating?” Thankfully, I remembered my emergency floor banana in the car—it was more filling.
The server was robotic, treating us like machines. They dropped a water pitcher at our table and walked away, never once asking how our food was. The interaction was cold and devoid of any feeling.
The pizza took forever to arrive—so long, in fact, that we ended up asking for it to go because we didn’t want to spend another second in there.
The only highlight was the beautiful ceiling, clearly dating back to the early 1900s.
… moreLaurie Lewis
If you want really REALLY good pizza ..George’s Pizza is a slice of heaven. Relaxing/ chill environment. Grab a beer and try their cheese bread! So good! I have family who come across the country and have to stop in at George’s when they visit. The staff are always so nice and willing to accommodate any specific needs. I used to work there many many years ago. I loved it. Great memories.Great ..
… morePaula Kiser
We used to come to George’s all the time, hadn’t been for a while because of others saying it wasn’t the same. Boy were they right. Worst service I’ve had, and we eat out a bit. Server says she completely forgot about us…but purposely would not make eye contact so we could order. Pizza was okay.
… morePenny Skauge
Bacon cheeseburger pizza is my favorite here and it didn’t disappoint! Perfect and hit the spot. Always good to come back to my hometown and have the taste of nostalgia!
… more