ᗰคгรєlค ᗰ.
Gardner’s has been a family-owned staple for over 20 years, and even though we’ve lived in town for 4 years now, this was actually my first time dining inside. My husband and I decided to stop in and try something new after spotting a little flyer at the counter advertising their new breaded chicken breast sandwich.
Everything was made hot and fresh to order, which I really appreciated. The mozzarella sticks (served with marinara and ranch) were a great appetizer. I wasn’t a huge fan of the marinara on its own, but dipping them in the ranch definitely did the trick!
The chicken sandwich itself was good and came out nice and hot, though I found myself wishing for just a little more flavor by the end. Still solid overall. But honestly? The French fries completely stole the show. They tasted like fresh-cut potatoes with the perfect amount of seasoning and salt. Crispy, hot, and easily the highlight of the meal.
The vibe inside was cozy with sports memorabilia and jerseys hanging on the walls. While we were the only ones dining in for an early lunch, there was a steady flow of customers coming in to pick up to-go orders, which tells me this place is definitely a local favorite.
I’ve only had their pizza once before and still haven’t tried the wings, but after this visit, I’m looking forward to coming back and exploring more of the menu!
… moreKianna Eaton
Had to wait 30 mins past my pick up time. Spent 100 dollars of my hard earned money just to get inedible food, the two sandwiches adding to a total of 25 dollars had bottom buns that were harder than the hubs of hell, cheese that wasnt melted just burnt on the edges like plastic, we had to just take the meat off to eat and at that point it’s not a sandwich it’s a patty, the supreme pizza had like barely a few pieces of sausage but a heaping mound of onions, which tasted horrible and nothing like supreme more like a onion pizza, so for 100 dollars the only thing edible was French fries, and a small pepperoni pizza, this was inexcusable, the restaurant was empty besides one couple, they knew they were serving rock hard bun sandwiches and still proceeded to put them in the container and let me take them home to my family, and the extra 30 minutes I had to wait was more than enough time to perfect the order and make new buns instead of ruining my family’s lunch and wasting my hundred dollars.
This picture is me firmly smashing my fingers on the bread which as you can see isn’t bent in the least, wish I could add a video for you all to hear the rock hard knocking sound it makes when you tap it .
… moreThe Pizzaman
Found Garner’s via Google while traveling in town for business. I had pizza from someplace different the first three nights. Thinking back after a few weeks, I wish that it made a bigger impression on me. I remember thinking it was OK for hand tossed pizza, but to be honest, I can’t recall much about it. Ordered as a takeout. Pizza was still hot when I got back to the hotel.
… moreBrandon Lawson
I had the sweet chili wings and they were really good. My wife had the mild and she said they were good as well. We also had a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was very good also with its crispy crust. The only thing I would change is if they had a personal pan pizza for individual or kids. The staff was very pleasant and everything including the bathrooms were very clean.
… moreRick Yerby
So we are traveling and Morton is our stop for the evening. We were both wanting pizza so after searching the available places decided on Garner’s. Because of the lead time I chose to pick up the pizza. We ordered the flaming Buffalo chicken pizza, 6 boneless wings and an order of cheddar cheese balls. The cheese balls were hot and tasted good. The wings were very well cooked and also good. Pizza was thin, crispy and a good mix of toppings. Jalapeños are hot, sauce was tasty, overall a good pizza place that, if you don’t know the area, is a little bit out of the way.
… moreWilliam Maass
My favorite place in a 28 mile range to go for wings. They cook them the way you ask for them, A bit crispy for me. I tried one of their dessert pizzas for the first time as I love the ones from pizza ranch and the cherry one I ordered was just as good. Absolutely no complaints. I have been a customer for over 20 years. My french fries didn’t last the way home. In my tummy! Carryout.
… moreLindsay Barnett
Ordered delivery. Got the first pizza. Barely any sausage on the sausage pizza. Called to complain. Second pizza not any better. I can get a frozen pizza for less and get more sausage.
… moreLeanne Chambers
None of my residents have had Garners before, and they were all SOOOO happy with their food and experience.
… moreDJ Ell Ess
I only tried the wings. But they are exactly the way I like them. Not breaded and wet. Customer service was great as well. Today I had to edit this post because I tried the pizza. Lovely thin crust great ingredients well done
… moreUrracadan Williamson
Phoned in a take out order of a large Pizza. When I went to pick it up there were plenty of places to park, the store was clean, the staff was friendly and well trained. My pizza was up, boxed and ready. Got it home and it was prepared correctly and was immediately consumed. Thank you for the great experience!
… more