Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Modern, light-filled eatery with ample outdoor seating offering inventive Californian-style cuisine.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2701 Monroe St, Madison, WI 53711
Phone: (608) 416-5242
Website: http://everlymadison.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Everly | American Restaurant in Madison, WI
Everly is a modern, light-filled eatery with ample outdoor seating offering inventive Californian-style cuisine. Offering unique, unexpected plates of …
Everly (@eatateverly) · Madison, WI – Instagram
4.2K+ followers · 1.8K+ posts · A casual, comfortable, eclectic eatery on Monroe Street with a bright, friendly vibe.
Everly – Madison, WI – Tock
… Everly. Madison, WI · California-Style Cuisine · $$. Modern, light-filled eatery with ample outdoor seating offering inventive Californian-style cuisine …
Reviews
Al Bunshaft
Ate dinner here because there were good vegetarian options. That was true and the food was generally good.
We started with the fried artichoke which we found was okay. The sauce provided most of the flavor. I would not order this again.
For mains we had the salmon, the grain bowl and the Pozole Verde. The salmon was very good. The grain bowl was fine, but it’s mostly cold, not a hot meal, if you care about that. I loved the Pozole Verde. Beware that it’s kinda spicy. I thought it was great but others tasted it and found it too hot.
The service was fine until the end when the server took some of the plates away before everyone was finished which is a complaint of mine. Then she gave us the check, took the credit card and returned bill never clearing the dirty plates while we sat there and chatted. It’s fine to the clear the plates when we’re done.
Food was good and we’d go again. Place was clearing out and server was maybe in a rush.
… moreWe started with the fried artichoke which we found was okay. The sauce provided most of the flavor. I would not order this again.
For mains we had the salmon, the grain bowl and the Pozole Verde. The salmon was very good. The grain bowl was fine, but it’s mostly cold, not a hot meal, if you care about that. I loved the Pozole Verde. Beware that it’s kinda spicy. I thought it was great but others tasted it and found it too hot.
The service was fine until the end when the server took some of the plates away before everyone was finished which is a complaint of mine. Then she gave us the check, took the credit card and returned bill never clearing the dirty plates while we sat there and chatted. It’s fine to the clear the plates when we’re done.
Food was good and we’d go again. Place was clearing out and server was maybe in a rush.
Victoria Murphy
This place was fantastic! They had many clearly labeled vegan options. We went on a Sunday around brunch time and there was an hour long wait, so be mindful of that. This place is popular (for a reason) and relatively small inside. I would make a reservation when possible.
The parking lot is small and shared with out businesses, we got lucky by lurking and got a spot as someone left. But if it’s busy, expect street parking and a short walk.
Once we got in we were seated and waited on in a timely way. I got their vegan chorizo breakfast burrito. They were unfortunately out of their house made vegan chorizo but the waitstaff was able to sub in their tofu scramble instead for me. That and my hot chai latte were SO GOOD. The fingerling potatoes are something I’m STILL thinking about.
It’s a bit pricey here for me, but absolutely somewhere I’d go back to.
… moreThe parking lot is small and shared with out businesses, we got lucky by lurking and got a spot as someone left. But if it’s busy, expect street parking and a short walk.
Once we got in we were seated and waited on in a timely way. I got their vegan chorizo breakfast burrito. They were unfortunately out of their house made vegan chorizo but the waitstaff was able to sub in their tofu scramble instead for me. That and my hot chai latte were SO GOOD. The fingerling potatoes are something I’m STILL thinking about.
It’s a bit pricey here for me, but absolutely somewhere I’d go back to.
Steven Warren
Great food, huge portions of potatoes for each meal. We loved their chai chai chai latte. Come check this place out! They had a great gluten free menu with a dedicated gluten free fryer.
… moreNicole Clausen
Brunch was fantastic. We enjoyed the varied menu with lots of options for all our diet needs. The drink menu was extensive and there was a great atmosphere. Clean, bright, happy vibe. Definitely try it out!
… moreMariah Cunningham
I’ve been to Everly a few times before and have never had an experience like this, which is why I feel the need to share.
We waited about 40 minutes for our food, and when it arrived it was lukewarm to cold. I ordered the salmon, and it was difficult to cut through. I’ll be attaching photos, but the fish appeared raw in the middle and was cold, while the outside was warmer.
