Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 360 Enterprise Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551
Phone: (262) 914-9198
Website: http://elsiemaes.com/
Related Web Results
Elsie Mae’s Sweet Shop: Home
Handcrafted Pies. Small-Batch Sweets. Legendary Flavor. … Award-winning pies, bakery treats, and cocktails rooted in Wisconsin tradition — made from scratch and …
Elsie Mae’s Sweet Shop | Lake Mills WI – Facebook
Forget the math… just eat the pie. PI DAY AT ELSIE MAE’S THE 3 • 1 • 4 BOX — $50 3 Jams 1 Bacon S’mores Nutty Buddy Pie 4 Mini Sweet or Savory Pies Friday – …
Order Online – Elsie Mae’s Sweet Shop
… 360 Enterprise Dr. Lake Mills, WI 53551-1780. +100 miles. Store info. Elsie Mae Pies & Pints. 6521 120th Ave. Kenosha, WI 53142-7309. +100 miles. Store info.
Reviews
Theo
This is my 3rd year getting pies from Elsie Mae’s for Thanksgiving. I ordered 3 pies this year & one of them was a Carmel Apple. My wife went to pick them up this afternoon at our scheduled 1pm time. She called me from there saying they made a mistake & did not have a Carmel Apple for us but could do an Apple. She doesn’t like to cause a fuss so she took the pie. I emailed Elsie Mae’s because I feel like paying the amount you do for these pies, you should get what you ordered. They quickly responded apologizing for the error and told me to keep the regular apple & they would deliver me the Carmel Apple as well this evening prior to Thanksgiving. I live about 20 minutes south of Kenosha. I received my pie this evening like they said. That is fantastic customer service & they definitely earned a lifelong customer. I really truly appreciate it! My little brother really wanted the Carmel Apple. We’ll be back for Xmas pies
… moreJana Boswell
Had a pizza pot pie, cornbread Italian sausage pie, cherry and blueberry pies, and some sourdough feta bread. Everything was amazing!
… moreDl Fuller
I purchased a maple cranberry apple pie this week I will not buy another . Five people sampled it. We threw out the remaing thing of it . It was very small in diameter, not a typo cal 9″ pie. The filling was shallow. People did not enjoy the flavor. $25.00. not recommended.
… moreAnnaliza Rios
I first tried their pies at the Park Ridge farmers market in Illinois, and loved it!!! I love that they have so many options and flavors to choose from! If you’re thinking about wanting something sweet and tasty I would definitely recommend Elsie Mae’s!!
… moreSarah
Sad to see they are temp closed. The donuts were good when we could get them on the weekends. Usually sell out quickly, which is understandable. Smaller place but a good variety of items. We liked everything we tried, enjoyed having the small pie options to try a variety of them. Didn’t try any mixes or other store offerings. If the location was more central to the downtown, I think they would do way more business and be more known, the location is hidden within an industrial park.
… moreCindy Brady
Oh, my! A quick Google search brought me to Elsie Mae’s doors. Great luck! The Wisconsin berry turnover was flaky and delicious—so clearly home-made goodness. The soda bread was amazing. There is nothing quite like exceptional quality bakery. I have no doubt all the items are wonderful. I’ll need to return.
… moreBari Schwartz
We organized an Elsie Mae Pie fundraiser for our school right before Thanksgiving, which, as you can imagine, is a hectic time and quite a challenge to manage a school full of orders. We encountered a few bumps along the way, but Paul truly went the extra mile to ensure the fundraiser was a huge success! He was fantastic to work with and an all-around wonderful person! The feedback from our school community has been overwhelmingly positive, with everyone raving about how delicious the pies are! Thank you for bringing such a delightful treat to our holiday celebrations!
… moreMike
The store is very neat and clean with a nice area with high top tables and chairs. There is a coffee maker and carafe! The coffee tasted good. They also have hot water for tea, so you can sit down and enjoy your pastry.
They have wonderful pies, but they are somewhat expensive, IMO. I purchased a loaf of cinnamon raisin bread, which is very good.
… moreThey have wonderful pies, but they are somewhat expensive, IMO. I purchased a loaf of cinnamon raisin bread, which is very good.
Katie McNeely
The guests at my wedding LOVED the pies from Elsie Mae’s! So much that we had no leftovers! That never happens with wedding desserts! Haha. Highly recommend if you’re looking for an alternative to traditional cake.
… moreLaura Peterson
My boyfriend surprised me with this bakery on a rainy Sunday. We bought day old donuts, which were really good & packed full of flavor. Picked up a few pot pies to try also. Cute shop inside and out. Def. worth a stop!
… more