Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2010 New Jersey Ave, Wildwood, NJ 08260
Website: https://five-girls.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Five Girls Sandwich Shops – Catering & Sandwich Shop
North Wildwood’s Sandwich Shop. Everything made fresh daily! Eat In or Take Out! Delivery by Door Dash.
Five Girls Sandwich Shop | North Wildwood NJ – Facebook
Five Girls Sandwich Shop, North Wildwood. 4099 likes · 245 were here. Available for Catering.
Five Girls Sandwich Shop – The Wildwoods, NJ
Five Girls Sandwich Shop. North Wildwood. Five Girls is founded on the premise of sometimes all you need in life is Good Food, Good Vibes and a Good Time!
Reviews
Carlos Salazar Jr.
I went to 5 Girls – The Sandwich Shop based on several recommendations from coworkers and passengers who said the food was amazing. Unfortunately, my experience didn’t live up to the hype.
I started with the chocolate milkshake, but it tasted more like plain milk with chocolate syrup. It lacked any real milkshake flavor or thickness.
The mini burgers (supposed to be five small patties) were okay in terms of the meat, but the bread tasted old—not fresh at all, which really took away from the meal.
Next were the cheese fries. The fries themselves were a good portion and tasted fine, but the cheese came in a small plastic container on the side instead of melted over the top like proper cheese fries. Charging an extra $2 for that was disappointing.
Lastly, I ordered a cheese steak hoagie. The meat was in big, chunky pieces instead of being sliced thin and cooked properly. The bread it came on also tasted old and not fresh.
Overall, I was really hoping for a better experience, especially after hearing so many good things. Sadly, I left disappointed. I hope the quality improves because the potential is there—it just wasn’t delivered this time.
… moreI started with the chocolate milkshake, but it tasted more like plain milk with chocolate syrup. It lacked any real milkshake flavor or thickness.
The mini burgers (supposed to be five small patties) were okay in terms of the meat, but the bread tasted old—not fresh at all, which really took away from the meal.
Next were the cheese fries. The fries themselves were a good portion and tasted fine, but the cheese came in a small plastic container on the side instead of melted over the top like proper cheese fries. Charging an extra $2 for that was disappointing.
Lastly, I ordered a cheese steak hoagie. The meat was in big, chunky pieces instead of being sliced thin and cooked properly. The bread it came on also tasted old and not fresh.
Overall, I was really hoping for a better experience, especially after hearing so many good things. Sadly, I left disappointed. I hope the quality improves because the potential is there—it just wasn’t delivered this time.
Repo
It was a great dining experience.
Having been in the food service industry for over 20 years they have hit a home run here.
Clean modern plenty of lighting.
The food is fresh so expect a few minute wait at times its worth it.
Everyone was happy polite and smiling.
… moreHaving been in the food service industry for over 20 years they have hit a home run here.
Clean modern plenty of lighting.
The food is fresh so expect a few minute wait at times its worth it.
Everyone was happy polite and smiling.
Lisa Vogel
My child wouldn’t eat the kids cheeseburger. It was a low quality burger and tasted awful. The regular cheeseburger was good and the crab cake was okay. French fries were delicious though.
No one greeted us or asked us if we wanted to order and we didn’t see a single employee until after I placed my order on the touchscreen several minutes after standing at the front counter. The store was completely empty, one employee came out from the kitchen to make a milkshake and said nothing to us. It was a very strange experience and extremely overpriced for the quality we won’t be returning.
… moreNo one greeted us or asked us if we wanted to order and we didn’t see a single employee until after I placed my order on the touchscreen several minutes after standing at the front counter. The store was completely empty, one employee came out from the kitchen to make a milkshake and said nothing to us. It was a very strange experience and extremely overpriced for the quality we won’t be returning.
kderoc
SECOND VISIT: Decided to give them a second chance and ordered the same meal as the first visit since the food was so good the first time. This time when placing our order we selected the food in the order we wanted to receive it. This time we ordered one order of fries first, then the sandwiches. This seemed to work this time. Also didn’t have to wait as long for the food, everything was out within a half hour. So for this visit I changed the Service rating from 2 to 5 Stars. The food was just as DELICIOUS as the first visit and the cheese steaks were definitely over stuffed. These steaks were HUGE. In fact, like the fries we are thinking about ordering one sandwich and splitting it between us. We will definitely be back for more before the end of summer. GREAT JOB GIRLS and GUYS you upped your game on this visit.
