Troy McGahuey
Small town restaurant. Dim lit with multiple drinks available except for draft beer. Ordered a cheeseburger pizza and was pretty good, I liked the crispy crust. Plenty of toppings. Veggies were warmed but not cooked which I loved because it leaves them crispy. Never had ketchup on one before but it wasn’t bad. Seating was a little tight for a group of 4 but we managed. Service was good as well. They had one unisex bathroom which was a little odd but it worked. I’d love to go back and try another pizza flavor. Overall, definitely worth a visit. It’s on the main town square so easy to find.
… moreDenise Belt
We were staying at Pine Lake State Park, and friends recommended we get pizza! Also, the history of the building, being a Carnegie Library, made it all the more to add to our adventure.
… moreBret Heiden
Great unexpected place in a small town. Good Italian menu with great choices. Staff was very friendly and attentive. Food selection includes sandwiches, pasta dishes, and homemade pizzas.
… moreNoelle Sullivan
Delicious food here. After visiting a few Italian restaurants and finding disappointment with bland dishes, THIS place was a wonderful surprise with well seasoned dishes. I had the margarita pizza and my husband had the ziti. Both were good and he finished his plate.
… moreDanielle Adams
MUST stop!!! We have ordered many pizzas and they are cooked to perfection. The service is always friendly and welcoming.
… moreKait
The food, drinks and service were really good. The building is beyond neat, they really missed the mark on decor/atmosphere though. The room we were in had a florescent light, was clearly part storage and must not have vents that work…there was a space heater on near the table. The wrinkled, finger printed paper food menus were out of place as well. They’re trying to be ‘high-end’, which for Eldora/Hardin County, it is compared to other restaurants. There is SO much potential for decor and atmosphere improvements.
… moreDaniel Adams
A great reuse of the public library! Right on the square! Good food, fine art to view or purchase! Definitely a place to stop at if you are traveling or camping at the Pine Lake State Park!
… moreKaitlyn
Meatball sub is my go to. Hubby loves the pizza! Great staff as well
… moreChad Carpenter
The pizza was outstanding. The drinks were very good. The ambiance was very unique with great service highly recommend
… moreLance Thornton
I was impressed with the service and atmosphere of a small town restaurant.
The food was not at par with the service and for the price.
They state artisan pizza, but it doesn’t taste even close or look like an artisan dough pizza. There was no char or bubbled crust. I understand there are lots of variations of “artisan pizza,” but this missed the mark.
The price for a pizza and 6 beers with tip was $70.
I may return for the service, but not the food.
… more