Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Our Menomonee Falls cafe is built in the historic Koehler-Zahn House. We worked very closely with our team of architects and builders to preserve the buildings unique character while adding modern features like a rooftop patio, community conference room, and open dining spaces.
Address and Contact Information
Address: N88 W16621, 1893 Appleton Ave, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051
Phone: (262) 252-9003
Website: https://www.fiddleheadscoffee.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menomonee Falls – Fiddleheads Coffee
Our Menomonee Falls café is an exciting blend of the old and the new. The building’s rustic historical details meld with our modern, colorful interior.
Fiddleheads Coffee
Fiddleheads Coffee Roasters is a Wisconsin-based coffee roastery, bakery, and set of cafes … Menomonee Falls Art · Thiensville Art · Wauwatosa Art.
Cafe menu – Fiddleheads Coffee
… Cafe Art · Cedarburg Art · Menomonee Falls Art · Thiensville Art · Wauwatosa Art · Fiddleheads Coffee Cups · About Us · Cafe Locations · Cafe menu · Cafe …
Reviews
Flower Blueberry
I’ve loved this coffee shop for years and it continues to be one of my favorite places to relax. The atmosphere and overall style are beautiful — it feels warm, inviting, and thoughtfully designed. It’s the kind of place you genuinely want to sit and stay awhile.
That said, I do hope the shop considers making plant-based milk options free of charge, as places like Starbucks and Colectivo Coffee have already done. It would make a big difference for customers who prefer or need non-dairy options and would feel like a thoughtful, modern update.
One small but important suggestion: adding protective pads under the chairs. When chairs are moved — especially by staff during busy times — the loud screeching against the floor can really interrupt the calm atmosphere. A simple fix like that would help preserve the peaceful experience that makes this place so special.
Overall, still a spot I truly enjoy — just a few updates away from being perfect.
… moreThat said, I do hope the shop considers making plant-based milk options free of charge, as places like Starbucks and Colectivo Coffee have already done. It would make a big difference for customers who prefer or need non-dairy options and would feel like a thoughtful, modern update.
One small but important suggestion: adding protective pads under the chairs. When chairs are moved — especially by staff during busy times — the loud screeching against the floor can really interrupt the calm atmosphere. A simple fix like that would help preserve the peaceful experience that makes this place so special.
Overall, still a spot I truly enjoy — just a few updates away from being perfect.
Evan Courtney
The environment and location of this coffee house are excellent. There’s plenty of seating with different arrangements, so it’s easy to find a spot whether you’re meeting a friend or settling in to get some work done. I also really appreciate the free water station—it’s a thoughtful touch. Overall, it’s a welcoming space with a great vibe, perfect for both social and productive visits.
… moreCiandria Francis
Stopped here to kill time before work. This was my first time in a fiddleheads cafe in general. All the employees here were so nice and friendly and seemed to recognize some regulars. My food was good. I got a sausage, egg and cheese breakfast sandwich in an English muffin and I swapped the cheese to cheddar. I also got an Apple oatmeal bar it was sooo good. I need to go back for another one. I will come back forsure if I have time before work.
… moreSooya xyooj
We came here in the morning for coffee which was great. I got the log cabin and didn’t even have to tweet it. Customer service and the atmosphere was great. I like the section rooms and space. The murals are beautiful.
… moremusic24Klm
Rich flavorful coffee, never too sweet in my opinion. Cute inside with some merch and little places to sit, outside and in. Love supporting local coffee shops and this is worth the extra bucks. Ginger spritzer is my favorite non coffee drink and this one is far better then starbs.
… moreCarol Pozos
Charming local coffee shop. It’s obviously very good based on how busy you was on a Friday morning. Baristas were cheerful, efficient and competent. The cinnamon roll was light and airy, perfectly sized with the perfect amount of sticky, gooey cinnamon filling. The latte was well crafted, not bitter, not overly sweet.
Being busy and having really cool brick walls made it very loud and slightly unpleasant. I’m not a fan of a lot of noise though. Interior decor was comfortable industrial. I love that.
… moreBeing busy and having really cool brick walls made it very loud and slightly unpleasant. I’m not a fan of a lot of noise though. Interior decor was comfortable industrial. I love that.
Dan Sinclair
Great atmosphere on a snowy Saturday morning for a cozy coffee and bakery visit with friends. I wish I lived closer because I’d be here all the time!
… moreAmir Rasouli
Also it’s a bit hidden, Fiddleheads Coffee offers a delightful coffee experience with its cozy ambiance and carefully crafted brews. The coffee is rich, full-bodied, and well-made, showing the baristas’ dedication to quality. The pastries and light bites are fresh and pair perfectly with the drinks. The atmosphere is relaxed, with warm decor and friendly staff, making it an ideal spot to unwind or work. Overall, Fiddleheads Coffee stands out for its inviting vibe and high-quality offerings.
… moreRyan Hoger
Stopped here on our way from Milwaukee to Appleton in search of a coffee shop that wasn’t a big chain. Right off the bat, the environment was nice. The place is nicely furnished and has plenty of seating (inside and outside) to accommodate larger groups.
I ordered a cold brew with Oat Milk, and while I could tell that the coffee was high quality, it was not as strong as cold brew coffee should be. Cold brew should always be brewed extra strong to compensate for the melting ice!
I also had a bacon/egg/cheese breakfast sandwich, which was great. The “zesty mayo” was on point, and the sandwich wasn’t too greasy or sloppy. Everyone in my group was happy with their food, but apparently they cannot do any modifications to the sandwiches, which is odd. When my friend asked for cheese on his sandwich, they said they could not add it.
Overall this place is a cool vibe, and a welcome change from the usual Starbucks/Dunkin chains, but has a few small areas for improvement.
… moreI ordered a cold brew with Oat Milk, and while I could tell that the coffee was high quality, it was not as strong as cold brew coffee should be. Cold brew should always be brewed extra strong to compensate for the melting ice!
I also had a bacon/egg/cheese breakfast sandwich, which was great. The “zesty mayo” was on point, and the sandwich wasn’t too greasy or sloppy. Everyone in my group was happy with their food, but apparently they cannot do any modifications to the sandwiches, which is odd. When my friend asked for cheese on his sandwich, they said they could not add it.
Overall this place is a cool vibe, and a welcome change from the usual Starbucks/Dunkin chains, but has a few small areas for improvement.
Scott W
Have been to a few of the Fiddlehead locations. This location is one of the best. It has lots of space. Easy to order with two counters. Plenty of space for seating, and the upper level seems to be the “quiet” zone. Friendly and efficient staff.
… more