Nancy Rodriguez
TERRIBLE! ,called in a m.ball grinder, got there, not ready so like always rush, rush ,rush made the grinder mozzarella on grinder look like rubber, cheese not melted bread falling apart the min I picked up for a bite , then on top of it cold!!! I told the guy I called the order in why are we doing it now he said 2 sec it will be ready. Already was getting that look like is a crime to complain about your order. So I got a cold grinder w a long ruber mozzarella that was not melted! Grinder was nasty! won’t be going there no more $15 to the garbage!!!!
… moreShelby Lineweber
Absolutely incredible! Best in CT! (And NY!)
My favorite sandwich is chicken cutlets on their delicious sesame bread, topped with fresh mooz, sun-dried pepper (or tomato) arugula, pesto and balsamic glaze. The chicken cutlets are thin and perfect. The staff is wonderful. Don’t look further for a sandwich. As a bonus they’re huge and the prices can’t be beat.
… moreAaron Danenberg
Hands down, my favorite deli anywhere. Shelton location delivers the same great food as as the original Stratford location. Their grinder roles and sharp provolone make for a terrific roast beef sandwich. Never had anything from Gaetanos that I didn’t love!
… moreChristopher Rosario (BamBamBPT)
Gaetano’s Deli brings that Arthur Ave vibe right here without the Bronx trip. Guy, Vinny, and the crew run a top-notch operation. I always go for the Stratford and Main, but honestly, nothing on the menu disappoints. A real gem for anyone who appreciates quality and flavor.
… moreEddie Vendetti
This is the first time that I’ve been here, and let me tell you, the food is incredible, the staff is phenomenal, and the owner Guy, forgetaboutit, he the best. It feels like a real Arthur Ave. deli, and while you’re waiting for your order, they just keep feeding you, sharp cheese, different meats… I’m definitely looking forward to my next trip down, I live about 40-45 minutes away, and it 100% worth the trip. Thank you for the great experience!
… moreMatt zebroski
Good deli. Not the best in the state but very good. No coffee. It would be nice to at least have some coffee option. Maybe not an espresso machine but a nice strong coffee at a deli. Very good ingredients. Friendly service. Not cheap. 4 stars is very good! Just not what they boast to be. My sandwich was great. It would also be nice to have a larger menu available so you can make a choice before you get to the counter. It’s super small print. There is tons of room there to post a big menu board.
… moreRabbit C
I dont even know where to begin! What a wonderful staff, great food, great service. My son even made a few friends, I mean they treated him like a little king. Their ingredients are fresh and tasty! I absolutely adore this place.
… moreBrian Allen
The sandwiches and deli options at Gaetano’s are the best! This is the third year in a row that I’ve hosted my year-end employee appreciation luncheon ordering from Gaeatano’s and it’s always a hit! This year, many thanks to Carlos and team for putting together 20 delicious items!
… moreMadison F F
I’ve gotten this deli a couple times, I’m not sure what happened today but…
… moreCasto Mercado
It’s the BEST sandwich shop in Connecticut. 5 stars . Macaroni and potatoe salad was amazing. Why would anybody go else where. We need one in Deland Florida. Hint.
… more