4.7 – 113 reviews • Pizza restaurant
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Last Updates
Reviews
D Marie
We decided to stop at Fat Guy’s for lunch. A young man, name Benjamin, took our order quickly and efficiently. The pizza I ordered was very fresh, with tasty mushrooms and black olives. The crust was one of the best I’ve ever tasted. It was crispy and cooked well. The toppings were plenty, as well as the cheese. Thank you, Benjamin, for your terrific service!
… moreIsolation Overland
I was told to go here by a local while in the area on business and I am happy that I listened. I got the grilled chicken salad and a 3 topping small pizza. The salad was so good! All of the ingredients were fresh, crisp, and had plenty of flavor. It was more than enough to warrant saving the pizza for the following day. The pizza was much larger than I had anticipated. I was able to have a satisfying lunch, snack, and still had some slices to share with others. It was perfectly cooked, not soggy, and the toppings were full of flavor. The staff was friendly and helpful. I will definitely visit again if I am in the area.
… morelilbabybat
In a very rural area, this is one of the better pizza and sub places.
It does get busy and dine In is self service. But they do work with you
The pizza is really good.
… moreJames DiBattista
Cannot say enough about this place. Had their pizza and a Muffaletta. The pizza had a good amount of toppings. The dough was homemade, was airy on the inside, and had a great crispy crust on the outside. We had bacon and sausage on the pizza. The Muffaletta had a nice toasted bun with some quality meats on it, my favorite part of the sandwich was the homemade pepper mix they use. It had a slight bite with big flavor. It was good to see it’s a family owned business with the owner and his boys. Next time I will be trying a Stromboli they were huge. I saw them making a couple while we were there. They also said they have whole wings.
… moreStacey Valenta
Overall FANTASTIC experience this past weekend! Was visiting from out of town and ate there every chance we could! From pizza, hoagie (the muffuletta was AMAZING), Stromboli and salad… everything was absolutely amazing! They will even make pizzas that are not on the menu! Owner was very courteous and welcoming even while very busy! Can’t wait to go back!! Not only was the food was delicious… but the price was right also!
… moreBonnie Morehouse
Awesome pizza!!! the guys just swear alot in front of customers! Constantly dropping the F-bomb lol but overall I’ll continue buying their $43.00 for 2 large pizzas…. Not a bad price for great pizza
… moreTrent
Great pizza
The choice between thick and thin crust is awesome and the pepperoni tastes great. 10/10 we will be back.
… moreA Simon
I wanted a greasy, delicious pizza and Fat Guy’s met the mark. It was my first time, and I will be back. Ben (one of the owner’s sons) was kind, cordial, and delightful. The pizza was made quickly and they let us eat inside until they were closing. Would easily recommend to others!
… moreEdward Lance
Outstanding pizza. The crust is perfect, and the sauce is very tasty. They use good quality toppings as well. Small business, but very friendly. Getting popular fast (for good reason). They’re usually pretty busy. I left off rating the atmosphere as I’ve only ever gotten take out from them. Just called to place an order and got no answer. Voice recording said to try again in a few minutes as they’re probably busy, but to my surprise, within a minute, they called me back!
… moreWendy N.
We got a pepperoni and onion pizza. It was good but very salty. I believe it was the sauce. Dough is good, has a chewy thicker crust. Otherwise the menu looks great. Next try will be the buffalo pizza or the hogie.
… more … View more