I asked the waitress whether the salmon was raw or cooked a certain way, and I was told it was cooked medium. Trusting that, I finished the meal and went on with my night.
However, once I got home, I was violently throwing up for hours. I had eaten multiple things that day, and the only food I became sick after was the salmon.
It’s been about 18 hours since I’ve eaten the Salmon and I am still violently vomiting, shaking, and my stomach has been cramping. I was told to go to urgent care but I’m holding off.
I’m very disappointed, especially because I’ve had good experiences here in the past. Serving fish that is undercooked and not properly heated is a serious food safety concern, and I hope this is addressed so it doesn’t happen to someone else.
… moreWe waited about 40 minutes for our food, and when it arrived it was lukewarm to cold. I ordered the salmon, and it was difficult to cut through. I’ll be attaching photos, but the fish appeared raw in the middle and was cold, while the outside was warmer.
I asked the waitress whether the salmon was raw or cooked a certain way, and I was told it was cooked medium. Trusting that, I finished the meal and went on with my night.
However, once I got home, I was violently throwing up for hours. I had eaten multiple things that day, and the only food I became sick after was the salmon.
It’s been about 18 hours since I’ve eaten the Salmon and I am still violently vomiting, shaking, and my stomach has been cramping. I was told to go to urgent care but I’m holding off.
I’m very disappointed, especially because I’ve had good experiences here in the past. Serving fish that is undercooked and not properly heated is a serious food safety concern, and I hope this is addressed so it doesn’t happen to someone else.
Faith F
This is a very cute restaurant with great food. The Parmesan truffle fires were delicious and I highly recommend. The fish tacos were also very delicious, I wish they had more sauce but that’s all I would change. They have a nice area outside for seating, which was perfect for the summer evening. I would definitely come back!
… moreKarla Bond
My team decided to celebrate the start of the cricket season at Everly. We made our reservation for 10 people and everything went smoothly.
We didn’t have to wait long to be seated. The table was big enough for everyone. I must say it was maybe a little too big to reach the foot bar lol.
Our server took care of us right away with drinks. Answered all our questions and was very helpful and cordial.
Drinks were fantastic! I had the About Bloody Thyme. So refreshing!!!
Food was served at a reasonable time and all dishes were served altogether so no one had to wait. Everyone enjoyed their meal. I had the Green Pozole and was very happy with my choice. I’ve never seen pozole this fancy.
We decided to skip desert and get our bills. I was very impressed and pleased to see we were allowed to pay separately. That is not always the case.
Bathrooms were cleaned, they have hooks available for coats and/or purses, the restaurant is beautifully decorated, the lights are amazing, both natural and artificial.
Overall, it was a great experience!!!
… moreWe didn’t have to wait long to be seated. The table was big enough for everyone. I must say it was maybe a little too big to reach the foot bar lol.
Our server took care of us right away with drinks. Answered all our questions and was very helpful and cordial.
Drinks were fantastic! I had the About Bloody Thyme. So refreshing!!!
Food was served at a reasonable time and all dishes were served altogether so no one had to wait. Everyone enjoyed their meal. I had the Green Pozole and was very happy with my choice. I’ve never seen pozole this fancy.
We decided to skip desert and get our bills. I was very impressed and pleased to see we were allowed to pay separately. That is not always the case.
Bathrooms were cleaned, they have hooks available for coats and/or purses, the restaurant is beautifully decorated, the lights are amazing, both natural and artificial.
Overall, it was a great experience!!!
Mr Taylor
Let’s start with the positive.
The truffle fries were very good.
Great flavor. I did make a reservation b/c I
figured that they will be busy. I arrived
20 min early and the female host with
dark wavy hair past her shoulders sat me.
The tall multiracial eccentric looking
gentleman, just seemed confused. Very
confused. I was slightly frustrated with
him, b/c he seemed so lost about his job
but the woman who sat us helped him out.
Thank God for her.
When we were sat, we waited for at least
10 min, we weren’t acknowledged by our
waitress with the beautifully red curly hair.
She was nice. But if I were to ever come
back I would never want to be waited on by
her again. We had to ask for refills of water
after I seen her look at our empty cups and
keep walking.
When I asked for straws she did bring them
in napkins but she placed them on the
table so fast they rolled out onto the table.
The chicken and waffles ..
