Welcome to Frankie’s NY Pizza! At our local restaurant, you’ll find delicious food and exceptional service. Whether you’re in the neighborhood or just passing through, stop by for a hot, delectable slice.
Explore our mouthwatering selection of pies, starting with our classic cheese or build-your-own with your favorite toppings. We also offer a variety of specialty options like the Cheesesteak, Margherita, Jenny (Hawaiian), and Charlotte (Veggie) pizzas.
Our menu extends beyond pizza to include fresh salads, starters, calzones, burgers, pasta, desserts, and more. We have an excellent kid’s menu and provide catering services for your special occasions.
Join us for a delightful meal with your for a delightful meal with your family and friends.
Family-owned pizzeria with an array of classic pies & casual Italian dishes for dine-in & takeout.
Nicki Christian
We just recently moved to the area and are on the hunt for our new staple places. FRANKIE’S NY pizza is definitely our pizza place now!! This pizza is so Delicious, and truly has that homemade flavor. I don’t know if they make their own sauce but it sure does taste like they do. We got the Sicilian crust and it was fluffy and airy and the perfect amount of toppings. We also got their fried mushrooms and they were amazing with the homemade ranch sauce. They were not greasy. They were perfectly crunchy and a great size mushrooms. We will DEFINITELY be getting our pizzas from Frankie’s from now on. Thank you for amazing food!!!!
… moreJoseph Courtright
So good! This is the NY pizza you want. I got there a little early and waited in the parking lot until they opened. I travel across the Carolina’s and try out as many pizza places as I can and I really wanted to try out this place. They were nice and greeted me as soon as I came in. I apologized for getting them right when they opened and were still prepping. “Not a problem” they said and asked what they could get me. Two slices of cheese, crispy. They got right on it and had it ready quickly. It was great temperature, it looked awesome, and tasted great. The flavors were there. The cheese was perfect. The slices were huge as well. As I’m sitting here writing this a couple days later, I’m wishing I was in the area to get another couple slices. If you haven’t been here and you love pizza… what are you waiting for?
… morePeter Haight
NY Style Perfection: Jumbo Slices Done Right! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I am so thrilled that this location is under new ownership within the last year! In the past, I was pretty underwhelmed by both the service and the pizza, but the transformation has been incredible. It has officially hit the high bar set by the flagship Five Forks location.
The Highlights:
Authentic NY Style: These are true jumbo slices—perfectly foldable, great crust, and exactly what you want from a New York slice.
Massive Improvement: The quality and service have skyrocketed under the new owners. It is now consistently delicious and welcoming. Thank you for respecting the legacy of Frank Fatigati and his hard work in the Upstate pizza realm.
Price & Convenience: You get a ton of food for a great price. Plus, being able to walk in for a slice anytime makes it the ultimate neighborhood go-to.
Summary: Whether you’re a regular at their other locations or a local looking for a quick, top-tier lunch, this spot is now a must-visit. It’s easily some of the best pizza in the area! ️
… moreBodhi Schell
Awesome pizza! I use to throw pizza for very legitimate New York pizzerias. Today, I decided I was in the mood for a good slice, but Greenville is usually full of every kind of unauthentic pizza you can think of. I loved the pizza here. It was perfect. The staff were extremely friendly and polite. I don’t ever write bad reviews for anything, but I will write a good review when something or someone stands out. This place has great food and behind that food is good people.
… moreHunter Axtell
Frankie’s NY Pizza delivers an exceptional New York-style pizza experience in the heart of Simpsonville. I ordered the cheese pizza and the margarita, both of which were outstanding. The crust was perfectly crisp, the ingredients tasted fresh, and the flavors were well-balanced.
I also enjoyed an ice-cold Pepsi, which was surprisingly refreshing and complemented the meal perfectly. Beyond the food, the atmosphere truly stood out—it felt as if I had stepped into a classic New York pizzeria. The ambiance, from the decor to the energy of the space, was authentic and inviting.
For anyone in the Greenville area seeking high-quality NY-style pizza, Frankie’s is a must-visit. Highly recommended.
… moreThomas Calderon
Pizza was great I thought I was in bensonhurst Brooklyn having a slice again, I stumbled across this place while attending a seminar across the street. Best decision I ever made for lunch break and now I travel from Spartanburg whenever I’m in a good mood for pizza. True talk I haven’t found a better pizza place in South Carolina then Frankie’s and to top it off the only place I found that makes Zeppoles
… moreParesh Desai
We have been looking for delicious pizza in greenville, sc for more than 20 years now. Today we ordered the Charlotte Vegetarian Pizza from Frankie’s on the Parkeay in Greer and it’s hands down the VERY BEST pizza i’ve had anywhere in America over all these years. The best part of it is that we live 2 miles from Frankie’s. This is going to be our to go pizza joint forever now. Well done Trevor and team…you are doing an outstanding job.
… moreSteve Resto
Best Pizza one slice doesn’t do justice.. if pizza is good doesn’t need topping ill take a cheese please… oh make it a lrg pie
… morePhilip Marett
My wife and I was door dashing and came in to pick up an order.there was a little wait as they were really busy. The smell of the place got to me while I was waiting for the dash order and just had to order a pizza for our self. The staff was extremely friendly and I promised if my food was as good as it looked and smelled I’d be back again. I will be holding my promise cause my food was amazing.
… moreChris Edwards
We order from here every other week or so. Last night, my wife ordered pasta, salad, pizza, a whole spread. Everything was delicious. Always is. Delivery time was reasonable.
We usually get a meatball pizza to carry out. It’s always good too. Always light and not greasy.
If you choose to eat in, the seating is basic.
… more