FIRST VISIT: The food was delicious even though one cheese steak was missing the cheese and the other was missing the mayo. When we arrived there was 4 other people ahead of us placing their order. So I do not understand why the food was so slow to come out. The drinks came right away which we almost finished before we got our sandwiches, and I was done eating my sandwich before our fries came out.
I liked to food, sandwiches were packed with meat so you are getting your monies worth there. And the dining area was clean and air conditioned. They just need to work on their timing and pay attention to the details.
… moreFIRST VISIT: The food was delicious even though one cheese steak was missing the cheese and the other was missing the mayo. When we arrived there was 4 other people ahead of us placing their order. So I do not understand why the food was so slow to come out. The drinks came right away which we almost finished before we got our sandwiches, and I was done eating my sandwich before our fries came out.
I liked to food, sandwiches were packed with meat so you are getting your monies worth there. And the dining area was clean and air conditioned. They just need to work on their timing and pay attention to the details.
Krista Tellerico
Went in at 8pm to an empty dining area. Ordered for my family of 5 but only got 2 of the 5 meals fairly quickly, then waited about ten mins to get the other meals except they never brought our two orders of fries or our mozzarella sticks. They finally brought the fries out when we were already done with our sandwiches! They didn’t bring the mozzarella sticks out until like 8:40pm!!
The table behind us didn’t even get their final person’s meal until their entire family was completely finished eating and THEN they come walking out with their order of fries!
Food was okay but definitely not worth ridiculous kitchen errors. Someone needs to retrain them on proper firing times for food back there.
The poor girl working alone in front was so fantastic and so very sweet though! I’m sure she catches a TON of slack because of the kitchen’s shortcomings.
… moreThe table behind us didn’t even get their final person’s meal until their entire family was completely finished eating and THEN they come walking out with their order of fries!
Food was okay but definitely not worth ridiculous kitchen errors. Someone needs to retrain them on proper firing times for food back there.
The poor girl working alone in front was so fantastic and so very sweet though! I’m sure she catches a TON of slack because of the kitchen’s shortcomings.
Kristi Hershey
The food was decent, but they made 2 out of the 3 cheesesteaks wrong and said that it was the way we ordered it, but it is not what was checked on the kiosk- our receipt shows differently. Also told the staff that we would not of ordered it this way because he is allergic to lettuce and she shrugged her shoulders. The staff was really rude, never fixed the mistakes- did minimal work so I would not pay the 15% gratuity or more when ordering- we made this mistake…. Milkshakes are milky and don’t taste like chocolate or vanilla. They come out looking good, but neither kiddo finished theirs. The store was clean, don’t park by the trash and outdoor storage room- they are rude if they need to get into those places. Disappointed and would not return. Five Guys over Five Girls for sure!
… moreKenzo
Recently had a turkey, roast beef and ham, hoagies, everyone said they were great! The free milkshake were great too! The service was excellent very friendly people. Will definitely order again.
… moreDylan Rauscher
Everything pictured was delicious just wish they would put more sauce in the cornbeef sandwich
… moreJim “The Cheesesteak Guy” Pappas
New spot in Wildwood. It was the last day of their month-long grand opening half price cheesesteaks and hoagies. 2021 version of a 1950’s soda shop. No cash. Everyone was getting their half priced cheesesteak so 45 minute wait. The cheesesteak had good components but i hope/think last day rush affected the care in making it.
… moreKenneth
Very nice experience for my party and I after a long day at the zoo and on the beach birding. We had a big appetite that we found an answer for here. My son-in-law and I devoured the big cheese steaks (that came with a free milk shake). In Central PA., where we are from, these cheese steaks would easily rate among the Top 3 best in the midstate. The rolls are fresh and you order through the touchpads so you can customize them as you like. The milk shakes here are better than those at any of the ice cream shops down here. All of the staff here are motivated and very friendly.
… more