The waffles taste like they were frozen and warmed up. They didn’t taste like they were freshly made – they were hard. The chicken, wasn’t that bad, the color of the batter was off it looked very light .. oddly light but the flavor was ok. Needed more seasoning.
The syrup was thinly placed on there. I wish the waitress would have asked,”do you need more syrup”?
The Sirloin Hash…
It was ok, it definitely needed tomato salsa or a light pico de gallo for people who don’t like a “runny egg” or a sunny egg. I asked her could they cook the egg a little longer – I just didn’t want it runny and it came back hard < sigh >. A little more meat wouldn’t hurt either.
At the end, she took at least 10 min to bring my change for the bill.
I’m like what is going on!?
The ambiance, the cleanliness, the polite female host, the truffle fries, barely brought my experience to 3 stars but here we are .
8/24/25 1:30pm
… moreThe truffle fries were very good.
Great flavor. I did make a reservation b/c I
figured that they will be busy. I arrived
20 min early and the female host with
dark wavy hair past her shoulders sat me.
The tall multiracial eccentric looking
gentleman, just seemed confused. Very
confused. I was slightly frustrated with
him, b/c he seemed so lost about his job
but the woman who sat us helped him out.
Thank God for her.
When we were sat, we waited for at least
10 min, we weren’t acknowledged by our
waitress with the beautifully red curly hair.
She was nice. But if I were to ever come
back I would never want to be waited on by
her again. We had to ask for refills of water
after I seen her look at our empty cups and
keep walking.
When I asked for straws she did bring them
in napkins but she placed them on the
table so fast they rolled out onto the table.
The chicken and waffles ..
The waffles taste like they were frozen and warmed up. They didn’t taste like they were freshly made – they were hard. The chicken, wasn’t that bad, the color of the batter was off it looked very light .. oddly light but the flavor was ok. Needed more seasoning.
The syrup was thinly placed on there. I wish the waitress would have asked,”do you need more syrup”?
The Sirloin Hash…
It was ok, it definitely needed tomato salsa or a light pico de gallo for people who don’t like a “runny egg” or a sunny egg. I asked her could they cook the egg a little longer – I just didn’t want it runny and it came back hard < sigh >. A little more meat wouldn’t hurt either.
At the end, she took at least 10 min to bring my change for the bill.
I’m like what is going on!?
The ambiance, the cleanliness, the polite female host, the truffle fries, barely brought my experience to 3 stars but here we are .
8/24/25 1:30pm
Paul Herford
Been here about 3 times now, and always a great experience 🙂 cocktails are delicious, service is usually prompt, and food is wonderful. My ONE note is more for vegetarians in that the tofu isn’t the best seasoned/prepared. THAT said, it’s usually an additive for a salad that doesn’t need it as they are quality dishes by themselves. My parents who are extremely picky eaters loved it. Easy endorsement and ready for the next visit 🙂
… moreGina Jacobson
Everly’s dishes never disappoint! I ordered the shrimp fettuccine, and my boyfriend had the Valentine’s Day seafood risotto special. Both were outstanding! And for anyone hesitant about beets, the seafood risotto was beautifully balanced and absolutely delicious.
We did have a small hiccup at the start of our visit. When we arrived for our Sunday reservation, there wasn’t a table immediately available. The hostess seemed a bit overwhelmed but was kind and did her best to accommodate us by offering seats at the bar while we waited. We appreciated that effort.
While seated at the bar, we weren’t greeted right away and didn’t receive water until I asked. After about 15 minutes, we were brought to our table. Once seated, our server T was wonderful and made the rest of the evening very enjoyable.
Overall, we love Everly and will absolutely be back. The butternut squash and forbidden rice curry remains one of my all-time favorites! I’m confident this was just an off moment during what is usually a consistently great experience.
… moreWe did have a small hiccup at the start of our visit. When we arrived for our Sunday reservation, there wasn’t a table immediately available. The hostess seemed a bit overwhelmed but was kind and did her best to accommodate us by offering seats at the bar while we waited. We appreciated that effort.
While seated at the bar, we weren’t greeted right away and didn’t receive water until I asked. After about 15 minutes, we were brought to our table. Once seated, our server T was wonderful and made the rest of the evening very enjoyable.
Overall, we love Everly and will absolutely be back. The butternut squash and forbidden rice curry remains one of my all-time favorites! I’m confident this was just an off moment during what is usually a consistently great experience.