Erik Tietz
Very small dining area that seemed to be an after thought. My pizza was okay, my 4 friends ordered a variety of other food that was judged between bad and okay. I wouldn’t try to drive people away, but there are better options around.
… moreTrina Mercado
Stopped in Siren WI for a family reunion had dinner at Fat Daddy’s pizza. Service was great and food was delicious, staff was very professional. Highly recommend stopping and tasting all their yummy food. Next time I’m in town I will be stopping to eat there again!
… moreLinda Whitehouse
The pizza at Fat Daddy’s is exceptional. Not only are their pizzas delicious, their oven baked sandwiches and the root beer floats are also. Service was great. If you are in the Siren WI area, it is a great place to stop and eat.
… moreJeremy Morton
Downgrading from 5 stars to 4.
I think the food here is awesome. The Philly cheese steaks are terrific, the only real problem is that they have been out of bread or meat all but one of the last 6 times we have ordered. The 1st time they were out of the large size bread, so we had the smaller one, the second time they were out of the right bread and put it on different bread, also a smaller size, but heck part of what makes a good Philly is the bread. The 3rd time, they had what we needed, the 4th time they were out of meat and bread, so we ended up ordering a pizza,, theh time out of the big bread, at least this time they piled on the meat, and the last time – on a day that the house special Philly was on special – we got there at opening time and they were out of any bread.
As I said, this place has great food, but I think they need to figure out their supply problem (make it in house, get a more reliable supplier, or something).
I want this place to stay in business, so I will give this place a couple more tries, but will throw in the towel if this keeps happening.
… moreJohn O’brien
Horrible service! Over a half hour late on my last two orders. First order was delicious, but forgot the drinks and second was a pathetic excuse for a pizza.
… moreCarmen Kraus
They have horrible hours. They’re only open a couple days a week for 4 hours or so. Saturdays they’re supposed to be open all day, but they don’t answer the phone. I don’t have a review for the food because they haven’t even made it possible for me to order any.
… moreJay Edgar
Any choice of any frozen pizza will enhance your dining experience ! Skip this place
At least the delivery person was was polite and cordial
… moreLisa Anderson
The pizza is excellent. They don’t skimp on the ingredients. There isn’t a pizza that I didn’t like on the menu
… moreDawn Wetterling
Love their pizza so good they have alot to choose from , all fresh , salads are perfect and so is desert num num num
… moreGillRigged
Tonight is the THIRD TIME in a row that they’ve screwed up our order. Been ordering here for years but now they don’t have it together. Probably our last time with these people.
… more