Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Fajitas, enchiladas & other Mexican dishes pair with margaritas in a festive space with wood booths.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 140 Perry Rd, Plainfield, IN 46168
Phone: (317) 838-9425
Website: https://www.elpotrobarngrill.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
El Potro Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill – Plainfield, IN
140 Perry Road, Plainfield, IN 46168 Horse and horseshoe Catering El Potro Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill would be honored to provide our services for your …
El Potro Bar & Grill Mexican Restaurant | Plainfield IN – Facebook
El Potro Bar & Grill Mexican Restaurant, Plainfield. 755 likes · 3 talking about this · 2879 were here. Mexican Restaurant.
El Potro Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill – CLOSED, 140 N Perry Rd …
Get more information for El Potro Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill in Plainfield, IN. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
John Pringle
I visited today and ordered their Margarona. The menu shows it with a full Corona, but what I received was a smaller Coronita instead. That’s a noticeable difference in both size and alcohol content, yet nowhere was it explained that smaller drinks come with smaller bottles. This feels misleading, especially since the main draw of the drink is the Corona itself.
On top of that, the presentation wasn’t consistent with the menu image. Instead of a clean, frozen margarita with the bottle inverted, I got a clip holding the bottle and a floating rubber duck. More gimmicky than the sleek drink advertised.
Another thing to note: the Google menu shows prices like $4.99 entrées and $6.49 lunch specials, which are clearly outdated and not what you’ll pay in 2025. That can be confusing for new customers who expect those deals.
Overall, the food and drinks may be fine, but the way things are advertised versus what you actually get leaves the wrong impression. Transparency would go a long way — list whether it’s a Coronita or Corona, and update the online menu to reflect real prices.
… moreOn top of that, the presentation wasn’t consistent with the menu image. Instead of a clean, frozen margarita with the bottle inverted, I got a clip holding the bottle and a floating rubber duck. More gimmicky than the sleek drink advertised.
Another thing to note: the Google menu shows prices like $4.99 entrées and $6.49 lunch specials, which are clearly outdated and not what you’ll pay in 2025. That can be confusing for new customers who expect those deals.
Overall, the food and drinks may be fine, but the way things are advertised versus what you actually get leaves the wrong impression. Transparency would go a long way — list whether it’s a Coronita or Corona, and update the online menu to reflect real prices.
Robert Trevino
Great food! The tortilla chips taste fresh but could use some salt. The rest of the meal, fantastic. Good portions for what you pay, tastes fresh and well seasoned, wholesome flavors that aren’t over empowering. The staff were friendly and on top of making sure everyone was well served.
… moreJacob Walker
Layers of flavor!!! Horchata is on point! Queso isn’t bitter! I ordered Texas fajitas!
… moreShay Ann
My new favorite restaurant! ❤ Excellent food at a great price! I had Nachos Carbon, which was grilled marinated steak, chicken, & *large* shrimp, lettuce, cheese sauce, sour cream & guacamole on nacho chips – for $12.00! GREAT PRICE! Free chips & salsa. Good service. I highly recommend this restaurant!
… moreSharon cress
You gotta love a place that has a rubber ducky swimming in your margarita. Fast service, great fish tacos and margaritas.
… moreRyan Fitzpatrick
I love this place. Anytime I’m in Plainfield I make it a point to stop and eat here. Definitely the best Mexican food in Indiana and rivals the best I’ve ever had. Great atmosphere, service and the food is amazing.
… moreSandra S.
Drinks here are great. I can’t say the same for the food. Maybe it’s what I had. I ordered the chicken taco salad and the chicken was boiled and shredded with no seasonings. It didn’t have any beans and the lettuce was stale. I sent it back and ordered a steak taco with flour tortilla and that is all it was. Nothing but steak and flour tortilla. It’s been a while since I have been here but I would not be back.
… moreMike Cheeze
I always get carryout so can’t attest to the dine-in experience. I always get the burrito Indiana with a side of beans and rice and it always tastes great with nice portions. The burrito is pretty massive and the total comes out to just over $21 but it can be made into to small(ish) meals. I just wish there was more than 2 people who can do the military discount.
… moreSharon Cress
After driving all day, we found this place not far from our hotel. The margaritas were fabulous, and my fish tacos were delicious. My husband enjoyed his fajita quesadilla. The service was very fast and friendly. Next time we are in the area, we will definitely visit again.
… moreMichael Sizemore
Don’t bother. Terrible food quality and even worse drinks. The steak was just a plate of fat, the beans were watery, and the margaritas were a total fail. Our entire group left disappointed and hungry. Definitely not worth it.
… more