Colin Piaskowski (HTA Colin)
Crazy fluffy crust on the pizza. Brother sister operation and owned and operated since the 80s. Shrimp, sausage, onion was fantastic. Jalapeno poppers were priced right, cooked well and tasted great. Drinks are made with canned soda. Will definitely be back. Edit took home pizza and used air fryer to heat up and the crust was still light fluffy like it was the day before.
… moreMatthew Mikolainis
My kids and I ate here after swimming in the quarry across the street years ago and the pizza was fantastic back then.
Today I had a double bacon cheeseburger with fries and it was the best burger I have had in a while.
The place is exactly what I needed with great people and atmosphere and top quality food.
Don’t let the exterior appearance fool you, this place is awesome.
… moreJacob Church
Table of 8 ordered 2 large pizzas, 2 appetizers and a few sandwiches. appetizers didn’t come until an hour and a half later and not even all of them came. The BLT sandwich that was ordered came with cold bacon and wasn’t given the sides that were ordered with it. the pizza we got had a half cooked stale crust that was a weird saltine cracker texture that had sat for 2 days. The other appetizer we ordered didn’t come until we were about to leave. We understood that trying to wait on lots of tables can be difficult but we had no communication to us until we were leaving that they were understaffed which made us feel like they didn’t care. atmosphere is nice but overall poor service and food. I would recommend this place if you are just driving through town for a quick stop but service may keep you for the night
… moreMitchell Kulis
I don’t have to tell you that Elmer’s has been an area staple for a long time. I’ve been going here for 36 years. This place never disappoints. If a classic pizza and a brew is what you need stop by this old time bar.
… moreTerri Dopp-Paukstat
Haven’t been here in quite some time, and honestly can’t figure out why. The pizza is as good as ever. Love the crust, as well as the sausage and sauce. It is just so good.
The tap beer is cold and the service is friendly. Just can’t ask for more. And everything is reasonably priced. You really should check it out if you’ve never been here. And make sure to go back if it’s been awhile.
… moreMatthew Munson
It’s an old bar in a small town about an hr from where we live. We make the drive now and then just for the pizza and deep fried mushrooms. The pizza is awesome, the pepperoni is the bomb!
… moreAshley Altman
Absolutely soo soo good food! The deep fried mushrooms were the best I’ve ever had. If you like them, you gotta try them HERE! My boyfriend and my niece went up to B R Diner after swimming and got kicked out by a very rude server because my niece didn’t have a shirt, so we went to Elmers, and I’m so glad we did! Definitely was meant to be! Friendly staff, great service. Was all around pleased here. Trust me, go here instead.
… moreAlan Rupnick
I travel from Ripon just to enjoy their pizza. I have always received great service and great food. If you are passing through the area I recommend you give it a try.
… moreAngela Lang
We’ve been coming here about every month for a year and a half, love it. No weak drinks here!!!
… moreKatrina DeRosier
Stopped at Elmers for a pizza on our way home from vacation. The crust was absolutely delicious, thin and crispy! We got pepperoni and it had a nice smoked flavor, they weren’t your ordinary pepperoni. The sauce was delicious!! The bartender was so nice and chatty and informed us that they roll out their dough and it’s not frozen dough. As we were waiting, there were multiple people coming in to eat pizza and picking up pizza to go. I definitely know why!! Definitely recommend the pizza and while waiting have a drink and the bar!!
… more