Shannon Johnson
The fish boil was fantastic! Great flavor! The chicken was a little dry, both the white and dark meats. The food is served buffet style. Everything is all you can eat except the dessert. This is a cash only establishment, and they do have an atm on site. The host explained how the processed worked and was very welcoming. They do have a fully stocked bar for when you are waiting for your table. You are also able to go out and see where the cooking takes place. We will definitely be going back for more fish boul!
… moreKirk Bates
Excellent restaurant! I recommend the fish, chicken, and rib plate. The boiled cod is excellent and the BBQ chicken and ribs are spot on! Staff is friendly and took care of us the whole time we were there. This time of year we love to sit at one of the outside tables where we can watch the outdoor kettles while the fish is being cooked. We spent a little over 2 hours eating and visiting with friends. I highly recommend Fitzgeralds.
… moreEngel’s Daniel’s
I visited this restaurant with a friend, who told me that he has been coming to this place since his childhood.
He told me here I will eat the best fish, and I will have no complaints.
And the truth is that I loved it, the delicious fish, the very cozy place, plus the service of the staff and their attention make an excellent complement to the restaurant.
I loved it so much that I want to return, so if you visit Lake Geneva, make your stop here, so that this delicious fish debuts.
And still excellent price.
… moreEric
Great door county fish boil only a few miles into WI from IL. Fish cooked perfectly. Amazing flavor. Potatoes and onions were also excellent. Great dessert as well. Service very attentive. Fun place to experience!!
… moreDan Tyler
This restaurant is a gem. Unique house that has been fitted up as a restaurant. Excellent boiled fish bit the chicken and ribs are exceptional too.
Definitely worth a try. I will be back.
… moreScott Detienne
Delicious fish, chicken, and ribs. All you can eat in a historic octagon house. Great experience for a Wisconsin fish boil.
… morefood_from_the_usa
Welcome to supper club! All you can eat fish, chicken, ribs. The fish is cod, boiled old school along with ribs or chicken (grilled on charcoal). Side choices of coleslaw, boiled red potatoes, boiled onions. Can’t forget the brandy old fashion sweet! @food_from_the_usa
… moreJack Jostes
Classic Wisconsin fish boil! I have been coming to this place with my family for years. Great food, great service, fun place to spend time with your family. Go for all three: chicken, fish, and ribs. You will not be disappointed!
… moreGregg Szyp
Food tasted good, bartender and waitress were very nice and quick, good Old Fashioned. The issue was the cook. The cook(s) was or were too slow, often the buffet was out of food (ribs & chicken) resulting in a long line at the buffet waiting for the cook to prepare more food. We were there before and during the supper rush. This put the poor buffet server girl in an awkward situation, and interrupted the flow of service.
… moreJamie Lynn
Their Fish Boil is AH-MAZING! I had the fish & Chicken, best poor man’s lobster style cod I’ve had anywhere! The honey bbq chicken was good to but the cod was the star! Will definitely be back
… more